This blog represents the work of the students of RELI 227 "Skeptics in Scripture" at Hendrix College. We are a community of learning investigating the biblical texts of Job and Ecclesiastes. Your thoughtful comments are invited and encouraged.
Wednesday, October 27, 2010
How Redundant
Although it’s kind of boring I think the repetition of the arguments shows the strength of Job’s character. It would be easy (and probably natural) to claim innocence at the beginning of an argument in which people are questioning your actions. However, I think the compelling arguments offered by the friends the second time would make many people crack. This seems especially likely since it’s a three against one argument. The fact that Job endures the accusations twice from each friend and still steadfastly clings to his claim shows that Job is a strong man whose beliefs aren’t easily changed by the suggestions of others.
I feel like Job is becoming a little desperate in these chapters. His friends won’t stop heckling him and the god who did this to him won’t even answer his questions. I feel sad for Job and I wish for his sake that God would have appeared after the first round of arguments to explain himself. I also feel similarly desperate to find the truth about what is really going on in the book. I think the fact that God hasn’t shown up maybe says something about how he feels about the situation. I get the feeling that God might be trying to avoid Job and the situation he created because he realizes it might have been too much. I suppose it’s also possible that God is so arrogant and sure of his actions that he didn’t feel the need to explain himself to his own creation. If the first is true, Job’s God has similar characteristics to humans and that isn’t very awe-inspiring. If the latter is the case, God doesn’t seem very approachable or loving. It’s impossible to understand exactly how God felt about what he did to Job. It’s also impossible to know if Job was truly righteous or if he was guilty of some punishment-deserving deed. These impossibilities make it frustrating to read the text because we can never know the truth. Although I don’t usually welcome frustration, I think it might provide a way for readers to feel just a touch of what Job felt during his misery.
I Swear On Everything I Own, I'm Innocent
Job is getting angry, you won't like Job when he is angry.
This section of Job starts with Eliphaz claiming that no man could be righteous before God. "Can a man be of Benefit to God?" Eliphaz asks many rhetorical questions which all sum to "God does not care about you!" This is the same argument we saw from the scientist in "God on Trial" I believe. Why would God make a hundred thousand million stars and care about one man? God simply has not yet noticed that Job is suffering according to Eliphaz, but once god does notice He will do something about it. Bildad does not even think that Job is owed an explanation. "Dominion and awe belong to God; he established order in the heights of heaven." Bildad thinks that God is too busy to be bothered by Job's plight. This only makes Job more forceful with wanting to plead his case before God. Job seems quite upset with God now opposed to simply wanting to be able to state his case. "I would state my case before him and fill my mouth with arguments." Is what Job says he would do if he could only find God. Job seems to think that God has hidden himself so that Job can't make his case and therefore God does not have to answer for what He has done. Eliphaz would seem to agree with the statement that God is hidden but not because he does not want to talk to Job, simply because he does not have to talk to Job because He is God. Job then continues on to make his case about other people disserving punishment more than he does in ch 24. In ch 27 there is a hint as to why Job is so upset at his friends, and why the friends may be punished at the end of the book. In Ch. 27 verses 4-6 Job says that he will never say a wrong thing and this is why he will not curse god or admit to having sinned. The friends have been telling him to speak against God and die and Job refuses because that would not be a truthful thing to say. Job is insistent that he cannot admit to doing anything wrong because that would be a lie.
I like Job's Friends.
Job grows increasingly impatient and begins lamenting the injustice that God lets wicked people prosper while he and countless other innocent people suffer. In chapter 23 Job wants to confront God and complain, but Job can't physically find God to do it. Job believes that wisdom is hidden from human minds, that no one can know. Since job can't see God face to face, he resolves to pursuing wisdom by fearing God and avoiding evil. In chapter 27 Job gives all these examples of him maintaining his integrity. Job says that he will die before he puts away his integrity.
Bildad and Eliphaz also are curt in their answers to Job. In chapter 25, Bildad only had six verses, when before it was in the 20's, when refuting Job. Eliphaz takes the other approach, he is long winded but accuses Job of high crimes and misdemeanours for which he supposes God was now punishing him. Chapter 22 is my favorite of this section. Eliphaz is totally justifiable in his thinking: Job is being punished, so Job did something wrong. Eliphaz accuses Job of oppressing and being unjust to the world and people around him (v. 5-11) and of committing treason with God (v. 12-14). Eliphaz then compares Job to the world of the old (v. 15-20) Here it seems as though Eliphaz might be hinting at the flood (v. 16) and that they were punished for doing wrong, just like Job is. But at the end, Eliphaz doesn't just leave Job out to dry, but gives him very good counsel, assuring him that, if he would take it, God would return mercy to him and he should return to his former prosperity (v. 21-30). Ironically, this is what actually happens in the end.
I believe that the friends are just being themselves and have concern for Job's life. If they didn't care, i don't think that they would waste the time arguing with him. Yes, maybe his friends are a little harsh, but its comes from a good place.
Round and Round and Round...
