Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Wisdom is better than might

In chapter 9, Qoheleth starts contrasting wisdom to other attributes with the story of the poor wise man and this continues throughout the reading. It seems as if Qoheleth thinks wisdom is the trait to have, “Wisdom is better than might”, but he goes on to say no one remembered the poor man. I’m not sure what to think of this, because obviously someone remembered the wise man.

Chapter 10 is laid out like a list of advice, or words to live by. Qoheleth is still contrasting wisdom to foolishness. He states “The heart of the wise inclines to the right, but the heart of a fool to the left” and “Words spoke by the wise bring them favor, but the lips of fools consume them”. These two verses are just saying it is better to be wise than to be a fool. In verses 5-7 in chapter 10, Qoheleth takes a break from the structure of the rest of the chapter and talks about folly. The verses read “There is an evil that I have seen under the sun, as great an error as if it proceeded from the ruler: folly is set in many high places, and the rich sit in a low place. I have seen slaves on horseback, and princes walking on foot like slaves”.Qoheleth is saying that we should not live for folly, or hold it above anything such as riches. I think this is strange idea to portray before chapter 12, which is all about remembering your creator in your days of youth, because the days of youth are usually filled with folly.

Chapter 12 is the last one in Ecclesiastes, and it really isn’t to depressing, except that Qoheleth is pretty much saying once you get old your life kind of sucks, so enjoy life and the creator while your young. The chapter starts with “Remember your creator in the days of your youth, before the days of trouble come” and then goes on to describe in more detail why life when you’re old is worse than life in your youth.

I Pity the Fool.

Again Qoheleth's biggest fear is being forgotten. Yet the part that seems to upset him the most, is that even the wisest of men are forgotten. He tells the story of a brave old wise man that stood up to the king and saved his small town (Ecc. 9:13-18) and after all the old man had done, he was still forgotten in the end. I believe that Qoheleth has this all wrong. Eben after the old man's death we still remember him because we read about him through Qoheleth and his writings. In some fashion or another, someone will remember you.

The differences between wise men and foolish men are stated throughout our readings (Ecclesiastes 9:111-12:8). Qoheleth seems to have made up his mind about wither or not it is better or worse to be a wise man or a foolish man. (Yayy Qoheleth!) In Ecclesiastes 10:12 he stats that "Words from a wise man's mouth are gracious, but a fool is consumed by his own lips." To me, this implies that a wise man word's are few but hold a lot of meaning but a fool says whatever passes his lips without a second thought. He also goes on to say that many of the foolish have most of the authority possessions while the wise and the people that should hold those offices are not, they are just as ordinary as anyone else. He also heeds his readers not to speak of these foolish men in office for a "bird" could hear your conversations and you shall be in a big trouble for it. It makes me wonder what was done during this time period to tick him off so badly. My thoughts would be that hearing the story of the old wise man being forgotten and bashed by the king offends him because he, more than anyone, can relate to the old man. To Qoheleth, that had proved his theory of being a hero, yet no one remembering.

Enjoy Your Youth, The End is Coming

A reoccurring theme that we have seen through the book of Ecclesiastes is to enjoy life even though it is vapor. IN the reading assigned for today (Ecc.9:11-12:8) Qoheleth makes the distinction that to not only enjoy your life but to enjoy it while you are young, because you will quickly turn old and become one step closer to death. This section begins in 11:9 and continues through 12:8, in my opinion. In 11:9, Qoheleth explains that you should enjoy your youth and in a way be spontaneous, but to also be careful because God is watching. 12:1a continues this theme of enjoyment, stating that you should “remember the creator in the days of your youth,” possibly portraying the thought that you should not only enjoy life when you are young but also take time to enjoy the one who created you. 12:1b then marks the shift in Qoheleth’s attitude. He then returns to the pessimistic mindset by saying that the only reason you should enjoy being young is because you will quickly turn old and no longer find pleasure in the world. He supports this case in verses 2-5a by explaining what happens to you once old age strikes.
In 12:5b Qoheleth states “Then man goes to his eternal home and mourners go about the streets.” I believe this is where he begins to wrap up his idea that life is vapor and we all die. The Bok of Ecclesiastics has had the reoccurring themes of death and meaninglessness. 12:5b-8 seems to wrap up these themes as the imagery of a funeral is explained and death finally occurs. I believe these verses wrap up the pessimistic side of Qoheleth as “the dust returns to the ground it came from, and the spirit returns to God who gave it” and death finally prevails. Life may be meaningless and we may die and return to God (v.7b-idea of afterlife?), but we better enjoy that life in everyway possible, especially when we are young.

