Monday, September 20, 2010

Fear God....a prolonged life? Or prolonged after life?

These few verses of Ecclesiastes 8 and 9 seemed to portray a more optimistic approach to this vain life than the previous chapters. Qoheleth’s adamant reassurance in justice, hope, and joy is a nice hiatus from the “all is vain”, “why should we live”, and “oppressed are we” talk. Because of this overall optimistic tone I read it from a different angle. In chapter 8 verses 12-13 I saw a hint of the possibility of an afterlife. Verses 12 and 13 basically say that we are all sinners but that there is one distinction between us; those who fear God and those who don’t. Qoheleth says that those who fear God that their lives will be prolonged, and those who don’t fear God that their lives won’t be prolonged. He even goes to say that those who don’t fear God are like shadows (13b). Now, earlier in Ecc. Qoheleth repeatedly says that all humans and even beasts have the same fate, which is ultimately death (3:19, 2:14, and 7:2). I don’t think that this is just another contradiction. I think that Qoheleth is entertaining the idea that if we do fear God, our lives will be prolonged: prolonged after death. I think that Qoheleth believes this because Qoheleth confesses his belief in judgment from God (3:17). Why would Qoheleth believe in a God that judges people when we die, if there is nothing after death and a reason for the judgment? Qoheleth must be intrigued by the idea that something does exists after death, because the life one lives here on earth is judged by it. Thus, the rest of this particular excerpt (8:10-9:10) and throughout Ecc. Qoheleth is giving commands on how to live this life that will be judged. To fear God (8:12-13), live righteously, become wise (8:5, 7:16), and find enjoyment in this vain and unfair world.
One of Qoheleth’s biggest commands can be found inverse 15 of chapter 8; Qoheleth is commanding his readers to find enjoyment “for there is nothing better” for people to have. Qoheleth advises that this joy works with the toils of the world, just like “darkness only enhances the weak radiance of joy’s light” (Brown 93). You can’t truly experience one without experiencing the other. In chapter 9 verses 7-10 Qoheleth commands with great intensity and urgency to “go eat, drink, let, enjoy, and do” (Brown 93). Qoheleth is advising that if we enjoy these things the struggles and toils of life are lessened of their burdens. Enjoy life before death takes control. Qoheleth is hitting on the point that humans only live once, so seize the day before death takes control.

3 comments:

  1. I'm a bit confused about your concept of an afterlife. You interpret 8:12-13 as advocation for fear of God, because this will result in a prolonged life. I must be honest and admit that I do not know what a "prolonged life" is referring to. However, I don't see how it could be referring to an afterlife. It does seem in these verses that God is judging the actions of people and that those who fear him are benefitted somehow, and that those who do not fear are not benefitted. I think that your argument for "prolonged life" referring to an afterlife is a bit weak, because in order for this judgment that Qoheleth speaks of to be meaningful God would have to punish the people who do not fear him. If he is to do this in an afterlife, then all would be receiving a prolonged life as they receive their punishment or reward. Prolonged life as an afterlife would be prolonged life for all, and Qoheleth is clear that prolonged life only comes to those who fear God. This is why I asked about your concept of an afterlife. Your argument only works if the afterlife only exist for those who have feared God. This is confusing though, because it seems that in order for God to judge, everyone's life would have to be prolonged. If prolonged life meant the afterlife, then prolonged life would simply be reality, not a reward.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think "prolonged life" in this context is referring to a longer life here on earth, not an afterlife. It would certainly be interesting to look at the Hebrew for this particular phrase.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think it's interesting that you pulled the concept of an afterlife out of those verses. Some things in the reading today seemed to hint at afterlife to me, too, but I think you have to be reading with that concept in mind to see it in the passage. Those verses in particular don't point as strongly to it for me, because the judgment of G-d could easily occur during this lifetime. I thought 9:2 was interesting when Qoheleth talked about "joining the dead," though it could just be a poetic way of talking about death rather than an actual joining with the rest of the dead. And most of chapter 9 seems, at least to me, to be working against the idea of an afterlife. "The dead know nothing; they have no further reward, and even the memory of them is forgotten" (Ecc 8:5). This seems to better support the argument that Qoheleth does not believe in an afterlife and is worried about not being remembered.

    ReplyDelete