Job Chapter 22 starts with Eliphaz being able to speak a second time. This time he starts by asking two questions “Can a mortal be of use to God? Can even the wisest be of service to him?” (Job 22:2). After hearing Job’s response to his suffering for almost 21 chapters, Eliphaz is wondering if God has any actual use for Job or for any humans. He goes on to discuss if humans choose to make God the highest in the heavens then no one, including Job can questions what God knows. We cannot question the source of evil, if we are not prepared to question the source of goodness. This is very similar to a moment in the movie “God on Trial” when a man asks even in his darkest moment, where all the goodness comes from? Eliphaz ends this chapter by telling Job that “[God] will deliver even those who are guilty” (Job 22:30). This speech is very similar to the one the Eliphaz gave earlier in this book and he ends with the same conclusion that Job has sinned and that he must repent.
Job has a very similar response to the one he gave earlier after Eliphaz finished speaking the first time. He restates that he has done nothing wrong and that God does whatever he desires. Job also complains about the amount of violence in the world. He still doesn’t understand why God punishes those who are good and leaves those who are evil to continue on with their wicked lives. Job finishes this chapter by asking God to “Prove me a liar and show that there is nothing in what I say?” (Job 24:25). Just like in the previous chapters Job refuses to believe that he has done anything wrong and just like in the previous chapters he is asking God to show him where he has sinned.
Bildad then speaks again, but is only given six verses this time to say what he wants. He asks, “How then can a mortal be righteous before God?” (Job 25:4). Obviously, Bildad’s opinion has become less important throughout the Book of Job.
Job once again refutes his friends opinions and still cannot believe that he did anything wrong. He tries to hold on to his righteousness and claims again that he will not curse God and that God has personally made his “soul bitter” (Job 27:2). Job asks God to hear the cries of the righteous and punish the wicked.
These chapters seem incredibly similar to the earlier chapters. Eliphaz and Bildad and Job all seem to be repeating what they have already said. The friends are still blaming Job for his sins and Job is responding and says that he hasn’t sinned and that he wants to talk to God, so that God can explain to Job why he is being punished. We already have heard these speeches and responses and the reader seems to be going around and around not getting any farther into solving Job’s problems or returning his life back to normal.
there's nothing worse than a bitter soul
The best way to understand what I mean by this is to refer to Soelle’s three phases of human suffering. Job’s suffering prior to and during the dialogue of Job 3-27 is summed up by Job’s question to his friends, “Why do you, like God, pursue me, never satisfied with my flesh?” (Job 19:22). This is Soelle’s phase 1; Job is lamenting the fact that he is suffering at the hands of others, and expressing his belief that there is no reason he should be suffering. This lamentation of his suffering halts promptly at the end of Job 27. Next, the meditative words on wisdom in Chapter 28 turn the text away from suffering momentarily, and in that moment Job’s phase 2 is becoming phase 3.
As a transition of character, Job 28 neatly separates Job’s argumentative voice in Job 3-27 from his more subdued voice in Job 29-31. At the same time, as a transition of content, Job 28 divides Job expressing his frustrations with the injustices of his suffering through dialogue (see Job 10:1), from the later Job who ceases to address people, and pleads with God to reveal what his injustices are (see Job 31:5-6). In other words, after a phase 2 style argument with friends the idea of wisdom in chapter 28 prefaces Job’s heightened state of mind in phase 3, during which he has moved beyond seeking the sympathy of peers and wants only to know what he has done wrong.
My main point of interest in this section of the text is that whether the neutral voice of Job 28 represents the narrator outside of Job’s story, or Job briefly getting outside of himself does not matter necessarily. What’s beautiful about Job 28 is that for a brief moment, Judaism’s higher reality of wisdom not only acts as a turning point for the text, but wisdom imbeds itself in Job in such a way that the process of prayerful debt so important to Judaism rises to the surface of the text.
Monday, October 25, 2010
Is there a reason?
One of the issues that these men deal with in the film is the idea of God punishing children for the sins of the father. These men do not believe that they deserve what is happening to them or that they have broken their covenant with God but, given the possibility that they were not, in fact, good men, they do not understand why God chooses to punish children. The film brings up scriptural examples of God killing the firstborn of Egypt because of Pharoah's unwillingness to grant the Israelites freedom and of God killing the child of David and Bathsheba for their indiscretions. The men also discuss their experiences with this. One man tells the poignant story of how he was made to choose between his three sons. At the end of the film, one of the older men sees his son selected to go to the gas chamber instead of him. These men, unlike David or Pharoah, do not see how they have sinned and do not see the justice in the suffering of thier children even if they have, in some way, caused God to turn from them.
I find that this issue in particular--of allowing the father to live and killing the son--is reflected in the book of Job. The first way that God tests Job is by killing his children. In the end God restores Job by giving him new children. The taking of children as means of punishment or trial seems to be a common scriptural theme and is a great part of Job's suffering. To the men in the film God on Trial and to Job, the suffering caused by losing their children is likely greater than the thought of their own suffering and death and brings up questions of the justness of a God that would allow the innocent to be punished in that way.
"Now God's guilty, what do we do? We pray."
