The beginning of Ecclesiastes 5, Qoheleth presents the correct behavior in worshiping God, but warns against the vanity that can lie within. Ecc. 5:1 states, “to draw near to listen is better than the sacrifice offered by fools; for they do not know how to keep from doing evil”, this, along with 5:2, “Never be rash with your mouth, nor let your heart be quick to utter a word before God” illustrate how quickly worship can turn impertinent. Reverence must be pure, or else you are just listening to yourself talk, which is vanity. Qoheleth goes on to say “God is in heaven, and you on earth”, showing that God is above man, he is the supreme power, and we cannot fool him with meaningless words. This idea is confirmed in 5:8-9, Qoheleth discusses how to act when we observe the “oppression of the poor and the violation of justice and right”. He tells us “do not be amazed” or in essence, not to worry when we experience this, for there is always someone in a higher position watching over. God is not just some idle bystander; he will come to judge the oppressors and the violators. I feel as though you would have to have an abundance of faith to watch this happening and believe that a just God is allowing it and will bring the wrongdoers into judgment some day though.
In Ecc. 5:18-20 Qoheleth is saying again how eating, drinking and finding enjoyment in all the toil is what is good and how we should be continuing the days we have on this earth. The last line of the chapter is my favorite though, 5:20 states “For they will scarcely brood over the days of their lives, because God keeps them occupied with the joy of their hearts”. I cannot imagine anyone reading this line in a depressing light. If we can realize that God has given us worth beyond that of the gains from toiling under the sun, then nothing in life is “meaningless” at all, in fact all of our toil has more value then we could ever imagine. I find all of chapter 5 to be the most uplifting section of Ecclesiastes we have analyzed so far.
In the song “Casimir Pulaski Day” by Sufjan Stevens ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9EzeW5KoPUI ) it is obvious that he is singing about the decay of someone close to him, and his internal conflict with why God would allow this to happen. In the line “All the glory that the Lord has made and the complications you could do without” I believe we can hear a somewhat sarcastic approach by mentioning the glory of the lord, and this obvious terrible mistake he has made by giving this ill human all of these obstacles that were not necessary. In the last two verses of this song, the singer addresses his own interactions with God, I think he doesn’t understand why God let this happened and is most likely really hurt and confused. I can see how this song ties into this weeks’ reading though, you must have faith in a just God that knows best and will be fair in the end.
I'm glad that another person thought that Qoheleth was referring to God when he talked about someone in a higher position watching over. This would explain why Qoheleth seems to not feel like he can do anything about the suffering. However, in Brown's commentary, he seems to think that Qoheleth is referring to the role of a just king. Brown's interpretation frustrated me because Qoheleth leads us to believe he is Solomon, which should have been a king that was powerful enough to restore some justice. If you have no idea what I am referring to, see Brown pg.59.
ReplyDeleteI think you're right in acknowledging the "abundance of faith" that Qoheleth seems to have. I think that fact alone is why it makes sense to take positive feelings from reading the book of eccleseastes...I think this section in particular illuminates the audacity of the man who thinks he has any real power, and the sagacity of the man who in faith embraces the triviality of his place in the universe.
ReplyDeleteI think you're right about the song having a bit of a sarcastic tone. I think when he sings "All the glory that the Lord has made" he's voicing perhaps a struggle with God. This possible struggle seems to relate quite well with Qohelet's questioning of our purpose.
ReplyDeleteI'm wondering where you got the impression that Qoheleth's G-d is just and would bring judgment? I read the passage as tying back in to Qoheleth's earlier assessments about the cyclical/repetitive nature of things (there has always been and will always be oppression and injustice, so why let it bother you). Just wondering where you were seeing that in the text.
ReplyDelete