Youth and Old Age

Ecclesiastes 11:7-10 is the beginning of the end of Qoheleth’s discourse. Qoheleth opens this section by saying that, “Light is sweet, and it is pleasant for the eyes to see the sun.”(v.7) As evidenced by Ecclesiastes 8:1 “ Wisdom makes one’s face shine, and the hardness of one’s countenance is changed,” Qoheleth believes that the sun (or light) is representative of joy or happiness. Unfortunately, these days of light that Qoheleth speaks of cannot last forever. In v.8 Qoheleth says that the days of light will not last, and eventually all that will be left is darkness. I interpreted this passage as saying- enjoy the days of your life, but keep in mind that this is temporary and eventually you will die.

In v.9 Qoheleth instructs the reader to enjoy the days of their youth and to “follow the inclination of your heart and the desire of your eyes.” In this verse, I believe that Qoheleth is telling the reader to “suck all the marrow out of life”(Thoreau). Whatever you desire to do – go out and do it, before the responsibilities of life take over. Oh, and on an endnote, don’t be too stupid, because “ for all these things God will bring you into judgment.” I find this passage in Qoheleth to be somewhat confusing. How can you instruct the youth to “follow the inclination of your heart and the desire of your eyes” and not potentially incur God’s judgment? Does Qoheleth think that the youth should only do things that are in accordance with God’s will? If so, what does Qoheleth think God’s will is? Does he think that He has one?

Qoheleth ends this section by instructing the reader to “banish anxiety from your mind, and put away pain from your body; for youth and the dawn of life are vanity”(v.10). I believe that Qoheleth is saying to stop worrying and enjoy the time you have left on earth. When I read this verse I thought of a passage in the New Testament where Jesus seems to echo Qoheleth’s sentiments by instructing his followers to “not worry about tomorrow, for tomorrow will worry about itself (Matthew 6:34). While Jesus (to my knowledge) never says that “life is vanity”, I do find it interesting that he and Qoheleth seem to agree on the idea that anxiety (or worry) is useless and unbeneficial. Brown’s commentary nicely summarizes my interpretation of this passage of Qoheleth, “ Such is the key to human existence for the sage: to relinquish control over life in order to be freed for joy”(104).

Plant Many Seeds

In Ecclesiastes chapter 11 Qohelet begins by discussing the benefits of sharing one’s resources (“bread”) with others.  In v. 2 he says that one should give to several people “for you do not know what disaster may come upon the land,” this fits with what Qohelet said in 9:11.  He believes that “time and chance” happen to all men.  Life is unfair and disaster or misfortune can strike both the wise and foolish.  Brown makes the claim that Qohelet promotes charity because you can get charity in return when something unfortunate comes to you, for Qohelet “charity is self-preservation,” (p. 103).  The more people you share with, the more people will return the favor when you need help.  This is also be supported by Qohelet’s views on friendship in 4:10.


Qohelet continues this section by saying that men cannot know what is going to happen in the world (v. 3-4).  It will rain, trees will fall and trying to know when and why is a waste of time.  He says “whoever watches the wind will not plant...will not reap,” (v. 4).  In verse 5, Qohelet continues with this theme and says as wind and the formation of life cannot be understood “so you cannot understand the work of God,” (v. 5).  As Qohelet would say, to try to know is a chasing after wind.


In verse 6, Qohelet promotes working as a better use of one’s time.  He says not to let “your hands be idle”.  It is good to invest one’s time in work and charity so that one has a better shot at success.  One does not know “which will succeed” (v. 6) so it is good to invest time in both. Qohelet says that work is a good thing in 2:24 and 5:18.  Indeed finding joy in work and enjoying food and drink are consistently mentioned by Qohelet as what people should do with their time on Earth.

Monday, September 27, 2010

What it's like

"What It's Like" Everlast
song:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vCZ1YteCv5M
lyrics:
http://www.elyrics.net/read/e/everlast-lyrics/what-it_s-like-lyrics.html

Thought this song fit. He talks about bad things happening to good people and then life goes on. We all got to live and it sucks.

