Wednesday, September 22, 2010

Is a life of toil beautiful or ugly?

In the film ‘American Beauty’, Beauty manifests itself in a number of ways. I would argue that Beauty primarily functions as a motivator: its perceived presence or absence, lures characters towards particular emotional states and courses of action. Meanwhile, orbiting the central notion of Beauty, are the themes of death and enjoyment. Indeed, it seems that for all of the characters in the film where there is beauty enjoyment can be found, and where beauty is lacking enjoyment lacks as well. For example, the lack of beauty in the protagonist’s marriage makes the beauty of a young girl that much more enticing. However, the beauty of the girl is transformed when he finds out that she is a virgin, and therefore, his enjoyment is similarly transformed (e.g. he no longer desires to has sex with her as a virgin, even though the goal of sex previously motivated him to start working out.) All the while, death is lurking right around the corner. The significance here is that by contextualizing Ecclesiastes’ themes of death and enjoyment this film opens a peculiar window through which we can view the book itself.

On multiple occasions the protagonist of the film comes to a conclusion, which Qoheleth would agree with; that his commitment to ideals, such as marriage, career, and obedience to the law have proven to be vain, unfulfilling pursuits. This conclusion seemingly leads to another; that at this point he is solely committed to finding enjoyment in his toil. The twisted irony of the film, however, is that by going down this path the protagonist ultimately brings his own death upon him. It should be noted, too, that upon dying what flashes before his eyes are those moments that he found to be truly beautiful.

The last portion of the protagonist’s life seems to go as followed: vain pursuits are abandoned, enjoyment guided by beauty becomes the primary goal for each moment, and the relief of death arrives shortly after. At this point, it’s tempting to argue that according to Qoheleth, the protagonist’s last days were literally as good as gets. But alas, a fundamental question must be answered before it can be claimed that Qoheleth would advocate the life-choices that the film’s main character made: What does Qoheleth believe is beautiful? What motivates him and his writing?

It seems clear to me that what ultimately defines how we interpret something, is what we value more: the particular or the universal, the individual or the society, the piece or the whole. In my mind, so long as we cannot know the motivations of the writer of the book of Ecclesiastes, any attempt to interpret it is vanity. At the same time, the value of interpreting Ecclesiastes is found not in our interpretations, but in the enjoyment we find in the process.

To end my response, I’d like to offer a song for reflection that I think relates to the movie’s emotional tone pretty well…

“Slow Motion” by Third Eye Blind, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Ibfvjv4uxE

1 comment:

  1. I like your song. I think it does a good job of showing that our perceptions of people and our world are not always what we think, which was also emphasized in American Beauty.

    ReplyDelete