The contradicting views of God are evident from the very beginning of the trial. The man who acts as the “plaintiff” sees God as a bastard who is all-powerful yet chooses not to stop the suffering of the Jews. Another man who speaks up reminds the blockhouse that bad things have happened before, Jews have suffered before, and the breaking of the covenant is a habitual thing. This God, who ritually breaks the covenant, is violent yet loving, purifying not punishing. One man puts a twist on the saying, “Don’t hate the player, hate the game” by referring to God as a surgeon and the Nazis as a knife: “Don’t hate the surgeon, hate the knife.” This reflects the hope some of the Jews still have, the belief that this suffering is a test of God and of their faith (sound familiar?). I think this is how Job’s friends see God – don’t take this punishment personally, it just needs to happen. You did something wrong, you needed to be tested, this God is still here with you in your suffering – it is all part of trusting God and having faith in him. Like some of the Jews in the blockhouse, the friends believe in the act-consequence worldview, and this is how things are.
Other men take the complete opposite view of God. The idea that God just works with whomever he wants is thrown into the mix – when he was on the Jews’ side, it worked out. Now, God has taken the Nazis’ side and turned his back on the Jews of Auschwitz. This is a powerful God who chooses not to stop the suffering “his people” are enduring. I think this is where Job, especially in the second set of dialogues, has a foot placed. Job certainly doesn’t see the personal, loving God of the defenders in the blockhouse. He has suffered so much, lost everything, and when he calls to God, he hears nothing in response. He hasn’t gone so far as to deny God, but he cannot see how this can yield any good.
Though the opinions and images of God are in striking contrast during the trial, as the movie comes to a close and the selected are being taken away, a common bond between the men emerge. As the selected are taken to the gas chambers, all of them, whether they were adamant about their faith or not, begin to pray. The God of the hopeful Jews in Auschwitz may not have been everyone’s God, but when suffering dominates your life, you need something to cling to.
Life of Pi Spoiler Alert
The prisoners argument strongly reminded me of the book Life of Pi. In the novel, the protagonist, Pi, finds himself on a lifeboat with a zebra, an orangutan, a hyena and a bengal tiger. In the course of his journey, Pi witnesses the hyena eat the zebra and the orangutan and the tiger eat the hyena. Eventually, Pi is rescued, but when he tells his story to the authorities, they don’t believe him. Pi then tells them another version of the story in which the orangutan is his mother, the zebra is a sailor, and the hyena is the ship’s cook who killed Pi’s mother and ate the sailor, and Pi is the bengal tiger. Pi then asks the authorities which version of the story they prefer and their answer is the story about the animals. Pi views his faith in God in the same sense- it may be less realistic and it may not even be true at all, but it’s better than the alternative.
The same can be said for Job. Job has lost everything and even his wife tells him to turn from God. Job acknowledges what God has done to him but he does not waver in his faith, saying, “for I know that my Redeemer lives, and that at the last he will stand upon the earth; and after my skin has been thus destroyed, then in my flesh I shall see God, who I shall see on my side, and my eyes shall behold, and not another” (19:25-26). Despite Job’s plight, he holds onto his faith, possibly because he knows that if he denounces God, then he truly is left with nothing. Similar to Pi, Job knows that faith in God, even in a seemingly unjust God, is better than no God at all.
At the end of the film, many of the prisoners are selected to be gassed. One prisoner who was intent on his lack of faith in God finds that he has been selected. In response, he breaks down and begins to pray. In hopeless situations such as these described, though it may be beyond reason to believe in God, one finds that faith is better than the alternative.
I Want My Weakling God
If God is mighty, if God is omniscient, if God is all powerful and totally just, then why couldn’t he stop the Holocaust or simply prevent it from ever happening? A God who is capable of stopping suffering and chooses not to is a bastard, which seems to be the conclusion that the Auschwitz prisoners come to in the PBS documentary ‘God on Trial’. It is interesting that these prisoners really wrestle with their concepts of God during the trial. They seem to be circling around two options: God is a powerful bastard who “was not ever good, he was only on our side” or God is not actually powerful, but instead God is personal, God is suffering in Auschwitz, God is being gassed with us. The men seem to mentally settle on the former option when they charge God with murder, when they decide that he is indeed guilty. However, it is not so easy to know what option they choose in their hearts. One man says, “Now God is guilty. What do we do now? Now we pray.” There is something comforting in praying to God; there is something comforting in feeling that God suffers and that God cares.
Job also suffered in the same manner that the Auschwitz prisoners suffered: his children were taken from him and killed, his possessions were destroyed, his body was broken. In the midst of his suffering, Job also called God a bastard, in quite a few more words. Job wondered if maybe God wasn’t fair, but Job still wanted God to be with him in his heart. Even while calling God a bastard, Job still wanted the bastard. This could be why the prose tells readers, “In all of this Job did not sin or charge God with wrongdoing.” (1:22). Maybe Job questioned God, but on the other hand, he still wanted this God to suffer with him, he didn’t really want God to be a bastard, even as mentally he couldn’t deny that he might very well be.
The Holocaust victims are an extreme case of what Job is going through. They allow us to see that even while men call God a bastard, they will still pray to him. ‘God on Trial’ actually helps me feel more sympathetic towards Job. Job is not whiny and Job is not some hotheaded jerk who simply wants to argue his point with his friends. Job is a man in pain. His life experience suggests that the God he needs is either a bastard or a weakling. Job’s worldview is shifting and if God wouldn’t have come back in his whirlwind, the book of Job would have probably ended with Job realizing that “God is [his] God, even if he doesn’t exist.”
