Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Can you pull in the Leviathan with a fishhook?

Job presents some very interesting concepts and questions. In the beginning of Job we have G-d being swayed by Satan to allow the "testing" of Job. This sets the stage for the long dialogue that follows between Job, his friends, and finally G-d himself. A large theme of the book seems to be one that was touched on in Ecclesiastes, stemming from the idea that G-d is in heaven and we are on earth. Job is told not to challenge or to question G-d -- it is not his right as the creation to challenge the Creator. He can't even pull in the Leviathan that G-d created with a fishhook.

Job's friends throughout the dialogue push for him to repent of his sin, whatever that may be. In what seems to be the worldview held by Proverbs, they believe that as long as you live a righteous life, you will be rewarded. Only the sinful are punished. This runs as another common theme with Qoheleth, who seems to disagree with the truth of this worldview. Job insists that he has done nothing wrong. He questions G-d's judgment.

There seems to be a distinction between questioning and challenging G-d in the book of Job. To challenge G-d is wrong. Challenging G-d is to assume the possibility that G-d made a bad decision or didn't think things through enough. It's a challenge to G-d's perfection. This may be wrong because as humans, we cannot fully understand the will of G-d (like our old friend Qoheleth). To question G-d though does not seem to be as big of an issue. After questioning why he is being made to suffer, Job is still praised for his righteousness. Job was not presuming that G-d might be in the wrong. Rather, he was trying to understand how G-d was in the right.

A few final thoughts that don't really go into paragraphs: What is the role of Satan before G-d at the beginning of the book? What is a Behemoth? What is a Leviathan, and can I have one? Presumably, it can live underwater for 30 minutes or more, and is technically dorm friendly. Might have issues fitting it in a 20 gallon tank though.

No comments:

Post a Comment