The second cycle of dialogue in the book of Job begins in chapter 15 with Eliphaz one again criticizing Job’s belief that he has done nothing wrong. Eliphaz characterizes Job’s claims as “unprofitable talk”(v.3) and accuses him of “choosing the tongue of the crafty”(v.4). Eliphaz then comes to the conclusion that Job has condemned himself though his own utterances. Job then goes on to respond to Eliphaz (and the others) by chastising them for speaking against him, rather than offering encouragement in his time of distress (16:5) Rather than support and stand as witnesses on his behalf, they have accused him of sin.
In chapter 17, once again Job reflects back over his suffering. His body has rapidly deteriorated and his friends have offered no comfort. However, Job seems to find some sort of hope in the midst of his suffering. His hope does not come from his friends, an ease in his suffering, or from reflecting back over his past life (v.11). In v. 12, it is suggested that there is a light that has begun to ignite in Job, in spite of the darkness that surrounds him. In his commentary (p.126), Janzen seems to think that the “they “ in v. 12, is referring to the previous verse’s “desires of my heart.” Janzen believes that this light is the desires of Job’s heart and that his wish for death (in previous passages such as 3:21, 6:8-9,etc.) has disappeared.
While I don’t think that Janzen’s commentary on this passage is completely ridiculous, I don’t buy his argument that Job’s wish for death has disappeared. In verses 15 and 16, Job asks his “mother” or “sister”, “where then is my hope? Who will see my hope?” It seems to me that Job feels that there is no reason to continue to exist. The passage then ends with Job asking, “ Will it go down to the bars of Sheol? Shall we descend together into the dust? (v.16) I am not sure who or what Job is referring to when he says “it” and “we.” Is he referring to hope or God or something else entirely? The last several verses in chapter seventeen were extremely confusing and frustrating, and I have yet to come to any firm conclusions about what the author is trying to communicate.
I read the "it" in 17:16 to be Job's hope. In verse 15 Job asks "where then is my hope? Who will see my hope?" followed by "will it go down to the bars of Sheol?" I also think that the "we" refers to Job and his hope and when Job asks "shall we descend together into the dust?" he is maybe saying that when his hope dies then he will die also and return to dust. Another way to read it is that his hope has already died and he is wanting to follow it into Sheol.
ReplyDeleteKate, I really like your interpretation of Job 17:12. Janzen's point seems to be a stretch and while his interpretation is possible, I don't feel as if Job's wish for death has disappeared because as you continue reading it seems that Job has not changed his viewpoint and he continues to yearn for death and ask God why he is being punished.
ReplyDelete