Wednesday, October 20, 2010
Punishment By the Sword
In chapter fifteen, Eliphaz does not change his argument but simply reinforces it. He strongly emphasizes that Job must have sinned, saying he (Job) has “empty counsel” or “vain knowledge” (verse two) and telling him that he must repent if he wants to escape further judgments. Job responds by telling him he is a “miserable comforter” and bluntly states he is tired of hearing him talk (“is there no end to your empty words?”—ch. 16, v. 2-3).
Bildad begins his dialogue in chapter eighteen, sounding extremely frustrated. He asks Job why he considers them stupid like cattle, irritated that Job refuses to adhere to their advice (to confess before God). Instead of comforting Job in his time of need or even trying to bribe him into repenting, Bildad proceeds to remind Job of all the horrible things that could happen if he did unknowingly sin and does not repent. Job reminds his friends to not be too quick to defend their idea of righteous guarantees rewards/sin guarantees suffering, lest it come back to bite them.
Zophar perceives something that Job says to be threatening/an attempt to rebuke the three friends. Like the other three friends, Zophar strongly encourages Job to repent. Job asks his friends to stay silent for a while (as they did initially) but to “continue mocking” (ch. 21, v. 3) after he has spoken. (He doesn’t trust that they will be supportive, seeing as they have started speaking to him in an almost threatening manner.) Job admits to his friend that he is upset with God and he is very afraid. He is afraid because although he has faith that God is powerful and such, He is still allowing these things to happen to him (Job) and he can’t see a logical reason why God would do this.
Friends suck.
Eliphaz starts off the passage accusing Job of folly, implying that maybe Job just considered himself more righteous than he actually was. Eliphaz seemed to mock Job like, "ha ha, you suck, I'm more righteous than you." Job starts arguing back, that basically his friends are not there for him and that they don't understand what he is going through, which is true, I'm sure that God never placed a bet on their lives as he did Job's. Not cool God. I agree in a way with Job that his friend's should comfort him more when he is going through the worst of times and not attack his faith and beliefs, but at the same time they should add a little bit of criticism in there for how Job is basically questioning his faith and on the pursuit of cursing God's name. Job thinks this is God just adding to his suffering as he explains in chapters 16 and 17, "They gape at me with their mouth, They strike me reproachfully on the cheek, They gather together against me. Had has delivered me to the ungodly, and turned me over to the hands of the wicked." (Job 16:10-11) As far I'm concerned that's the closest you can get to cursing God without actually cursing him, which is what God was betting Satan Job wouldn't do.
Even during the Prayer for Job's Relief he was cursing his friends saying that they are "mockers" and he is getting ready to face death but they still bother and make him more miserable than God has already made him. Bilidad then steps in and tells Job that only the wicked are to be punished so obviously Job is a wicked man who has commit ed many sins even if he had not realized he was committing them. Bilidad is also pretty angry that Job is arguing with the friends as shown in chapter 18:2-3, where Bilidad basically says Job shut up, listen to me because I'm much smarter and don't call me stupid and goes on to tell Job how"wicked" he really is for he isn't praising God at this point in time. Job still believes that God is the almighty but that Job is such a small aspect in God's life that he doesn't want God's attention because God has ruthless powers and Job is tired of being punished, yet he still wants to see God in the after life. The argument over Job's "wickedness" continues on to Zophar who know gives a sermon over the meaning of being a wicked man and what happens to those who are wicked, well basically "everything under the sun" can happen to a wicked man.
Poor Job, had my friend's talked to me like that in a time of need, I probably would lay there and wait for death as well. Job's friend's are supposed to help reaffirm Job's faith, instead they are driving him farther from God. Perhaps that is why God punishes and sends them away at the end of the story.
Where then is my hope?
The second cycle of dialogue in the book of Job begins in chapter 15 with Eliphaz one again criticizing Job’s belief that he has done nothing wrong. Eliphaz characterizes Job’s claims as “unprofitable talk”(v.3) and accuses him of “choosing the tongue of the crafty”(v.4). Eliphaz then comes to the conclusion that Job has condemned himself though his own utterances. Job then goes on to respond to Eliphaz (and the others) by chastising them for speaking against him, rather than offering encouragement in his time of distress (16:5) Rather than support and stand as witnesses on his behalf, they have accused him of sin.
In chapter 17, once again Job reflects back over his suffering. His body has rapidly deteriorated and his friends have offered no comfort. However, Job seems to find some sort of hope in the midst of his suffering. His hope does not come from his friends, an ease in his suffering, or from reflecting back over his past life (v.11). In v. 12, it is suggested that there is a light that has begun to ignite in Job, in spite of the darkness that surrounds him. In his commentary (p.126), Janzen seems to think that the “they “ in v. 12, is referring to the previous verse’s “desires of my heart.” Janzen believes that this light is the desires of Job’s heart and that his wish for death (in previous passages such as 3:21, 6:8-9,etc.) has disappeared.
