In the past few chapters, the dialogue between Job and his friends has been about whether Job might actually deserve his suffering. Since they are operating under the idea that your acts determine your consequences, for Job to be suffering he must have done something wrong. If he was perfectly righteous in the eyes of God it doesn’t make sense that he would be punished.
In chapter fifteen, Eliphaz does not change his argument but simply reinforces it. He strongly emphasizes that Job must have sinned, saying he (Job) has “empty counsel” or “vain knowledge” (verse two) and telling him that he must repent if he wants to escape further judgments. Job responds by telling him he is a “miserable comforter” and bluntly states he is tired of hearing him talk (“is there no end to your empty words?”—ch. 16, v. 2-3).
Bildad begins his dialogue in chapter eighteen, sounding extremely frustrated. He asks Job why he considers them stupid like cattle, irritated that Job refuses to adhere to their advice (to confess before God). Instead of comforting Job in his time of need or even trying to bribe him into repenting, Bildad proceeds to remind Job of all the horrible things that could happen if he did unknowingly sin and does not repent. Job reminds his friends to not be too quick to defend their idea of righteous guarantees rewards/sin guarantees suffering, lest it come back to bite them.
Zophar perceives something that Job says to be threatening/an attempt to rebuke the three friends. Like the other three friends, Zophar strongly encourages Job to repent. Job asks his friends to stay silent for a while (as they did initially) but to “continue mocking” (ch. 21, v. 3) after he has spoken. (He doesn’t trust that they will be supportive, seeing as they have started speaking to him in an almost threatening manner.) Job admits to his friend that he is upset with God and he is very afraid. He is afraid because although he has faith that God is powerful and such, He is still allowing these things to happen to him (Job) and he can’t see a logical reason why God would do this.
Job's friends are totally clueless about how to support a suffering friend! However, we can't really blame them because, until Job experienced intense suffering firsthand, he probably would have said the same (insulting) things as well.
ReplyDeleteYou referenced the "theo-algebraic" equation we talked about in class, [(bad)action + just God = suffering], which is the formula Job's friends support. My guess is that if any of the friends were the "action" component of the equation, as they condemn Job to be, they would soon discredit the formula. No one wants to admit they have flaws, so, rather, it must be the formula that's wrong!
Genevieve, I like how you point out that Job would have acted the same way that his friends did if he was not the one experiencing the suffering. I also like your explanation of the theo-algebraic equation. However, I'd like to take it a step farther: if humans are not going to admit to their flaws and there is only one other variable (God), then it is God who must be flawed. You can say that this is a problem with the formula, but I think this would require humans to admit that they are at fault in creating a God concept that was inaccurate. Humans can either admit that they had an inaccurate God concept and change. Or, they cannot admit that they were wrong and accept that God by process of elimination is the one who is wrong. I think Job is in the former category.
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed the reference to the equation in class because I think it is a good way to explain the characters' thought processes. However, I don't think that the problem is necessarily that Job won't admit that he has done something wrong. If the prologue is an accurate representation of who Job is and God's motivation for his actions, I'm not sure we can assume that Job has done something to deserve what's happening. I think the story of Job is a more realistic view of life which has been exaggerated. The truth that Job presents is that bad things happen to good people and that's just how it is.
ReplyDeleteJob's friends are completely insensitive to Job's plight, but they are just standing by a theological tradition that Job himself would if put in their position. They lack empathy because 1) they have not experienced the pain like him and 2) it is not in their philosophy to be understanding to someone who is questioning God. I wonder why, then, God feels the need to punish the friends when he arrives later in the book; the friends may have been insensitive, but they were just acting according to the current philosophy of the time
ReplyDeleteLance I don't know if I would call them insensitive... It's like when you ask someone to help you find something, and their first instinct is to ask if you lost it. To them, it's a matter of deductive reasoning; you are suffering thus you screwed up somewhere along the line.
ReplyDelete