Monday, October 4, 2010

How Many Authors Does it Take to Write an Epilogue?

In these final five verses of Ecclesiastes (12:9-14), the author of the book seems to change abruptly. One reason that sparks the idea that the epilogue was added later by an additional author is the reference to Qohelet (the Teacher) in such a positive and praising light. 12:9 says, “Not only was the Teacher wise, but also imparted knowledge to the people. He pondered and searched out and set in order many proverbs.” Whoever wrote this final epilogue praised Qohelet and his wisdom, and gives the indication that Qohelet purposely challenged and righted proverbs of the day. I find this to be in stark contrast to the rest of the book of Ecclesiastes. Qohelet may reference proverbs or pieces of common knowledge, but setting them right never seems to be his goal.

Another contradiction I see in the epilogue is in vv. 11-12, which states that “the words of the wise are like goads, their collected sayings like firmly embedded nails” and to “be warned, my son, of anything in addition to them. Of making books there is no end, and much study wearies the body.” The author seems to be saying, in reference to Qohelet, that one should take the words of the wise and not question them or trust anything added to them, as well as avoid writing books and studying the words of the wise too much. This especially contradicts what the previous verse said about the Teacher who challenged and set right proverbs, though is in line with Qohelet’s position that too much wisdom is just as bad as foolishness. These inconsistencies lead me to think that two additional authors had their hands in the epilogue, possibly with a third voice emerging in verses 13-14.

The final two verses of Ecclesiastes are, as I read them, a middle ground between what seems to be Qohelet’s position on life and what 12:9-12 has to say. V. 13 warns the reader to “fear God and keep his commandments,” while v. 14 returns to the idea that everything will be judged by God. It seems to be a neutral way to end the book, touching on some prevalent themes but staying far enough away to avoid staking a radical theological claim.

The epilogue of Ecclesiastes, 12:9-14, is an inconsistent, yet at times vaguely cohesive, passage. It certainly does not have Qohelet’s usual pessimistic, depressing sass, and puts Qohelet and wisdom up on a metaphorical pedestal, leading to the conclusion that others have tampered with the end of Ecclesiastes,

3 comments:

  1. I agree that verses 13-14 are the closest to what Qohelet believes. Qohelet does fear God as seen in chapter 5 and there have been a few times throughout the book where Qohelet says that God will judge your actions (11:9). At least the epilogue doesn't say that obeying God will bring you success and happiness.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really like your argument that this epilogue was possibly written by three authors! I had not looked at it that way in much detail until now and I think it is possibly very justifiable. Even the Hebrew (as far as I can tell) is split up into sections that could be by different scribes just tacking on their two cents at the end.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I really liked your argument that there are possibly three authors to this passage- good job! In response to your analysis on verse 12:9, I think that Qoheleth would not view himself as being as a wise person- even if he did he would say that it is meaningless. I think this verse is one of the greatest evidences that this passage was written by another author.

    ReplyDelete