"Sometimes, there's so much beauty in the world..."

The film American Beauty (Dreamworks, 1999) sets itself up as a type of documentary of the last year of Lester Burnham's (Kevin Spacey) life. From the outside, it seems that he has the perfect life - a loving wife, a daughter, a nice house in the suburbs, a decent job with his very own cubicle. Tensions are high in his home though, and the conflict explodes to the surface as Lester goes through what seems to be a midlife crisis, wanting to return to his youth where he spent his time "flipping burgers," "partying," and "getting laid." He begins to work out and smoke pot, and he quits his job (where he had been miserable). His wife Carolyn (Annette Bening) begins an affair in response to her husband's actions and stemming from her own self worth issues. Meanwhile Lester's daughter Jane (Thora Birch) becomes involved with his drug dealer who happens to go to her high school and live next door, Ricky Fitts (Wes Bentley). The conflicts in the movie continue until all the characters are murdered, have mental breakdowns, or decide to skip town.

This movie is as thick with questions of the meaning in life as it is with nudity and rose petals. Most of the characters spend the entire movie looking for fulfillment and happiness, but few find it. Lester looks to lust and to some degree possessions to find his happiness. He spends the majority of the two-hour movie-year trying to recapture the lifestyle of his youth in the early seventies. As part of this, he begins to work out obsessively in an effort to get into the pants of Jane's friend Angela (Mena Suvari). In the end, he finds out that while she talks a big talk, she's actually a virgin, and he decides not to sleep with her, though given the chance. He trades in his car in favor of the dream car of his teenage years. When his wife finds out, she gets angry. In response, Lester almost seduces his wife on the couch. The romance is cut short though when Carolyn, obsessed with material goods and appearances, asks her husband to stop because he's going to spill beer on the couch. Carolyn is very caught up in her career and "looking successful." She has an affair with a successful real estate agent, but becomes upset at Lester when he finds out and does not care. Lester's affection is also important to Jane, who is upset both that her father has become obsessed with Angela, and that he doesn't seem to care about her. Ricky, the drug dealing boyfriend who's had a trip to the mental hospital and is beaten by his homosexual-hating, homosexual father Marine Col. Frank Fitts (Chris Cooper), seems to be one of the happiest characters in the film. In the end, he and Jane decide to run away together, though it is left unclear whether or not they actually go. Lester is murdered by Col. Fitts (in the kitchen with the antique gun) after turning down Fitts' sexual advances. Carolyn is left sobbing uncontrollably in the closet after finding murdered the husband whom she had already resolved to kill because he did not care about her. The movie is full of symbolism, most notably the rose petals that surround everything the characters search for fulfillment in -- Lester's fantasies, Carolyn's perfect roses outside of her seemingly perfect home, and the table Lester sits at before he is killed. Lester decides, in the second before he dies, that there is "so much beauty in the world," and he narrates (from beyond the grave) that he was grateful for every moment of his "stupid life." At Burnham family dinners, what Jane describes as "elevator music" was always playing in the background, even when Lester and Carolyn have a fight over dinner. At the end of the shouting match, Lester demands that different music be played at some dinners. This seems symbolic to me of both the image Carolyn wished to project of the family to the outside world and the monotonous repetition present in the "ideal" American life.

Qoheleth could have some interesting talks with the characters of American Beauty. Lester, for much of the movie, adopts the "eat, drink and be merry" attitude that exists in portions of Ecclesiastes. In Lester's last second, he truly appreciates the little things in his "stupid" (or vaporous/vain?) life, including past good times with his wife and daughter, just as Qoheleth instructs men to do several times. Carolyn realizes that she can not be fulfilled through possessions, but needs her family to be happy, just as Qoheleth wrote of his inability to be fulfilled by his wealth and accomplishments, but spoke well of the value of companionship. Jane looks for fulfillment in her relationship with Ricky, deciding that he is worth more to her than the plastic surgery she has been saving up for since she was twelve. In the end, I think Qoheleth and American Beauty come to fairly similar conclusions on what, after all, is meaningful in life.

Sunday, September 26, 2010

Lame, Lester...

