Monday, September 6, 2010

on the side of Their oppressors there was power, ...

There is much to ponder over in a reading of Ecclesiastes chs 3 and 4, from perspectives as broad as theology, social justice, and even cosmology. The everpresent theme of life as vane struggle persists, coupled with an eye to the(primarily economic) injustices that human existence perpetuates. As I have come to expect, for Qoheleth toil is the key motor that gets humanity going, our unhappy conatus. It is our primary reason for existing, according to a number of passages in the text. Whether this toil is given us by god or man is up for debate, for while God is represented as an all-powerful entity who has placed us upon the earth, he does not appear to be the benevolent deity so often conceived of in the popular imagination. I will have more to say on this later, but sufficed to say suffering is a leitmotif that represents the struggle of existence and its fleeting pleasures. "It is an unhappy business god has given human beings to be busy with," we are told in 1:13, and this inflexible unhappiness can be overcome through neither wisdom or follely. Rather we are advised to take pleasure in the small joys aforded us through food, drink and prurience, though none of these will provide us anything so unrealizable as ultimate satisfaction.
The insistence upon balance in Ecclesiastes, particularly the oft quoted ch 3 vs 1 through 8 which Brown refers to as "arguably the most well-known passage in the book,"(brown, 40) , brings to mind a theology more pantheistic than traditionally hebraic. When we, at least as americans ensconced in the Western judeoChristian tradition, think of God, we commonly attribute to him the three attributes of omnipotence, omnipresence, and omniscience. Yet while certain elements of this theology are retained in Qoheleth's rendoring of God, it would behoove us to pause and consider a few important distinctions. Brown touches upon some of these in his important insight that for Qoheleth, "... for every course of action in one direction, there will occur in due time an equal and opposite reaction. If the cosmos operates like clockwork, impersonal and repetitive, then chronos is its pendulum, held aloft by God. Each activity, whether positive or negative, has its season, and the seasons themselves
have their place in the rhythm of the ever-circling years."(brown, 41) this is far from the eschatology so prevalent in the Christian tradition, or even the special place accorded the Hebrews to be found in the Tora. Here we see something much more akin to the deism of seventeenth century philosophers and even many of the founding fathers. God is here seen as an aloof figure who, in lieu of personal involvement with his creatures, resembles a clockmaker who has placed the world in an orbit and a rhythm of regularity. This seems to me to be what the teacher is getting at in the introduction to ch 3, and it is this that is captured in the Birds' song Turn! Turn! Turn! Each stresses the orderly nature of existence in the widest terms possible of human activity.
Finally yet relatedly, there is what I would tentatively, quite tentatively but the temptation remains, refer to as the Marxist proclivities found in Qoheleth's tirades against the rich and the powerful. He seems to be saying that, since suffering is inevitable, it is an injustice for the powerful to lord their greatness over those whose lot it is, and whether this is divinely ordained poses another interesting question, to be stricken with poverty. Consider in the beginning of ch4, Qoheleth contends that it is better to never have been conceived than to witness the injustices and vacuousness of existence. This is brought on by his observation of the "tears of the oppressed" who have "no one to comfort them!"(4:1) Note that God, so often understood in the Bible as a shepherd overseeing his flock, or in the new testament as one who knows even the number of hairs on a subject's head, ... is strikingly absent. Those who endure with "no one to comfort them" are without consolation, hence the great emphasis given their plight by the Preacher. This undertaking emulates the work of such prophets as Amos and, admittedly anachronisticly, Martin Luther king, whose task was, as they saw it, to be a voice for those who have been silenced through the all-too-human inequalities inherent in the unequal distribution of power into which they are born. "‘For whom am I toiling’, they ask, ‘and depriving myself of pleasure?’ This also is vanity and an unhappy business."(3:8) Indeed, though i do not have time to pursue this line of thought, I feel that Qoheleth's belief that "all toil and all skill in work come from one person’s envy of another ..." could be, if followed, incorporated into an implicit critique of capitalism given this system's propencity to raise selfishness to the highest of virtues. but that's a story, for another time. ...broad as theology, social justice, and even cosmology. The everpresent theme of life as vane struggle persists, coupled with an eye to the(primarily economic) injustices that human existence perpetuates. As I have come to expect, for Qoheleth toil is the key motor that gets humanity going, our unhappy conatus. It is our primary reason for existing, according to a number of passages in the text. Whether this toil is given us by god or man is up for debate, for while God is represented as an all-powerful entity who has placed us upon the earth, he does not appear to be the benevolent deity so often conceived of in the popular imagination. I will have more to say on this later, but sufficed to say suffering is a leitmotif that represents the struggle of existence and its fleeting pleasures. "It is an unhappy business god has given human beings to be busy with," we are told in 1:13, and this inflexible unhappiness can be overcome through neither wisdom or follely. Rather we are advised to
The insistence upon balance in Ecclesiastes, particularly the oft quoted ch 3 vs 1 through 8 which Brown refers to as "arguably the most well-known passage in the book,"(brown, 40) , brings to mind a theology more pantheistic than traditionally hebraic. When we, at least as americans ensconced in the Western judeoChristian tradition, think of God, we commonly attribute to him the three attributes of omnipotence, omnipresence, and omniscience. Yet while certain elements of this theology are retained in Qoheleth's rendoring of God, it would behoove us to pause and consider a few important distinctions. Brown touches upon some of these in his important insight that for Qoheleth, "... for every course of action in one direction, there will occur in due time an equal and opposite reaction. If the cosmos operates like clockwork, impersonal and repetitive, then chronos is its pendulum, held aloft by God. Each activity, whether positive or negative, has its season, and the seasons themselves
have their place in the rhythm of the ever-circling years."(brown, 41) this is far from the eschatology so prevalent in the Christian tradition, or even the special place accorded the Hebrews to be found in the Tora. Here we see something much more akin to the deism of seventeenth century philosophers and even many of the founding fathers. God is here seen as an aloof figure who, in lieu of personal involvement with his creatures, resembles a clockmaker who has placed the world in an orbit and a rhythm of regularity. This seems to me to be what the teacher is getting at in the introduction to ch 3, and it is this that is captured in the Birds' song Turn! Turn! Turn! Each stresses the orderly nature of existence in the widest terms possible of human activity.
Finally yet relatedly, there is what I would tentatively, quite tentatively but the temptation remains, refer to as the Marxist proclivities found in Qoheleth's tirades against the rich and the powerful. He seems to be saying that, since suffering is inevitable, it is an injustice for the powerful to lord their greatness over those whose lot it is, and whether this is divinely ordained poses another interesting question, to be stricken with poverty. Consider in the beginning of ch4, Qoheleth contends that is better to never have been conceived than to witness the injustices and vacuousness of existence. This is brought on by his observation of the "tears of the oppressed" who have "no one to comfort them!"(4:1)

No comments:

Post a Comment