While I don’t think that Janzen’s commentary on this passage is completely ridiculous, I don’t buy his argument that Job’s wish for death has disappeared. In verses 15 and 16, Job asks his “mother” or “sister”, “where then is my hope? Who will see my hope?” It seems to me that Job feels that there is no reason to continue to exist. The passage then ends with Job asking, “ Will it go down to the bars of Sheol? Shall we descend together into the dust? (v.16) I am not sure who or what Job is referring to when he says “it” and “we.” Is he referring to hope or God or something else entirely? The last several verses in chapter seventeen were extremely confusing and frustrating, and I have yet to come to any firm conclusions about what the author is trying to communicate.
It's good to have friends...?
Eliphaz starts speaking in chapter 15, he is pretty much mocking Job, asking if he could really be as mighty and righteous as he thinks he is. In verses 7-11 he keeps asking rude questions, trying to get the point of Job not being as great as he thinks he is across. Eliphaz asks, “Are you the firstborn of the human race? Were you brought forth before the hills?” He obviously isn’t wondering, he is just putting Job in his place. He goes on to tell Job that the wicked get what they deserve, implying that all of these bad things have happened to Job because he has deserved them. In chapter 18 Jobs other “friend” Bildad comes in. He is about as helpful as Eliphaz was, and states the same idea that God only punishes humans if they deserve it. He goes through a long rant about all the terrible things that happen to the wicked, such as “ terrors frightening from every side” and “thrust from light into darkness”. These types of things are exactly what Job has been going through, but instead of having some sympathy for the guy, Bildad says, “Surely such are the dwellings of the ungodly, such is the place of those who do not know God.” The last friend we hear from in this section is Zophar in chapter 20. Zophar seems pissed off compared to the other two that have spoken, he starts out with “Pay attention!” he’s not playing around. Zophar tries to make the point that if the wicked are enjoying life, it’s only momentarily and eventually they will feel the wrath of God. I’m not sure if he is trying to reassure Job, or just let him know his time has come to feel the terrible hand of the Almighty, but he has the same “just God” view as the others. During all of this dialogue between Job and his friends, Job remains his innocence, but in some chapters this doesn’t even seem like his main focus. In chapter 19 Job is pretty much just saying how bad God has made his life and how his friends aren’t making it any better. In chapter 21 Job is explaining to his friends how the things that have happened to him are not fair because all of these wicked people ”spend their days in prosperity” and “in peace they go down to Sheol”. I guess if I were Job I’d be upset too.
Desperate Hope
Job goes back and forth on many things. In the last reading he went back and forth on death being a relief or something bad. In this section Job has no hope in chapter 17 and most of chapter 19. He says, “Who can see any hope for me?” (17:15) and in 19:7-20 Job describes how God is not answering his call for help (v. 7) and that God “uproots [his] hope like a tree,” (v. 10). Then Job begs his friends to have pity for him, (v. 21-22). The rest of this chapter was interesting to me. Is Job experiencing some hope or is it just wishful thinking that he knows is unrealistic?
First, Job wants his words to be recorded to give a permanent record of what happened to him (v. 23-24). Verse 25 struck me because of the many times that I have heard Jesus referred to as the Redeemer. However, my Bible had a foot note that said it could also be translated as defender. The Hebrew word is go’el which refers to a person that protected a family’s inheritance, (Wilson 208). Wilson says that God is referred to as a go’el in the Book of Isaiah. In this sense God is the punisher and the redeemer. The next two verses are seen by some as a belief in an afterlife because he says that after his skin has been destroyed Job will be in his own flesh and see God. Some see this as Job believing in some sort of resurrection with a new body. I think it is more likely that Job is wanting a chance to defend himself against God. The recorded words (v. 23-24) could serve as his go’el and his new flesh could be his flesh recovered from the boils. In verse 27 Job says that his “heart yearns within” him to see God. Job does not think that he has done anything wrong and since conventional wisdom says that God is always just, Job wants the chance to either make his case with God (13:3) or get an explanation from God.
Monday, October 18, 2010
Job 3:1-14:22: Shattering the Chart of Suffering
The reading by Solle, Suffering, provided an example of a factory-worker boy who suffered in a similar way to Job: inescapably. The boy said of his agony, “It often simply cannot be endured...And yet I have to endure it anyway. There is nothing one can do to change it.”(67) Both Job and the boy have been, in a disparaging way, forced to come to terms with their relentless pain, so much so that the only alternative Job wishes for is death. If Job could see Solle's “chart of suffering,” he would see that at that point of his suffering (as well of that of the young boy) he was entering Phase Two of “Powerlessness.” This would mean to Job that, if he lives long enough, if he endures his blood-sucking powerless feeling long enough, he would eventually pass through Phase Two, in which he would accept his powerlessness within the structure God provided for him, and into Phase Three, where he would conquer his powerlessness.
Solle's chart of suffering might have imparted a bit of hope for Job – that his variety of suffering is prone to eventual mitigation, but Job would have had a long way to go before being healed. Before he could be healed, he would have first had to accept his suffering, which generally comes after at least partial understanding of the situation, which Job had definitely not yet achieved. He had no clear answer for his agony: his friends blamed him for sinning, God didn't provide any helpful explanation, and so Job was left in a whirlwind of dark confusion.