Lester Burnam (Kevin Spacey), the narrator of the film American Beauty, according to modern American suburban standards, had everything. He lived in a well-furnished two story house, married an attractive realtor wife, fathered a cute daughter, and could put on a cheerful smile when needed. But, like Kohelet, he eventually reached a breaking point at which his life seemed to have lost direction and meaning. To our generation, Lester's breakdown looks like a mid-life crisis, a time at which everything he had been suppressing bursts back into consciousness. A Freudian interpretation would fit well here for Lester (as well as for every other character in the film), but there are things other than sex that he was ignoring. He had ignored his need for personal meaning. Everything in his life revolved around paying for his expensive lifestyle, leaving no room for personal growth or pleasure. So suddenly, his need sprung forth! Beautiful girls entranced him! He bought a sports car! Smoking pot was liberating! And just when he felt, for the first time in a very long time, that everything was good, he died. In Kohelets eyes, his death would be a perfectly obvious sign that his actions were foolish. Just because Lester could get high and fantasize about an underage girl does not make his life any better. He still died didn't he? His problems with his wife were left unresolved, his daughter will forever carry guilt and stunt her own happiness, and the man next door will have even more problems accepting his sexuality. Ridding yourself of tedious obligations and replacing them with pleasure and a shallow sense of wisdom, even if they dull the pain, does not augment the meaning of one's life. Way to deceive yourself, Lester! (says Kohelet).

Ecclesiastes Needed More CGI Rose Petals

In AMERICAN BEAUTY (Sam Mendes, 1999), Lester Burnham (Kevin Spacey) is a man without a purpose. He has become so listless that his life barely even qualifies as one. He feels like he has been dead for a long time. Then, he sees something that pulls him out of his existential funk, his daughter's friend Angela (Mena Suvari), a Lolita-esque vision of highly sexualized youth. From that point forward, he starts living his life for one purpose, his own enjoyment. The enjoyment based life is an idea that is emphasized repeatedly in Ecclesiastes, but does it work for Lester Burnham and would Qoheleth approve of Lester's choices? It's difficult to say. Does Alan Ball's Oscar-winning screenplay make Lester out to be a wise man who has found the secret to life or as a selfish asshole who abdicates his responsibilities as a husband and father.
The answer seems to be somewhere in the middle, but there is an incredibly telling moment near the end of the film. Lester has finally has obtained his ultimate prize; Angela is his for the taking. When she tells him she is a virgin, though, something clicks back into place for Lester. You could say that he, for lack of a better term, became an adult again. He quickly goes into paternal mode, consoling Angela. While she's in the restroom, he gazes contently at an old family picture in his last moment of life. It sends a very complicated message, but the message I gleaned from the film can be boiled down to this: the oppressiveness of suburban domesticity can cause to miss the real beauty in front of their eyes, namely their families, and do drastic things to recapture their own identity. With that reading in mind, it seems clear that Alan Ball (and Sam Mendes, for that matter) don't seem to support a life based entirely on enjoyment. Would Qoheleth support Lester's life, though?
In Ecc 5:17 Qoheleth states, "Only this, I have found, is a real good: that one should eat and drink and get pleasure with all the gains he makes under the sun". Lester seems to take this to heart. He quits his job, buys a sports car, and lusts after younger women. In the process, though, he alienates everyone around him. I feel as though Lester Burnham takes the ideas of Qoheleth to their logical extreme, to the point where is damages others' lives. On paper, Lester seems like a perfect model of Qohelth's philosophy, but he takes it to its breaking point, to the point that shows the fault in Qoheleth's thought.

Wednesday, September 22, 2010

The Seeker

The Who's "The Seeker", which was featured on the soundtrack to AMERICAN BEAUTY. I think you should all give it a listen. First of all, it's The Who, so it's awesome. Second of all, I think it's very relevant to our discussion of Ecclesiastes. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UAbzlj3nf4E Enjoy!

Is a life of toil beautiful or ugly?

