Wednesday, September 1, 2010

No Reason to Follow God?

Although Qohelet is not advocating that a higher power does not exist, it does seem that in Ecclesiastes 1:12 - 2:26 that he is suggesting that this higher power does not process any qualities that make Him worthy of our admiration. This part of Ecclesiastes is a testimony of Qohelet’s struggle with the actual vanity of believing in God.

In 1:13, Qohelet expresses that he believes that God gave wisdom to humans in order for them to learn about the ways in which the world operates, but goes on to let his readers know that this gift from God has made him extremely unhappy. It is almost like Qohelet views the relationship between God, wisdom, and humans as an evil game created for God’s amusement at the expense of humans. In verses 1:16-18, Qohelet realizes that because he has participated in God’s “wisdom game” he has received a great deal of sorrow.

It seems that Qohelet does not like the argument that he is making, because at the beginning of chapter 2 he begins to try to disprove his own idea. He speaks of how he no longer found enjoyment in pleasure because of his wisdom, but still attempted to convince himself that there was something to be gained from life. In verses 4-11, he explains to the reader the extent to which he tried to dissuade himself from his pervious notion. It is important to note that Qohelet admits that he did feel pleasure in the moment of his toil, but became dissatisfied because the pleasure of the moment passes once the moment is gone, which still results in no net gain.

This small bit of pleasure is important to Qohelet, because in 2:13 he starts to hint that he thinks wisdom may have an intrinsic value in and of itself. He explains that at least the wise have eyes to see, when the fools just walk in darkness. I am unsure as to whether he means that it is better to at least know that you are in darkness, or if he means that those who have eyes are seeing something better than darkness, such as light. Regardless of what Quohelet was feeling, he quickly neglects this positive outlook for a more negative tone. He begins to mourn the fact that the wise come to the same end in death as the foolish. Qohelet circles his argument one last time by offering the idea that even the fleeting pleasures of the moment come from God. This causes the reader to have hope that Quohelet is going to come to the conclusion that we should enjoy the moment and rejoice that God has given us this ability. Unfortunately, Quohelet crushes this hope by pointing out that since the moment is so vain, that we were not any better off in the end for having enjoyed it. This leads the reader to conclude that Qohelet thinks that the only gain from God is pleasure in the moment, but since the pleasure of the moment is not lasting, there is no actual gain from following the will of God.

5 comments:

  1. In Brown's interpretation of 2:16, he thought that Qoheleth was upset because wisdom could not prevent him from being forgotten. The wise and fool would both be forgotten. This is interesting to me because Qoheleth is still remembered and at the beginning of Ecclesiastes King David, who died hundreds of years before the book was written, is mentioned. I interpreted the last two verses a little differently in that Qoheleth does think that we can find joy by living in the moment but that it is meaningless because that kind of joy will not help them be remebered. Another thing I found interesting was that in verses 1-11 Qoheleth treated himself to material things and built great gardens (maybe for people to remember him by), but the only humans he mentioned were entertainers. He doesn't mention friendship or love which are pleasurable and people can actually remember you and pass down stories about you after you die.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "This too, I see, is from the hand of G-d, for without him, who can eat or find enjoyment?" (2:24-25)

    I found your interpretation of the text very interesting, Lacey. I read it more in light of the above verse though, stating that what little pleasure we do get, even if it is momentary or even "chasing after the wind," does come from G-d. I don't know that Qoheleth believes that there is gain in following G-d, even if he is the source of what pleasure we recieve in life -- that bit about the wise man and the fool both ending with up dead seems to point to your view. If Qoheleth does believe in an afterlife, then maybe there would be some gain to following G-d. I haven't seen evidence for that in the text yet though.

    ReplyDelete
  3. """Qohelet circles his argument one last time by offering the idea that even the fleeting pleasures of the moment come from God."""

    I assume you are referring to 2:24, right? If so, then you leave me very confused when you interpret 2:25-26 as such:

    """This causes the reader to have hope that Quohelet is going to come to the conclusion that we should enjoy the moment and rejoice that God has given us this ability. Unfortunately, Quohelet crushes this hope by pointing out that since the moment is so vain, that we were not any better off in the end for having enjoyed it."""