The world that God created and which he was said to have cared for felt, to Job, to be a cruel joke. Job mocked God's concern for the tortuous world saying, “What are human beings, that you make so much of them, that you set your mind on them, visit them every morning, test them every moment?” (7:17-18) At this point, Job sees God as a cruel landlord who has nothing better to do than make the lives of his tenants miserable. He cannot yet be healed because the world and it's relationship to God does not make any sense. Job's world was turned upside down by his unexplained suffering, his belief in a just God shattered, and his optimism for relief quickly escapes.
At least there is hope for a tree...
Job in Phase 2
In the reading for today, 3:1-14:22, we see what could be described as Phase 2 Job. Soelle describes phase 2 as "lamenting" and "able to speak". When Job's friends come to him, he is finally able to articulate his suffering. His friends, though, are of no help. They are insensitive to Job's plight and insinuate that he brought his misery on himself. Still, the presence of his friends allows Job to begin to speak about his problems, which Soelle claims is "an indispensable step on the way to the third stage".
There is a problem when considering the third stage, though. We never really see Job coming to terms with his grief, only lamenting it. God comes and speaks to Job and repairs his life. In a sense, divine intervention essentially bypasses the third stage, or nullifies the entire process. Still, Soelle's piece gives us an interesting way to look at Job.
Thursday, October 14, 2010
Inconsistent Countenance
First, it is made clear that like Qoheleth for whom life is essentially wearisome, for Job, life is ultimately troublesome:
3:3 “Let the day perish in which I was born”
3:10 “because it did not shut the doors of my mother’s womb, and hide trouble from my eyes”
Simultaneously, Job accepts the imperfect nature of creation:
14:4 “who can bring a clean thing out of an unclean? No one can.”
Nonetheless, Job passionately laments the fact that his sincere belief in his own innocence means nothing to God. He doubts the value of earnestly pursuing a life of righteousness, because his suffering is experienced as injustice:
9:29 “I shall be condemned; why then do I labor in vain?”
His radical opinion is that nothing makes humans truly righteous in relation to God:
9:33 “There is no umpire between us, who might lay his hand on us both.”
Job’s friends fail to console him. They suggest his suffering would not have begun, nor would it persist if he was truly innocent. But, Job understands the underlying belief that guides their opinions, that:
8:20 “God will not reject a blameless person”
Despite this understanding, it is Job’s opinion that the belief in a perfectly just system of punishment and reward is nonsense. He points to the fact that people who worship false idols, break commandments, and fail to live a righteous life, often suffer less than those who do uphold the teachings of proverbial wisdom:
9:2 “Indeed, I know that this is so; but how can a mortal be just before God?
9:15 “Though I am innocent, I cannot answer him;”
12:6 “The tents of robbers are at peace, and those who provoke God are secure, who bring their god in their hands.”
12:9 “Who among all these does not now that the hand of the Lord has done this?
13:12 “Your maxims are proverbs of ashes, your defenses are defenses of clay”
After all of this talk, this section finally reveals itself as the heart-and-soul of the whole book when Job proclaims his “Despondent Prayer”. Job’s final point is that he is does not feel impious for wanting God to explain to him his wrongs and free his soul of its bitterness. Above all, however, Job accepts his earthliness and the inevitability of his withering away.
13:23 “How many are my iniquities and my sins? Make me know my transgression and my sin.”
14:19-20 “the waters wear away the stones; the torrents wash away the soil of the earth; so you destroy the hope of mortals. You prevail forever against them, and they pass away; you change their countenance and send them away”
Based on my reading, the heart-and-soul message communicated by the book of Job, is that humans can accept God's reality, but they can never fully understand or explain it, as proverbial wisdom seeks to do.
Monday, October 11, 2010
Why Job?
Verse one of chapter one claims that Job was “blameless and upright.” Perhaps these horrible things happen to Job because Satan is trying to point out that Job is not as righteous as God sees him to be. In Job’s defense, Job does not curse god or even blame him for the tragedy which has befallen him. “In all this Job did not sin with his lips” (2:10b). What about Job’s heart? Even if Job does not outwardly curse God, would it not be possible for Job to curse God in his heart?
The more troubling part of this story is that God allows Satan to convince him to do these awful things to Job. In Hebrew, ha-satan probably refers to an officer of the king of the Persian empire who travels around the empire testing the loyalty of the kings followers. So, it is possible that this is just an employee of God doing his job. If this is the case it seems easier to understand why God allowed this to happen, but to me it is still very difficult to justify that God would allow such a good, innocent man to suffer.
Lemme Break It Down for You
'The Accuser'
In this context, the Hebrew “Satan” is “hassatan” meaning “the Satan.” Hassatan means “the Accuser” or someone who tests people for God to see if they are loyal to Him. This is what Satan means when he says he has been “roaming through the earth” in verse seven (roaming through the earth to test people for God). Testing Job’s faith does not profit God nor Satan, the test is for the audience to be left with questions to think about (Who’s responsible for Job’s suffering? What does he learn from it?). (Wilson 24)
Verses 1:13-22 tell of the first test of Job. Messengers came to tell Job that his donkeys, oxen, and camels were taken away, and his servants were killed. His daughters and sons were eating together in their oldest brother’s house when the house crushed them due to a strong wind. (It is unclear as to why Job was not invited to join his sons and daughters at their house.) Job responds by tearing his robe and shaving his head (marking public mourning). Unlike Satan’s prediction, Job praises the name of God (v. 21).