In the film ‘American Beauty’, Beauty manifests itself in a number of ways. I would argue that Beauty primarily functions as a motivator: its perceived presence or absence, lures characters towards particular emotional states and courses of action. Meanwhile, orbiting the central notion of Beauty, are the themes of death and enjoyment. Indeed, it seems that for all of the characters in the film where there is beauty enjoyment can be found, and where beauty is lacking enjoyment lacks as well. For example, the lack of beauty in the protagonist’s marriage makes the beauty of a young girl that much more enticing. However, the beauty of the girl is transformed when he finds out that she is a virgin, and therefore, his enjoyment is similarly transformed (e.g. he no longer desires to has sex with her as a virgin, even though the goal of sex previously motivated him to start working out.) All the while, death is lurking right around the corner. The significance here is that by contextualizing Ecclesiastes’ themes of death and enjoyment this film opens a peculiar window through which we can view the book itself.

On multiple occasions the protagonist of the film comes to a conclusion, which Qoheleth would agree with; that his commitment to ideals, such as marriage, career, and obedience to the law have proven to be vain, unfulfilling pursuits. This conclusion seemingly leads to another; that at this point he is solely committed to finding enjoyment in his toil. The twisted irony of the film, however, is that by going down this path the protagonist ultimately brings his own death upon him. It should be noted, too, that upon dying what flashes before his eyes are those moments that he found to be truly beautiful.

The last portion of the protagonist’s life seems to go as followed: vain pursuits are abandoned, enjoyment guided by beauty becomes the primary goal for each moment, and the relief of death arrives shortly after. At this point, it’s tempting to argue that according to Qoheleth, the protagonist’s last days were literally as good as gets. But alas, a fundamental question must be answered before it can be claimed that Qoheleth would advocate the life-choices that the film’s main character made: What does Qoheleth believe is beautiful? What motivates him and his writing?

It seems clear to me that what ultimately defines how we interpret something, is what we value more: the particular or the universal, the individual or the society, the piece or the whole. In my mind, so long as we cannot know the motivations of the writer of the book of Ecclesiastes, any attempt to interpret it is vanity. At the same time, the value of interpreting Ecclesiastes is found not in our interpretations, but in the enjoyment we find in the process.

To end my response, I’d like to offer a song for reflection that I think relates to the movie’s emotional tone pretty well…

“Slow Motion” by Third Eye Blind, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Ibfvjv4uxE

Monday, September 20, 2010

Eat, Drink, and be Merry!

Eat, drink, and be merry. This surfaces as a mantra in a book of the Bible, to the Epic of Gilgamesh, and even a Dave Matthews Band song. This idea seems to stem in all these cases from a fear of death or a realization of our mortality and the uncertainties of death.

Qohelet’s seems to formulate this idea after deciding that life is meaningless. In chapter 8 verses 12-14, Qohelet realizes that those who fear God it will be well in the eyes of God. But that is not necessarily the truth for humans. He tells of another vanity of earth: there are righteous people treated like the wicked and wicked people treated like the righteous. This difference between God’s judgements of humans and how humans judge one another causes Qohelet to come to the conclusion that humans should eat, drink, and be merry because this seems like the only logical thing to do.

Qohelet claims that everyone shares the same fate (9:3), the righteous and wicked alike die. Even the hero of an epic poem, Gilgamesh, is almost destroyed by his obsession with this realization after the death of his dear friend. Gilgamesh goes to search for an immortal man and speaks to a tavern keeper on his journey. He tells the keeper of his friend’s death and how he is now afraid of death. The tavern keeper tells him to be happy for “this is the work of mankind.” However, Gilgamesh continues on his journey to find Utamapishtim, the man who became immortal, and when he does he tells him of his plight. The immortal man asks Gilgamesh why he works so hard if nothing lasts forever. Even after this Gilgamesh seems confused and asks himself, “for whom have my hands been toiling?”

Unlike Gilgamesh, the possibly-equally-as-epic Dave Matthews seems to have taken the advice of the Tavern Keeper and of Utamapishtim. Dave Matthews Band’s song, Trippin’ Billies (http://bit.ly/881ey1), refrains “eat, drink, and be merry. For tomorrow we die.”

Fear God....a prolonged life? Or prolonged after life?

