Job is a book filled with contradictions and tension within itself that I surprisingly found more depressing than Qohelet. The book does have a more concise structure with narrative at the beginning and end with a poetic debate in the middle.
Job, the main character of the book, was one the greatest men of his time. He was “blameless and upright”, and he “feared God and turned away from evil” (1:1). Job was also very wealthy and had seven sons and three daughters. But, one day Satan comes along and challenges God to test Job to see if he truly is a righteous man of God. So God destroys everything he has and kills his children all in the same day. Of course Job is devastated however, Job does not claim that God did anything wrong. After this, Satan again challenges God to test Job. God allows Satan to attack Job’s health this time by afflicting him with sores covering his body. Once again, Job does not blame God for this or even question why he has done this (1:2-2:10).
Job has three friends that come to try to console him and this is where the poetic argument begins. This is also where the contradictions begin. In the narrative Job did not blame God or even question his actions however here Job begins complaining about his life and saying that he should not have been born. Job’s three companions keep offering him reasons that this has happened to him; they say he surely must have sinned and that he must deserve this punishment. Job persists and says that he has done no wrong. Why does Job accept his fate in the narrative but defend his righteousness in the poetry?
In his arguments Job questions the sufferings of the innocent and why such bad things happen to righteous people but his companions have no good answer for him. Then a fourth person, Elihu, attempts to provide an answer. Elihu is mad at Job for only justifying himself and he is mad at his friends for not providing him with the correct answer. Elihu argues that God is righteous and majestic and that God “does not recard any who are wise in their on conceit” (37:24b). Elihu’s answer seems to be a contradiction in itself. Job has all these tough questions about the suffering of the innocent but Elihu’s answer is simply “God is good.”
Then in chapters 38 and 39 God speaks directly to Job asking him if he knows all these things that only God could know. Then in chapter 40 verse 2 God tells Job to respond to this; Job says he has nothing to say. Then God challenges Job to stand against the Behemoth and the Leviathan, two of God’s greatest creations. Here Job concedes to God claiming that he did not understand and that God’s will cannot be stopped and Job repents.
Job’s difficult questions such as the suffering of innocent people were not answered even by God. Why does Job allow this? Does he just give up? Does God reward him at the end just to keep him quiet so he will stop asking these difficult questions? This book ends very sadly to me even though the main character enjoys a happy ending being rewarded with twice as much as he had in the first place… with none of his questions answered.
No comments:
Post a Comment