Job goes back and forth on many things. In the last reading he went back and forth on death being a relief or something bad. In this section Job has no hope in chapter 17 and most of chapter 19. He says, “Who can see any hope for me?” (17:15) and in 19:7-20 Job describes how God is not answering his call for help (v. 7) and that God “uproots [his] hope like a tree,” (v. 10). Then Job begs his friends to have pity for him, (v. 21-22). The rest of this chapter was interesting to me. Is Job experiencing some hope or is it just wishful thinking that he knows is unrealistic?
First, Job wants his words to be recorded to give a permanent record of what happened to him (v. 23-24). Verse 25 struck me because of the many times that I have heard Jesus referred to as the Redeemer. However, my Bible had a foot note that said it could also be translated as defender. The Hebrew word is go’el which refers to a person that protected a family’s inheritance, (Wilson 208). Wilson says that God is referred to as a go’el in the Book of Isaiah. In this sense God is the punisher and the redeemer. The next two verses are seen by some as a belief in an afterlife because he says that after his skin has been destroyed Job will be in his own flesh and see God. Some see this as Job believing in some sort of resurrection with a new body. I think it is more likely that Job is wanting a chance to defend himself against God. The recorded words (v. 23-24) could serve as his go’el and his new flesh could be his flesh recovered from the boils. In verse 27 Job says that his “heart yearns within” him to see God. Job does not think that he has done anything wrong and since conventional wisdom says that God is always just, Job wants the chance to either make his case with God (13:3) or get an explanation from God.
I was also struck by the idea of "redeemer" in this passage. It doesn't seem to have the positive connotation that I've always heard in the Christian since. The idea of God as punisher and redeemer makes more sense in this passage.
ReplyDeleteI also don't agree with this passage as arguing for an afterlife. I think that Job wants to plead his case to God or at least find out why he is suffering. At times I think Job truly believes he is innocent and at other times I think he believes he may have done something wrong though he doesn't know what.
Jillian, I also saw this passage referring to "hope". Not necessairly that there is hope, but that hope is the thing in question, desire, and pursuit. I found 19:7 interesting because, early Job gave an example that a tree has hope, therefore the tree is better off than he is. Now, Job is relating himself to a tree and saying that he has no hope....I don't know what to make of it exaclty, but that verse got my attention.
ReplyDeleteI am not sure that I believe that Job is talking about the resurrection. I didn't see the connection to an afterlife, but i found your interpretation very intriguing. I also agree that Job is probably meaning and just wanting a defender, than an actual Redeemer (like christ).