These few verses of Ecclesiastes 8 and 9 seemed to portray a more optimistic approach to this vain life than the previous chapters. Qoheleth’s adamant reassurance in justice, hope, and joy is a nice hiatus from the “all is vain”, “why should we live”, and “oppressed are we” talk. Because of this overall optimistic tone I read it from a different angle. In chapter 8 verses 12-13 I saw a hint of the possibility of an afterlife. Verses 12 and 13 basically say that we are all sinners but that there is one distinction between us; those who fear God and those who don’t. Qoheleth says that those who fear God that their lives will be prolonged, and those who don’t fear God that their lives won’t be prolonged. He even goes to say that those who don’t fear God are like shadows (13b). Now, earlier in Ecc. Qoheleth repeatedly says that all humans and even beasts have the same fate, which is ultimately death (3:19, 2:14, and 7:2). I don’t think that this is just another contradiction. I think that Qoheleth is entertaining the idea that if we do fear God, our lives will be prolonged: prolonged after death. I think that Qoheleth believes this because Qoheleth confesses his belief in judgment from God (3:17). Why would Qoheleth believe in a God that judges people when we die, if there is nothing after death and a reason for the judgment? Qoheleth must be intrigued by the idea that something does exists after death, because the life one lives here on earth is judged by it. Thus, the rest of this particular excerpt (8:10-9:10) and throughout Ecc. Qoheleth is giving commands on how to live this life that will be judged. To fear God (8:12-13), live righteously, become wise (8:5, 7:16), and find enjoyment in this vain and unfair world.
One of Qoheleth’s biggest commands can be found inverse 15 of chapter 8; Qoheleth is commanding his readers to find enjoyment “for there is nothing better” for people to have. Qoheleth advises that this joy works with the toils of the world, just like “darkness only enhances the weak radiance of joy’s light” (Brown 93). You can’t truly experience one without experiencing the other. In chapter 9 verses 7-10 Qoheleth commands with great intensity and urgency to “go eat, drink, let, enjoy, and do” (Brown 93). Qoheleth is advising that if we enjoy these things the struggles and toils of life are lessened of their burdens. Enjoy life before death takes control. Qoheleth is hitting on the point that humans only live once, so seize the day before death takes control.

"Eat, Drink, and Be Merry"... right?



The portion of the Epic of Gilgamesh that we read picks up right after Gilgamesh’s companion Enkidu dies. Gilgamesh, in his emotional state, decides to mourn for Enkidu by somewhat adopting his persona. Gilgamesh decides to shed the spoils and characteristics of mankind and become like the beast. By mourning for Enkidu, Gilgamesh casts aside all the benefits of life and surrounds himself in pity and despair. The death of Enkidu also brings on a fear of death within Gilgamesh and he feels the need to quest and find immortality.
In this quest for immortality, Gilgamesh encounters multiple characters. I feel as though these characters serve as voices of reasoning telling Gilgamesh to abandon his mission, that there is no immortality awaiting him, and that it is time for him to get over Enkidu’s death. “Gilgamesh, wherefore do you wander? The eternal life you are seeking, you shall not find.” (tablet X ln 77-78). In the end, Gilgamesh realizes the foolishness of his journey and behavior. Utanapishtim, the man with the answers, tells him that he has been wasting his time. “Why, O Gilgamesh, did you prolong woe, You who are of the flesh of gods and mankind… When was it, Gilgamesh, you […] a fool?” (tablet X ln 285-288). He goes on to state that death is a part of life and that nothing lasts forever through the use of various allusions.
Similar to the reading from Gilgamesh, I concluded that Ecclesiastes 9 is also speaking of death because Quoheleth speaks of this thing that effects everyone without bias. “It is the same for all, since the same event happens to the righteous and the wicked, to good and the evil, to the clean and the unclean, to him who sacrifices and him who does not sacrifice” (EST Ecclesiastes 9:2). He uses this as a reason for people to doubt their faith (in what I assumed to be God, but it could be other things) and allow them to act in various uncouth ways. “That is why people are not more careful to be good” (NLT Ecclesiastes 9:3). He goes on to state that the living at least understand that death is coming, but instead of dwelling on the fact they should enjoy life. “For the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing…Go, eat your bread with joy, and drink your wine with a merry heart, for God has already approved what you do.” (EST Ecclesiastes 9:5-7).
The similarities between the exerts from Ecclesiastes and The Epic of Gilgamesh rest within their outlooks on life and death. Quohelth encourages a merry existence in the face of death, because once life is over, that’s it. Utanpishtim urges Gilgamesh to stop focusing on his friend’s death like a fool. Siduri tells him “As for you, Gilgamesh, let your stomach be full,… your clothes should be clean, your head should be washed…” (tablet X ln 82-87). Death is unfortunate but until then, “eat ,drink, and be merry.”

