Monday, September 6, 2010

For who am I toiling?

When I read Ecclesisastes, I understand the Teacher to be writing with the intention of teaching something. So, as I interpret I ask myself, what insight or inspiration might the Teacher intend to leave his students with? Not, what is he saying, but what is his message? For this particular passage, it is my understanding that the Teacher wants his students to ask themselves, first, "for who am I toiling?" and second, "what determines how I experience my toil"?

I understand the first section of this passage to be 3:1-9. Qoheleth starts in v. 3:1 saying "for everything there is a season", and then goes on to show not only that everything is part of a cycle, but that nature possesses a certain sort of balance, or harmony. The problem with this reality is then pointed out in v.3:9, "What gain has the worker from his toil?" What i take this all to suggest is that humans are a part of nature, and nature consists of a natural balance of relationships, but because humans have such diverse experiences they are doomed to toil with the mystery of their own proper place in things. Sure, the Ten commandments say not to kill, as if this is a black-and-white, right-or-wrong world we live in, but Qoheleth is saying lets be honest, let's take a look at all of the natural processes taking place all around us, and admit that if all individuals do have an appointed place and time, what they do not have is an instruction manual telling them what their own place and time is. This my friends is why humans are doomed to a life of toiling.

In what i would call the second section of the passage, vv. 3:10-15, Qoheleth goes on to suggest that yeah, life is full of toil, but clearly that's how God made it. He says in v. 11, "he has put eternity into man's mind, yet so that he cannot find out what God has done from the beginning to the end." Qoheleth is saying, yeah we are never going to solve life's mysteries, or conquer anything ultimate, but that was never god's intention, and that type of mindset is a waste of time. Qohelth's message therefore, is to toil everyday knowing that v.3:12 "there is nothing better for them to be happy and enjoy themselves."

In what I would call the third section of the passage, vv. 3:10 - 4:8, Qoheleth is describing multiple realties of human experience to suggest that it makes no sense to toil for any particular thing or idea. Instead, humans ought to toil on behalf of a general experience of life that can be described as happy or enjoyable. The message here is that when we take joy in life, its source is never a particular thing or idea, but it is in fact an emergent from multiple things and ideas coming together in harmony. In vv. 3:16-21Qoheleth provides a set of what he would consider significant examples, to suggest that even the ideals of justice and righteousness are impure ideas, and even men can't be said to be a better thing than an animal is. In vv. 4:1-8, Qoheleth admits that there is absolutely nothing satisfying about living a life of oppression, and then goes onto suggest that even those who are free from the oppression of others, end up oppressing themselves by toiling vainly.

So, after acknowledging humanity's uncomfortable position in what appears to be a comfortably balanced universe, and after undermining any one who might want to think that man is special if he toils after a particular thing or idea, Qoheleth finally offers an approach to dealing with all the shit life gives you. I understand the teaching to go something likes this: As you toil in hopes of having an enjoyable experience keep in mind that "two are better than one" and "better is a poor and wise youth than an old and foolish king, who will no longer take advice." In short, the power to experience life in a positive way is obtained by consciously toiling alongside your fellow man, and never losing the will to learn from others.

Despite the abundance of vain toiling...Toil with the toils of others in mind, and never lose the will to toil some more.

4 comments:

  1. I also read this passage in a "wisdom for now" kind of light. It seemed that Qoheleth was indeed trying to teach something that could actually be applied to the here and now, instead of simply lamenting his approaching death. I was pleased that Qoheleth finally realized that there is benefit in caring about others, although I did not read this as optimistically as you did. When you say that "the power to experience life in a positive way is obtained by consciously toiling alongside your fellow man" it seems like you are saying that Qoheleth was advocating for helping others. I thought that his indifferent tone toward the oppressed in the beginning of chapter 4 was an indication that Qoheleth did not really care about those who are lesser than him. All of Qoheleth's talk about having friends in 4:9-12 seems to only be important to Qoheleth because this brings personal gain to the person who has the friends. Although I really like your positive tone, it seems that you are being to kind of Qoheleth. He is still being as selfish as always, he has just finally realized that having friends might be beneficial to himself.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with a lot of what you talked about in your post, and I liked the more optimistic interpretation of this particular text.

    Lacey, I don't think Qohelet is completely indifferent to those who are lesser than him. I read the beginning of chapter 4 seeing Qohelet merely stating the fact that those who are oppressed have no help, and while he isn't advocating going out and freeing them, he isn't saying oppression is okay. I felt that, because of the endless repetition, Qohelet doesn't see a real point in helping out the oppressed (because a) toil is meaningless and b) there will just be another group of people who are oppressed).

    I do think this text had many pieces of wisdom, you just had to look at it in a different light.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I am so glad that another person in the class has an optimistic view. I also read it to be taught something....he is the "teacher" afterall.

    I don't think that Qohelet is indifferent to people, and that hw won't help those who are less than him, i think that Qohelet was just pointing out that most people don't, especially someone with his power. It was the norm to outcast them. In modern days its more the norm to take care of the oppressed. I don't think that Qohelet was being selfish, but realistic.

    I do agree with your interpretation of "the power to experience life in a positive way is obtained by consciously toiling alongside your fellow man, and never losing the will to learn from others."

    ReplyDelete
  4. In what you used as the second part of the passage, I feel like I've seen the same thing reoccur throughout Ecc...the idea that sometimes things are not enjoyable but they are from God, that's how they are, and they shouldn't be questioned/you shouldn't waste time trying to figure it out (you used the example of toiling).

    ReplyDelete