During the movie “Up in the Air” which casts George Clooney as the protagonist Ryan Bingham, we are entered into a world of airline travel and isolation. Ryan Bingham’s job is to travel around to other companies and fire employees for bosses who are too pansy to do it themselves. It sounds like horrible work, never being home, traveling in crowed airports all the time, but Bingham loves it. He discusses how he couldn’t imagine living any other way, here in the sky is where he calls home. Bingham’s whole life is about efficiency and he proves himself to be very efficient by using the fastest car rental place, by swiping his elite status cards at every checkpoint and being able to cram his whole existence in to one carry-on suitcase. He runs away from family and from any type of human connection because he doesn’t know why he should care. His life is shifted when he meets Alex, a women who lives or so he thinks a very similar lifestyle to him and then again when he is asked to work with Natalie the new up-in-coming associate in his office. His world of isolation is shifted into a world of companionship and connection. He attends his sister’s wedding with Alex and realizes that he likes having her around. Suddenly he has the backbone for the first time in his life to step up and be there to support his sister. He even saves the day when her fiancé gets cold feet before the wedding. The fiancé asks what the point of life is if at the end we just die. Bingham responds that there is no point because at the end you will just die, but wouldn’t you rather spend the time you do have here on earth with somebody. He no longer wishes to be isolated, but to suffer through life with someone by his side. Bingham flies to Chicago to tell Alex, but discovers that she has been lying all the time and that she has a family. After putting his heart on the line it gets crushed by someone he really cared about. Is it worth it? Having all the feelings of pain and suffering of love on top of the pain and suffering of life. I think it is and so does the book of Ecclesiastes.
Qoheleth in the book of Ecclesiastes talks about the oppressions in life and how people are living lives of vanity. He discusses how people like Bingham are toiling away and gaining nothing, “For all their days are full of pain, and their work is a vexation; even at night their minds do not rest. This also is vanity” (2:23). He also is trying to discover the meaning of life, the purpose of his existence on earth and the reason for him to keep on living. Most of Ecclesiastes is dark, but one of the lighter parts is when Qoheleth talks about companionship. He says “Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their toil. For if they fall, one will lift up the other; but woe to one who is alone and falls and does not have another to help” (4:9-10). Qoheleth is acknowledging that that while life is not easy and most of the time it is horrible, if you have to suffer through it you should suffer through it with someone else. Bingham also comes to this realization during the movie, because he discovers that companionship is what he is missing. Qoheleth doesn’t give a lot of reasons to live in this book and even states that the best scenario would be if you didn’t live at all, but he makes room for eight verses to describe companionship. Obviously companionship became important to him at some point in his life. So maybe life doesn’t have a purpose, maybe it’s just important to find someone who is willing to search for that purpose with you.
Maggie, I loved your last sentence! Good writing!
ReplyDeleteYou said that you think that having the feelings of pain and suffering of love on top of the pain and suffering of life is worthwhile and that you think Qoheleth would agree with you. You make a very good case for Qoheleth admitting that companionship is valuable. However, it seems that Qoheleth is advocating for friends, not for lovers. Qoheleth seems to only be "pro-friend" because of the benefits that it offers. Friends are safe, because they offer benefits while you have them, yet don't leave you totally crushed if they leave, like a lover would. I think that Qoheleth would point out that Alex turned out to be a cheater and that Ryan would have been better off if he hadn't gotten so close to her. Maybe he would point out that in the end the whole relationship was meaningless.
ReplyDeleteI definitely picked up on the theme of companionship throughout the movie. It seemed to me though that while Ryan tryed to have friends and relationships, these ultimately turned out to be frustrating and hurtful, and the movie ends with his return to life on planes. I think this point in the movie was made (quite strongly) by the presence of Alex as well as Natalie's fiance who broke off their engagement via text message.
ReplyDelete