The first two chapters of Job set up the character of Job and tell of his great suffering. Job was the wealthiest and greatest man of the east and was also a very righteous man. For some seemingly arbitrary reason, maybe as a bet or challenge, Satan convinces God to destroy everything Job has. However, Job supposedly never curses or blames God for what happened. This poses a couple of questions to me: 1) Does Job actually not curse God like a normal person would? 2) Why does God have something he has to prove to Satan?
Verse one of chapter one claims that Job was “blameless and upright.” Perhaps these horrible things happen to Job because Satan is trying to point out that Job is not as righteous as God sees him to be. In Job’s defense, Job does not curse god or even blame him for the tragedy which has befallen him. “In all this Job did not sin with his lips” (2:10b). What about Job’s heart? Even if Job does not outwardly curse God, would it not be possible for Job to curse God in his heart?
The more troubling part of this story is that God allows Satan to convince him to do these awful things to Job. In Hebrew, ha-satan probably refers to an officer of the king of the Persian empire who travels around the empire testing the loyalty of the kings followers. So, it is possible that this is just an employee of God doing his job. If this is the case it seems easier to understand why God allowed this to happen, but to me it is still very difficult to justify that God would allow such a good, innocent man to suffer.
You're question of the outward/inward cursing is interesting. I've also been wondering what would qualify as corrupting one's blamelessness. Job's friends seem to believe that he must be inwardly cursing God/offending him (or was prior to his series of tragedies) even when he appears blameless to spectators. His friends could be right, that maybe he has evil in his heart and he's not perfect! Though perfection is a high standard.
ReplyDeleteAlso, your blog raises the question of what perspective with which to read Job: literally or metaphorically. We can take Job as a story that literally happened and so criticize God's actions, or metaphorically and then discern what the symbolism of the story implies of God's relation to man.
I don't necessarily think that this passage shows that God has something to prove to satan or that God "allows" satan to test Job. It seems to me that God is the instigator in this situation. He is the one who brings Job to satan's attention. I think what you said about is being difficult to justify God allowing an innocent man to suffer is why so much of the blame in this story is traditionally placed on satan. The text implies, to me, that God is trying to persuade satan, not the other way around.
ReplyDeleteBoth the youtube video and the South Park clip we watched seemed to adress the issues you had with Job. In the South Park clip, Kyle is so unsettled by the story that he sees it as proof that there is no God. Both of the clips highlight the difficulty of understanding Job in the context of modern Christianity. Job clashes with our view of God as understanding and benevolent and makes him seem petty and unpleasant.
ReplyDeleteGod does seem "petty and unpleasant", as Lance says. I like how you brought up that ha-satan could be an employee of God, whose job it is to go out and test people. However, I don't see that Satan really wanted to test Job in the text, or even that the whole turn of events that transpired against Job had anything to do with him. If ha-satan was out to test somebody, it seems that it was God (not Job) that fell into the trap when he started boasting about his servant Job. God was tested, and as Lance said he is "petty and unpleasant". It would seem that God failed the test. However, Genevieve has an excellent point about reading the story metaphorically and trying to figure out what this means for the God/human relationship.
ReplyDeleteI agree. I don't think Job is blameless nor perfect. I believe that he thinks he is would be a sin plus he's basically saying God is wrong for doing this but hey he's God. He does what he wants.
ReplyDelete