    That sounds like the opposite of what Koheleth is saying, Lacey. In fact, (and this is actually problematic for my view but in concordance to what I guess your lens on Ecclesiastes is) Koheleth seems to be saying that those who are "good" in God's eyes are blessed with the wisdom of enjoying themselves in the moment, while those who God does not approve of are cursed with the vain desire to work now for imagined later gain. (I think 3:9-13 is a nice parallel? Check it out)

    What *is* problematic for you and many in this class (and I'm guessing big here! forgive me and correct me as needed, since this is a leap!) is that this smacks of predestination. And I am guessing that bothers people. I think a lot of folks in our class want to find a concluding lesson along the lines of "As long as you do X, you'll be fine!" (X could for example be, "follow God's will and be a good Jew or Christian"-- whatever that means). This would have the advantage of being consistent with the simple religious teachings many were taught as children.

    But I think Ecclesiastes's view is a good deal more complicated than that. Koheleth may start out just like us, children looking for a magic answer that solves the problem entirely (and he tries out a lot of candidate answers). But he grows up and has to start looking at the world in a more adult way, admitting that it is more complex than we are able to understand.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I greatly appreciate your reading of 2:13. I too understand Qohelet to be implying throughout Ecclesiastes that 'Wisdom' has some sort of intrinsic value. The frustration with wisdom is rooted in the mystery that it encompases; a question something like this... 'towards what end does the value of wisdom serve?' This is an utterly unanswerable, but deeply fundamental question if one is every going to make full peace with wisdom.

    Indeed, Qohelet speaks against restless seeking, as utterly vain no matter what direction it points. But, whats significant to me about 2:13-14 is this: even if there is some degree of vanity undergirding all of human activity, in proclaiming that "wisdom excells folly" Qohelet makes an explicit value judgement. Both wisdom and folly may be vain when claimed by man, but one still offers more to man than the other.

    Along these lines, what I hear when I read the question in 2:15, "What befalls the fool will befall me also; why then have I been so very wise?", I do not hear a man that regrets having sought wisdom; in fact, I hear just the opposite. In relation to the rest of the passage, for me, the question depicts a man struggling to rationalize the fact that the more a man knows, the more he realizes he doesn't know. Its not that knowing more, or being wise, are an utter waste of time, but that the sense of clarity that comes with wisdom effects ones own preception only; not ones significance in relation to others. This is whats key.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Jillian, I like your more specific interpretation that Qoheleth thinks wisdom is futile because it doesn’t result in remembrance. I think that both of our interpretations are roughly the same, since the whole problem with death is that you cease to exist and be remembered. Also, great job pointing out the irony in that Qoheleth and David are both still being remembered so many years after their lives.

    Ed, It is probably good that you are able to maintain a positive view of Ecc. I was actually very pleased when I read about everything being from the hand of God and given for the pleasure of humans. This is very comforting. I actually didn’t come up with the overarching idea for this text (that maybe being “good” wasn’t helpful) until I read the very last verse of chapter 2 which negates 2:24-25 by referring to it as vain, pointless, meaningless, etc.

    Dom, Sorry you are confused by the shift that I found between 2:24 and 2:25. I thought that Qoheleth was switching from a positive to a negative tone. This doesn’t really have to be confusing because Qoheleth started out in a negative tone and then reaffirms his first opinion about wisdom in the end. I just thought that any positivity in between could be seen as Qohelth trying to disprove his argument, much like a scientist who tries to disprove his hypothesis. I wasn’t trying to ignore the positivity where Qoheleth speaks of the benefits of being wise, just showing that he refutes his own musing at the end of chapter 2.
    I really have no idea how you leaped to predestination from my interpretation. Although, I would love to know how you got there. I’m not attempting to find a concluding lesson from Ecc. As I read the text, I was trying to practice interpreting line by line. As for what our parents taught us as children, I don’t think that this can really be applied to Ecc. I don’t know about your parents, but mine never told me that there was no point in life or wisdom or that live people are worse off than dead babies. I’m not advocating for Qoheleth’s outlook on life, mine is very positive and I feel much more comfortable simply relating it on it’s own instead of trying to weave it into something as pessimistic as Ecc.
    I appreciate your well thought out post and I especially like the last paragraph. I find similarities between it and what I have said. I do think that Qoheleth is going through a learning process and trying to make sense of things that he learns, which can explain some of the ambiguity. Thanks for the thoughts!

    Big Daddy Z, I am grateful for your explanation of how you see Qoheleth’s outlook on wisdom. It is interesting that your view that Qoheleth thinks wisdom is futile because personal wisdom can only change personal viewpoints goes along with Jillian’s interpretation that Qoheleth is dissatisfied with not being able to accomplish anything that would allow him to have any lasting effect on humanity (be remembered).

    ReplyDelete