Monday, October 4, 2010

Isn't it Ironic

Ecclesiastes 12:9-14 seems to be one of the most contentious passages of the book. This epilogue has suffered debate over authorship and over intent. It is unclear whether it was added to the book later or, conversely, what the author meant by shifting tone so dramatically near the end of the book. Carolyn Sharp argues for an ironic, deconstructionist reading of the text arguing: "No biblical book is more thoroughly basted in reduction upon reduction of irony than is the book of Qohelet. The multifaceted irony of Qohelet calls the reader into the unexpected intimacy of shared confidence one moment and mocks the reader's expectations from a great distance the next, painstakingly constructs a deceptive rhetorical edifice and then dismantles it in a stroke (Sharp, 41)." Sharp's view implies that the author not only constructed the figure of Qohelet purposefully, but also wrote the epilogue as means of separating the reader from the fictional figure of Qohelet. To Sharp, Qohelet and the epilogue are rhetorical constructions attempting to prove the argument of the author and to show the irony in Qohelet's search for wisdom. Sharp interprets the use of these rhetorical tools as attempting to prove that: "Only obedience, not wisdom as such, can name the human person apart from the injustice, chaos, and disintegration that eternally constitute the cosmos. Wisdom and striving cannot free us, cannot enact justice in the life of the human person or in the eternal rounds of the universe. Obedience alone names us, defines and constitutes us, for that is all of who we are (Sharp, 65-66)."


It is possible to analyze Ecclesiastes 12:9-14 from Sharp's viewpoint. In the ironic reading, this passage, not the rest of the book in which the character (possibly a construction) Qohelet speaks, is the true voice of the narrator or author. That verses 9 and 10 speak of Qohelet in third person seems to coincide with Sharp's view. These passages seem to refer to further actions that Qohelet performed and they are from the point of view of someone familiar with his actions, not from himself: "..the Teacher also taught the people knowledge, weighing and studying and arranging many proverbs" and "The Teacher sought to find pleasing words, and he wrote words of truth plainly." This does seem to lend itself to an interpretation in which Qohelet may be the subject, not the author, of the text.


In her argument, Sharp states that the rhetorical devices employed in this book serve to point out the essentiality of obedience, not wisdom. Verses 12-14 seem to evidence this interpretation. "Of making books there is no end, and much study is a weariness of the flesh (12)." Throughout the book of Ecclesiastes, Qohelet searches for wisdom, for answers about life and death, to no avail. This epilogue seems to imply that such wisdom is impossible to find and is, dare I say, meaningless. Verses 13 and 14, as Sharp would note, extol the virtues of obedience to God. "Fear God, and keep his commandments; for that is the whole duty of everyone (13)." The "end of the matter" for Ecclesiastes is not wisdom, it is obedience to God.

2 comments:

  1. Your summary helped me make sense Sharps interpretation of Qohelet. In her writing she implies that her viewpoint is simple and easily summarized Ecclesiastes, but after reading more she seemed to make just as many justifications for her point of view as any of the other interpreters. Your post was especially helpful with the points clarifying that Qohelet was the subject, not the author, of parts of the text and that the epilogue was a means of separating the reader from the supposed (fictional) author. I don't agree with Sharps interpretation (I think her claims are overly interpretative), but thanks for the helpful analysis!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with Genevieve. I really liked your explanation of Sharp's analysis. Thanks for writing this blog!

    ReplyDelete