The Righteous vs. The Sinners

In this section Qoheleth begins by wondering why those who commit sins sometimes go without punishment and why those who are righteous are often the ones who get punished. He returns to a point in Ecclesiastes 8: 13, that humans should fear God and that those who hold him in reverence are still better off then those who go around sinning. For those who continue to sin and refuse to fear God live their lives as if they are in a “shadow”, as opposed to the people who fear God and “toil through the days of life that God gives them under the sun” (8: 15). I also believe that another question gets answered in this section. We have been discussing Qoheleth’s view on work and if he truly believes that the only way to live is to be merry and have a good time under the sun, but in this section he states “ So I commend enjoyment, for there is nothing better for people under the sun than to eat, and drink, and enjoy themselves, for this with go with them in their toil through the days of life that God gives them under the sun” (8: 15). Qoheleth uses the word “toil” in this verse to explain his point that your work should also be worth living for. I think he is finally declares that work is part of the enjoyment of life and he wants people to find a balance between work and toil.

Qoheleth goes on to discuss those who have spent time thinking about death will often feel despair because they will never be able to gain enough wisdom so that they can understand death. This discovery can be discouraging, but he claims, “then I saw all the work of God, that no one can find out what is happening under the sun” (8: 17). Qoheleth seems to take comfort in the fact that no one else can answer this question because then he does not feel like as much of a failure and therefore his pride can remain intact. He then restates his point about how that everyone will eventually suffer the same fate and that the greatest evil in the world is not what happens under the sun, but is the eventually death of everyone. I really feel that he is trying to drill this idea in our heads because this is the second time he has mentioned it and he wants it to be known that this is what he actually believes.

In this section Qoheleth finally seems to be dealing with some of the issues that he has been going back and forth on throughout this text. He has made some concrete claims that actually make sense and he is willing to repeat as opposed to recant.

The good life

The tale of Gilgamesh and the story that we see in Ecclesiastes parallel each other throughout the book as Brown points out in his commentary. Both are stories about men looking for a way to not be forgotten, and an explanation on how to live their lives. Gilgamesh is searching through a physical journey while Qoheleth is searching in a more metaphysical journey. Qoheleth, thorough his thoughts and experiences, is trying to find a way to live forever in the memories of the people that come after him. Gilgamesh is searching for Utanapishtim (whose name very closely resembles utopia) because he is the only immortal man and Gilgamesh wants to know the secret to immortality. I really like this parallel. It shows that this search has transcended cultures and time. The fact that we are still reading these stories shows that all of us are still looking for the proper way to enjoy our lives.

Qoheleth also struggles with judgment yet again in this passage. In 9:1-4 there is a sense that there is no reason to even be a good person because "as it is with the good man so with the sinner". What is the point of living a good life if we all die in the end? I think that the point is simply to live a god life. In 9:7 the tone shifts from hopeless whining to telling the reader how to live a good life. This is the message I have gotten from the rest of Qoheleth as well. All through the book we have had a sense that everything is meaningless, but I think it is all meaningless only because it does not last. Therefore we should enjoy ourselves while we are here and not worry about tomorrow.

