It wasn't until the end of Sufjan Steven's, Casimir Pulaski Day, that I put together our reading from Ecclesiastes and the song. I'm going to need a therapist after this class haha. Dread, doom, dread.
Qoheleth talks about man having everything under the sun and not having anything at the same time. The rich being prosperous yet not being happy with his earning or losing everything they have earned so that his son still has no earnings from his toils.
Eccl. 5:1-4 suprised me, it didn't have the same tone as the rest of what we have read from Ecclesiastes. The heading for this section, Stand in Awe of God, but I percieved it as more Stand in Fear of him. "Gaurd your steps when you go to the house of God. Gonear to listen rather than to offer the sacrifice of fools, who do not know that they do wrong. Do not be quick with your mouth, do not be hasty in your heart to utter anything before God." (Ecc. 5:1-2) Sounds like more of a warning if you ask me. Should we fear God? Or should we look at him in a fraternal way?
After listening to Casimir Pulaski Day, I got the feeling that while they were talking about the father driving to the Navy yard when he heard that the daughter (I'm guessing daughter) had bone cancer, and that he drove there to say he was sorry, that somehow he was supposed to be interpretted as God. Thinking of God as your father and then interpreting the song in that sense made the song make more sense to me.
Kate said...
ReplyDeleteI agree- I will definitely need a therapist after this class:)
I agree that the song was very depressing.... I like how you pointed out that Qoheleth seems fearful of God. The language that he used in 5:1-4 definitely supports this. He seems to only want to follow God because of what might happen to him if he doesn't. I sort of saw the same type of fear in the song 'Casamir Pulaski Day'. The singer has lost someone who he was in love with and he blames God. He sees God as someone who can take and take and take. Someone/thing with this much power, and someone who would use it to hurt humans so badly, seems like someone that should be feared, not exactly revered or even loved.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your comment about how 5:1-4 sounds more like a warning. Fearing God seems to be the point Qohelet wants to make - if you fear God and obey him, you'll be able to have and enjoy your riches, as opposed to having riches and not having any pleasure or enjoyment out of them.
ReplyDeleteThe meaning that I got from 5:1-4 is to fear God in such a way that you are more inclined to obey him. It almost seems like the fear a child would have for his or her father who looks threatening and spanks the kids so the child will do what he is supposed to.
ReplyDeleteI like your question about whether we should fear God or have a familiar relationship with him. In the interpretation by Brown, the author says that we shouldn't degrade God with our trivial thoughts and desires. This view of God is is very different than what is commonly depicted. For example, Phillipians 4:6 reads "Do not worry about anything, but in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God."
ReplyDelete