Even after a beautiful, sympathetic poetic rendering of the cycles of life in the opening Ecc. ch.3, Koheleth's writing remains ambiguous towards whether life on earth is a time to endorse with meaning or to disregard as “hevel,” vapor. To aid myself in understanding how Koheleth can simultaneously sustain his duality, I think of him as analogous to a solipsist. Solipsists, by definition, believe that the only thing they know to exist for sure is what is within their own mind. Everything outside of them in the world, everyone they interact with, and everyone else's experiences, are deniable to them as real because those experiences do not exist within their own mind. And yet these people still (hopefully) continue to live an outwardly typical life: have a job, make friends, etc... Within themselves they hold a disbelieving, skeptical view of the world, but cannot fully cave into that view because, somewhere inside, they know they have to participate in real life in order to survive.
Koheleth's skeptical view that life is hardly worth living is permissible because he does not fully bite onto that bait. Rather than completely giving up on life, he represses his underlying negativity and theorizes ways to get by in life, while he has to. For example, in Ecc. 3:21-22, Koheleth opens saying, “Who knows if a man's lifebreath does rise upward and if a beast's breath does sink down into the earth?,” representing his unresolved view of what eventually is to come of all of life. In 3:22 he then resolves and devises a practical way to live with his unsettled heart, writing, “I saw that there is nothing better for man than to enjoy his possessions, since that is his portion. For who can enable him to see what will happen afterword?” Neither Koheleth nor any man can see with a divine perspective and know whether anything is worth any effort, but we continue to try anyways because the risk of completely giving up outweighs the sacrifice of what we could reap from trying. To this point, Koheleth seems to cling to the spark of hope that life, perhaps when viewed from upside-down, will eventually have meaning and to not let himself fully cave into the tempting and engulfing wave of hevel.
I enjoyed your comparison of Koheleth to a solopist. It wasn't a term I had ever heard before but it really made sense. It does seem that if he really believed that everything was as meaningless as he said that he would be more depressed or less productive. It is a bit more optimistic of a take than I have been reading. I liked the perspective.
ReplyDeleteThe thought of how similar the Solipsist philosophy and the beliefs of Koheleth never crossed my mind, but I feel as though that is a really good comparison. The Solipsist don't believe in a place for the afterlife, or that a soul lives on after the body is gone, so in this way too they're much like Koheleth. If Koheleth really does think everything is meaningless, why does he keep working towards some unknown goal, or a goal that might not exist at all? I agree with the earlier comment, maybe he is not so sure it is all that meaningless.
ReplyDeletesounds like Koheleth preceded the existentialists by about 2000 years. Did any of those thinkers ever credit Ecclesiastes?
ReplyDelete