Monday, October 25, 2010

Life of Pi Spoiler Alert

In the Masterpiece Theatre film, God on Trial, the Jewish prisoners of Auschwitz hold a trial to determine if God is in “breach of contract” of his covenant with the Jews. During the trial, the prisoners debate the nature of God and justice, and whether reason and faith can coexist. One prisoner argues that religion cannot stand against reason. Because he uses logic and reason, he cannot believe in God. Finally, fed up with his fellow prisoners blaspheming God, one particularly pious prisoner counters their arguments of reason with one of hope. This prisoner argues that even if denouncing God naturally follows reason, what does one gain from doing so? In this prisoners opinion, one can gain nothing but despair from not believing in God. However, faith in God offers a source of hope and comfort, which is particularly important for these prisoners and others in situations of suffering.

The prisoners argument strongly reminded me of the book Life of Pi. In the novel, the protagonist, Pi, finds himself on a lifeboat with a zebra, an orangutan, a hyena and a bengal tiger. In the course of his journey, Pi witnesses the hyena eat the zebra and the orangutan and the tiger eat the hyena. Eventually, Pi is rescued, but when he tells his story to the authorities, they don’t believe him. Pi then tells them another version of the story in which the orangutan is his mother, the zebra is a sailor, and the hyena is the ship’s cook who killed Pi’s mother and ate the sailor, and Pi is the bengal tiger. Pi then asks the authorities which version of the story they prefer and their answer is the story about the animals. Pi views his faith in God in the same sense- it may be less realistic and it may not even be true at all, but it’s better than the alternative.

The same can be said for Job. Job has lost everything and even his wife tells him to turn from God. Job acknowledges what God has done to him but he does not waver in his faith, saying, “for I know that my Redeemer lives, and that at the last he will stand upon the earth; and after my skin has been thus destroyed, then in my flesh I shall see God, who I shall see on my side, and my eyes shall behold, and not another” (19:25-26). Despite Job’s plight, he holds onto his faith, possibly because he knows that if he denounces God, then he truly is left with nothing. Similar to Pi, Job knows that faith in God, even in a seemingly unjust God, is better than no God at all.

At the end of the film, many of the prisoners are selected to be gassed. One prisoner who was intent on his lack of faith in God finds that he has been selected. In response, he breaks down and begins to pray. In hopeless situations such as these described, though it may be beyond reason to believe in God, one finds that faith is better than the alternative.

1 comment:

  1. I really like the lens you provide with the character Pi to read Job. I think the two characters would definitely relate to each other. This way of reading could help explain why Job clings to faith which is the only place he can find hope.

    ReplyDelete