Monday, October 18, 2010

Job in Phase 2

The section of Dorothee Soelle's "Suffering" that we were assigned, Soelle attempts to describe the so-called "phases of suffering". The phases that she describes are easy to understand in a modern context, but it is a little bit more difficult to use them to describe an ancient text that describes suffering. The first problem one encounters is the validity of the text. Can one properly analyze someone's grief if that grief is fictionalized? Even if it is based on a true event, how accurate are the accounts of Job's speeches. For the sake of argument, let's assume that Job is entirely factual, or at least Job's reactions are. How then would we describe the stages of Job's grief. Phase 1 is described as "mute", "numb", and "speechless". Job's initial reaction to his trouble may fit into this category. In 2:1, after being inflicted with boils, Job "took a potsherd to scratch himself and he sat in the ashes". Before that, in 1:20, after hearing of his children's death it says, "Then Job arose, tore his robe, cut off his hair, and threw himself on the ground and worshipped". All of this seems typical of Phase 1. He is submissive, powerless, and overwhelmed by the tragedy.
In the reading for today, 3:1-14:22, we see what could be described as Phase 2 Job. Soelle describes phase 2 as "lamenting" and "able to speak". When Job's friends come to him, he is finally able to articulate his suffering. His friends, though, are of no help. They are insensitive to Job's plight and insinuate that he brought his misery on himself. Still, the presence of his friends allows Job to begin to speak about his problems, which Soelle claims is "an indispensable step on the way to the third stage".
There is a problem when considering the third stage, though. We never really see Job coming to terms with his grief, only lamenting it. God comes and speaks to Job and repairs his life. In a sense, divine intervention essentially bypasses the third stage, or nullifies the entire process. Still, Soelle's piece gives us an interesting way to look at Job.

1 comment:

  1. I don't think it matters whether the grief or suffering is fictional or reality in order to analyze it through Soelle's stages. Job could be entirely made up, with no factual aspects at all, but I still think your analysis would be the same. In 3:1-14:22, we see Job go through the stages, spending the most time, I think, in stage two. I do agree with your assessment the Job's friends, that as unhelpful and insensitive as they may be, open the doors for Job to communicate his grief.
    I don't know if divine intervention bypasses the third step or if it WAS the third step. Job asks to speak with God in this first section of dialogue and maybe once the divine does step in, Job comes to terms with his suffering, by receiving what he asks for.

    ReplyDelete