In the epilogue of Ecclesiastes (verses 9-14), the epilogist attempts to summarize Qohelet’s message. In my initial reading of Ecclesiastes, I found the epilogue to be very different from the rest of the book; however, upon closer reading, I believe that the epilogue provides a fairly reasonable summary of Ecclesiastes.
The first paragraph of the epilogue serves to state the reliability of Qohelet as a wise teacher. As readers, we can trust that Qohelet was not only wise, but “also taught the people knowledge, weighing and studying and arranging many proverbs” (v. 9). Additionally, Qohelet did not write Ecclesiastes as “some haphazard arrangement” (Brown, 116), but instead, as stated in verse 10, “he wrote words of truth plainly.” This paragraph verifies Qohelet as a reliable narrator.
The next paragraph discusses the nature of wisdom. This paragraph is particularly important to Ecclesiastes because while Qohelet touches on the negative affects of wisdom, verses 11-12 warn the reader that gaining wisdom is a painful experience. According to Brown, the use of the images of “nails” and “goads” depict how “pain is part of the process of learning, analogous to the forceful training of animals” (v. 12). So, while Qohelet generally speaks of wisdom in a positive sense throughout Ecclesiastes, the epilogue offers a word of caution. Additionally, verse 12 warns the reader against “anything beyond” what Qohelet has explored because “of making many books there is no end” (v. 12). Here, the epilogist warns the reader that attempting to seek more wisdom than what Qohelet has sought will never be satisfied. This warning parallels Qohelet’s theme that there is nothing new under the sun.
In the third and final paragraph, the epilogist restates the idea that all will be judged by God. Verse 13 begins by saying “all has been heard,” another restatement that there is nothing new under the sun. Verse 13 goes on to say “fear God, and keep his commandments; for that is the whole duty of everybody.” One could interpret this verse as a commandment tacked onto the end by the Church trying to reconcile Ecclesiastes with the rest of the Bible; however, according to Brown, the concept of fearing God “connotes a reverence of the wholly Other that is devoid of grandiose expectations and cleansed of ulterior motive” and “reflects a realistic faith at its simplest and sincerest level” (119). This parallels Qohelet’s idea that joy can only be found in the simplest aspects of life: eating, drinking, and our relationships with others. Similarly, in faith, one must not expect to gain something through serving God; rather, faith should be exhibited in it’s simplest form: obedience.
The epilogue, though clearly not written by Qohelet, is not completely irrelevant to or out of character from Ecclesiastes. Rather offers some summary of two major themes explored by Qohelet and some insight into how to apply Ecclesiastes to the life of the reader.
Even after multiple readings, I find the ending of Ecclesiastes to be strange. The conclusions it comes to seem to be the opposite of the ones that I come to, as if someone was trying to clean up the philosophical mess that is Qohelet. The only explanation that I've found satisfactory is in Sharp's interpretation of Ecclesiastes as being ironic, though I'm not completely convinced by her claims.
ReplyDeleteBeth,
ReplyDeleteI really liked your interpretation of the epilogue of Ecclesiastes. I still have trouble believing that Qohelet did indeed write this passage because the words seem so removed from the rest of the book. However, I do agree with you that whoever did write this epilogue had a very good insight to what Qohelet was trying to say. They obviously understood what he was trying to say.
I really appreciate your interpretation of the passage. When I read it I was really confused about the purpose and connection to the rest of Ecclesiastes. Your ideas about the purpose made sense to me and helped me better grasp what this last section is saying.
ReplyDeleteI was just like you when I read Ecc for the first time, i thought that it was the exact opposite of what the entire book just said. But, i stopped there and didn't see the possibility of it be cohesive. I like your interpretation of the epilouge, but i am not totally convivnced. It says that Qoh wrote "pleasing words", i have to disagree. He wrote about how everything is meaningless and portrayed God as distant. The "pleasing words" summation, i believe, does not summarize Qoh's words. And the other of the epilouge said that Qoh wrote the truth plainly, lies! Qoh was one of the most confusing writers, there was noting plain and straightforward at all, except for everything is vain, which goes against the idea of "pleasing words".
ReplyDeleteOther than that, i agree with the rest of your interpretations. Im just not totally as convinced as you are.
So... my bible makes no attempt to even to accredit the epilogue to Qooheleth, thus you will get no argument from me about that issue. I really like how you bought verses 11-12 back to the beginning of the book with the whole "there is nothing new under the sun." I feel like there is more to those passages, though. Perhaps it is not merely a warning against attempting to supersede Qooheleth's wisdom, but rather some form of insight against exhausting oneself with things that could distract from the worship of God. I know this seems kind of out there... It's just something to keep in mind.
ReplyDeleteI found your interpretation of Ecclesiastes very interesting. I also don't believe Qoheleth could have written this epilogue.
ReplyDelete