In the beginning of chapter two, Satan and God repeat almost exactly what they say in chapter one vv. 6-8. Only this time Satan says if God inflicts personal harm upon Job, this time he curse God to His face (v. 5). Job then breaks out in boils. When his wife says in verse nine “Do you still retain your integrity?” She nearly echoes what God says in verse three (“He still retains his integrity…”). In verse eleven Job’s friends appear but don’t yet speak to him because they see how extreme his pain and suffering is.
Job's Faithfulness
Chapter 1 then shifts settings from an earthly realm to a heavenly realm. Here God meets with all the "heavenly beings" and Satan. At first I was confused as why Satan was there, and how he could possibly even be there. If Satan was the opposite of God, full of evil, and wanting to destroy everything God does, then why would he be in heaven? From previous readings in the Bible i always thought that God couldn't be in the presence of anything than less than perfect, that's why Satan fell in the first place. But after reading Wilson's interpretation he gave me some insight on how that might be. Wilson suggest that the "Satan" that is spoken of in Job isn't the same Satan that is the fallen angle that is mentioned in other biblical books. Wilson explains that this is Satan should be interpreted as the "Accuser". In the Persian courts there was a position that would go out and test the people's faithfulness to their king, this position was called Satan. This would explain why Satan could be in heaven and talking directly to God; because he is a "worker of God". So with this cleared up, it makes the rest of the setup of the story make sense. God wasn't boasting or showing off, He was just questioning Satan ("the Accuser") about his servant Job. Now with all this said, and even if it does simplify the story, I don't believe that Wilson is correct. I just think that if this were true, having two possibly names identifying "Satan", one being on God's court and the other being the evil and malicious figure who wants to destroy God, that there would be more clarity in this book and the Bible in general. The idea of God and Satan, goodness and evil, are so different and so black and white that it makes no sense for there to be confusion on who Satan is and his role.
But then this goes back to the question of , Was God boasting, showing off, or tempting Satan? Was it God who told Satan to ruin Job's life? And I think that God was not showing off, and it wasn't God who "told" Satan to ruin Job's life. I think that between God and Satan a question came up on the integrity of Job's faithfulness, and instead of God blatantly giving an answer He let it play out on the earthly realm. God allowed for Satan to tempt Job, and allowed Satan to ruin Job's life. I think that God allowed a good man to suffer in order to reveal God's sovereignty and supremacy of divine wisdom over human wisdom. In the end, Job realized that he didn't know anything, and that he doesn't have the position to know (42:1-9)
But I believe that we are supposed to be focusing more on Job than the reason of God's allowance for suffering. Job was tested twice, once when he lost all of his family and fortunes, and then again with this health. Still, Job never once cursed God (1:22, 2:10). But this doesn't mean that Job wasn't angry, upset, or questioned God. Job was human ("there once was a man" 1:1), he questioned like a human, but his loyalty and faithfulness was never compromised. This is what i think that major theme and purpose of the book is. To love and honor God in the good and the bad (2:10).
How did Job not curse God?
In the very beginning of the book of Job, we learn a lot about what type of person Job is. First and foremost, Job is described as a man. This fact is stated so that readers know that he is a human and therefore is not perfect. The first verse continues to describe Job as someone one who is “blameless and upright, one who feared God and turned away from evil” (Job 1:1). Then all of Job’s blessings are listed. He is very rich and has seven sons and three daughters, who he makes burnt offerings for. Job seems to be living a fulfilling life on earth and working hard to be a good servant of God.
However, God is up in heaven, hanging out with the other heavenly beings and he strikes up a conversation with Satan. He casually asks Satan if he heard about Job, his wonderful servant. The first time that he asks this, I question if God is really bragging about how wonderful Job is or if he is just telling Satan about Job. Satan however, even if God did not mean to be bragging takes it that way and responses that the only reason that Job fears you, is because you have given him all of these wonderful possessions, but if you were to take all of those possessions away from Job, he would curse you. God agrees to test this theory out and Satan destroys all of Job’s worldly possessions.
While Satan may be the one doing the acts of evil against Job, I believe God is still in control and that Satan is working for him. God asked Satan to test Job and gives him guidelines upon which he can do this. I struggle with the idea that God is using his power for evil in this first situation. I really believe that God is using Job to show how powerful he actually is. And Job responds much better than I ever could, “Naked I came from my mother’s womb and naked I shall return there; the Lord gave, and the Lord has taken away; blessed be the name of the Lord” (Job 1: 21).
God then tests Job a second time. He once again is having a conversation with the heavenly beings and starts talking to Satan again. This time I am sure that God is bragging about what a great servant Job is. God says that Job “still persists in his integrity, although you incited me against him, to destroy him for no reason” (Job 2:3). God is actually taunting Satan in this situation. Satan responds that anyone can handle getting all their worldly possessions taken away from them, but he will surely curse you if you “stretch out your hand now and touch his bone and his flesh, and he will curse you to your face” (Job 2:5). Job is inflicted with sores all over his body and still does not curse God.
