I liked the movie Up in the Air in the same way that I like Ecclesiastes; they're not the perfect little happy stories. Yes, they are kinda sad ans depressing, but they are real and talk about true human thoughts and troubles. Last year when I first saw the movie, Ecc and its references ever crossed my mind. But on the second viewing I saw many similarities. However, i don't think that Up in the Air was based on or had its roots in Ecc. Qohelet in Ecc was struggling with legitimate queries and doubts pertaining to life. Those same questions are still reside in people today, but instead of writing about it, a movie was made. (This kinda supports Qohelets idea that wisdom can only take a person so far. People today struggle with things that people thousands of years ago struggled with; obviously we haven't made much progress). Up in the Air and Ecc have similar themes throughout but that doesn't necessarily mean they were based on one another.
In Up in the Air we learn about the life of Ryan Bingham (George Clooney), a corporate downsizing expert (aka: an expert at firing people) who cherishes his 24/7 isolating job. In the beginning Ryan sees no immediate need for family, friends, or a home. He lives out of a suitcase, is a stranger to his family and doesn't have any real friends. This all changes when Ryan's company hires a new young employee, Natalie. Natalie developed a method of video conferencing that will allow Ryan and his co-workers to fire people without leaving "home". This basically threatens the life Ryan cherishes. To prove Natalie wrong, Ryan takes Natalie on a cross country firing spree. While on this trip Ryan begins to see the downfalls in his way of life. His belief that 10 million frequent flyer miles will make him satisfied begins to shift when Natalie pokes and tests Ryans lifestyle. She asks him questions on family, love, and marriage. Only after convincing his sisters fiance to go through with the marriage saying that life sucks but its suckiness is better when someone else is there...a "co-pilot" does he truly convince himself. Here is where Ryans importance of life changes from frequent flyer miles to companionship. Ryan then decides that Alex, his girlfriend/friend with benefits is someone he wants in his life permanently and wants to have a home, family and friends.
I think that Ryan Binghams life and the book of Ecc mirror each other in themes. Qohelet searches for meaning in self-indulgence (2:3-11) but found short lived pleasure (2:11). Ryan Bingham looked for meaning his accomplishments (frequent flyer miles) and self-indulgence (golden access cards, specific travel cars) but never found true and whole satisfaction. Qohelet also tries to use wisdom to find and reach the meaning (1:13), but only found sorrow and vexation (1:18). Ryan, I believe, was intrigued and somewhat enlightened by Natalie and Alex to a new meaning of life, but Ryan only found sorrow because he discovered that he was truly alone. Finally Qohelet decides that the world is what it is, nothing can change it (3:14-15), and it stinks. But Qohelet discovers that the world, even in its vanity, can still have joy if you have companionship (4:9-12). Ryan comes to the conclusion at his sisters wedding that he needs his own co-pilot.
Both Ecc and Up in the Air conclude with the notion that life stinks and it will always stink but it can be bearable with others.
I agree with you about similar themes but I think that there is a difference with Ryan in that, in the end, he does make connections and relationships with people (for example trying to give some of his frequent flyer miles to his sister and brother-in-law and writing the recommendation letter for Natalie). I think that, in a small way, Up in the Air does have a little more optimism than the book of Ecclesiastes.
ReplyDeleteI think the way that you point out that Up in the Air and Ecc. share themes offers support for Qoheleth's point that "there is nothing new under the sun". You are right, apparently people haven't made it very far in figuring out the questions of life. It's sad to think that we are still right were Qoheleth was years ago.
ReplyDelete