The second time this happens is where I start to have a problem with God. He has already made Job suffer, why does he feel the need to do it again? I have a better understanding of why God took away his material possessions, so that he could prove that he is all-powerful and supreme. However, the second time Job gets tested, I feel that God is picking on him and instead of being a benevolent and gracious God and trying to prove that he is all-powerful, he has become cruel and mean. Where did this God come from?
Then God becomes even crueler because I think that Job gets tested a third time. Not from Satan himself, but from his wife, who asks him to “Curse God and Die” (Job 2:9). The one person who has been with Job through all of his heartache, asks him to give up his faith. However, Job remains strong and replies, “You speak as any foolish woman would speak. Shall we receive the good at the hand of God, and not receive the bad? In all this Job did not sin with his lips” (Job 2:10). God already has tested Job twice before, why does he need to go for the trifecta? God frustrates me with how he uses Job. The problem I have isn’t with God's supreme power or that he can choose whatever way he wants to demonstrate that power. It’s that God’s reasons for messing with Job seem to be cruel and evil, which seems so far away from the God that we know from the other books of the bible.
Sunday, October 10, 2010
Trust Issues
However, if the introduction is what happened, I have some problems with God. He seems so cocky when he’s bragging about his super devoted servant Job and the fact that he would just mess around with a righteous man with no clear reason other than to stick it to Satan is a little disconcerting to say the least. I also found God’s statement to Satan at the end of 2:3 to be a little odd. My translation reads “He still holds fast his integrity, although you incited me against him to destroy him without reason.” I find the use of the word “incited” to be slightly inappropriate seeing as God is the one who randomly started bragging about Job rather than Satan initially provoking him. This phrase makes God look like he can’t take responsibility for his actions. Even if Satan did provoke him, a truly omnipotent being would be able to resist the temptation to make a bet with an inferior creature like Satan.
Because I consider the prologue to be a speculation, rather than fact, I don’t think it is helpful to strongly focus on it. The reason I choose not to overly focus on the prologue is exemplified in the Goon Bible Project and South Park videos (http://bit.ly/K55D and http://cart.mn/dvl2d5 respectively). The portrayal God in both videos is that he’s basically a tyrant who decided to impress Satan for some unknown reason. This depiction is drawn from what I believe to be one person’s opinion that was inserted into the scripture to make sense of the dialogue. Because people take this opinion as truth, they make the possible mistake of attributing negative characteristics to God.
I’ve noticed that a common tendency when discussing the book of Job is to discuss God’s role. I think, however, that Job’s story is the most compelling which is probably why the book is called “Job” instead of “God.” My opinion of Job in this first section is that he is really wise. In 2:9 when his wife is being foolish Job is quick to correct. She is trying to convince Job that he should curse God for his misfortunes. I respect Job for realizing that good and bad are necessary aspects of life when he says “Shall we receive good from God, and shall we not receive evil?” Most people would be more inclined to the bratty practice of pouting that life didn’t turn out the way they wanted it to. I think it shows great wisdom that Job welcomes the bad as he would good.
Is God the Bad Guy?
The first two chapters of Job set up the story and get us up to the point where Job has lost everything and his life has completely fallen apart. Job's children have been killed, he is completely destitute, and is in great pain because of boils that he has all over his body. Yet, in all Job's suffering he still worships God and does not curse God for destroying his life.
There are two tests that Job endures. The first takes his family and wealth, and the second makes Job sick. These tests come about because God is having a meeting with his advisers and decides to bring up Job to show "Satan" that Job would not abandon Him if he took away all of his riches. The Satan that is in the book of Job is not the fallen angel that is in other books of the bible. The more correct interpretation for the word in Hebrew is "The Accuser" (Wilson 22). The Accuser was a position in the courts of Persian kings that would go through the kingdom and test peoples faithfulness to the king. This explains why Satan is not an intruder in the court of God and why God is talking to him in a civilized manner. This interpretation causes a lot of confusion in English. Satan in today's society is an evil figure that goes against God and seeks to undermine what God is trying to do. The "Satan" in the book of Job is one of the "Sons of God" who work for God. This means that Satan is not the evil thing in this story because he is only carrying out God's plans. This could mean that God is only doing this to teach a lesson. There is something in this story that the readers are supposed to learn, however I am not sure what that lesson is. The writers of South Park could not figure it out either. The end of the clip is Kyle losing his faith after his parents told him the story of Job, and Kyle is just generally confused by the whole story. If Kyle had read the story closer I am not sure that he would have gotten anything else out of the story either. Basically, I think God may be the bad guy in this story.
Once Job has been afflicted with sores his wife comes to him and tells him to just "curse God and die." Job tells her to stop talking "like a foolish woman." Job did not tell his wife that she was foolish he only said she was speaking "like" a foolish woman. This suggests that Job's wife only wanted to see her husband's suffering end, and not that she was foolish. I like this. All too often I think this verse could be used to give reasons to oppress women but a close reading of the text shows us that there is nothing of the sort in the text.