Journal of Optimism

Eccl. 9:4-5
“But he who is joined with all the living has hope, for a living dog is better than a dead lion. For the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing, and they have no more reward, for the memory of them is forgotten.”
In his usual fashion Qohelet brings forth a contradiction to what he previously wrote. In 4:2-3 he says “And I thought the dead who are already dead more fortunate than the living who are still alive. But better than both is he who has not yet been and has not seen the evil deeds that are done under the sun.” I’ll let these verses serve as support for the argument that Ecclesiastes was written like a journal in which Qohelet wrestled with the unknown. Qohelet has a near obsession with knowledge and I think at times he grows tired of having it and other times he sees its necessity. In chapter 4 Qohelet talks about knowledge as if it was a curse. It’s as if that day he encountered something terrible or unjust and because of this experience he’s decided (temporarily) that knowledge is something that no man should want. I think his awareness of the state of the world and the evils that exist make him feel that he would rather not know anything which produces verses 2-3 in chapter 4.
In chapter 9, Qohelet returns to valuing knowledge over death. I think it’s important to understand what the knowledge is of in order to compare this passage to previous passages. In 9 he specifically says that “the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing.” At first it seemed strange to me to place importance on the awareness of certain death but this passage compliments 9:7-10. If people are aware that at some point they will die, they will cherish the moments they have with family and loved ones more than people who live their lives as if they are immortal. Also, it’s too late for the dead. They no longer have the opportunity to appreciate the people around them or their circumstances because they no longer exist. I suppose I can’t help but find optimism in Qohelet’s message but I think Qohelet , like any human, was burned by his life experiences and because of that he searched for meaning and purpose. I believe that what he found was the importance of love (not necessarily romantic) and interpersonal relationships.

Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Death and Uncertainty

In reading Fox's commentary on Ecclesiastes 6:10-8:9 I gained a new perspective on some of the seemingly more depressing verses of the passage. Phrases that I had at first though to simply be morose and hopeless took on a more complex--though no more cheerful--meaning.

This passage, unlike some of th previous chapters that speak to an extreme fear of death, seems to find a small comfort in the certainty or knowing that death will bring. In this, Qoheleth realizes, all his wisdom is lacking and is ultimately folly, as the only way he will ever become certain of what happens in death is to die. This certainty, he ultimately deems, is better than all of the uncertain, unknowable aspects of living.

This theme first seems clear to me in verse 6:12 "For who knows what is good for mortals while they live the few days of their vain life, which they pass like a shadow? For who can tell them what will be after them under the sun?" This theme is again repeated in chapter 7, verse 8: "Better is the end of a thing than its beginning." His doubt as to the ability of mortals to ever know is poignantly stated again in chapter 7, verses 23 and 24: "All this I have tested by wisdom; I said, 'I will be wise,' but it was far from me. That which is, is far off, and deep, very deep; who can find it out?" Qoheleth, a man deeply afraid of death, begins to see the virtue in it. Death brings an end to uncertainty and an end to the constant seeking without knowing.

I contrasted the message in this passage with that of the song "Me and a Gun" by Tori Amos (link: http://http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uKzCxi2yf5s&feature=related. I could only find a live performance so the quality isn't fantastic) In this song, the woman goes through a horrific ordeal and contemplates the relief death would brings. She has lived through a terrible experiences but because "She hasn't seen Barbados," hasn't seen all that the world has to offer in all of its uncertainty, she prefers to go on living. Perhaps Qoheleth feels that he has, in fact, seen all that the world has to offer and that is the difference between the two, however, I find it interesting the way that the certainty of death is comforting to one and that the uncertainty of life brings comfort to the other.

Better to Live, or to Never Be Born?

Chapter 7 of Ecclesiastes opens up with the Qoheleth seemingly almost condemning anything that could be labeled as "vanity". Time and again it is stated that laughter should be given up and replaced by mourning, for this is what a wise man would do. Whereas earlier chapters have spoken of the meaninglessness of material achievements and joy and pleasure, chapter 7 almost seems to directly curse such things. (7:5) says that it is better to heed the rebuke of a wise man than to listen to the song of fools. This is a glorification of criticism, cynicism and negativity, and a condemnation of rejoicing in pleasure and joy. From the view of the teacher, this fits in nicely with the assertion in verse 1 that claims the day of death is better than the day of birth.

Apparently we should all envy the man who doesn't have to suffer through 1.) The trials and tribulations of this life any longer (as stated in earlier chapters) 2.) They don't half to walk in circles any longer seeking a peace of mind and feeling of fulfilment that will never come and 3.) The realization that in the end, according to the teacher, joy is stupid anyway and the more you mourn and suffer the wiser you are, so thank God you don't have to deal with that anymore. The Qoheleth says a man should not be overwise, but he does assert that it is good to be wise. This almost points to a masochistic lifestyle since wisdom seems to be another word for suffering.

Qoheleth is Meaningless, Yet he Still Has his Moments

Despite the fact that Qoheleth eventually does offer advice for how to cultivate a meaningful existence, Ecc. 6:10-7:14 begins in a fashion that leaves the reader thinking that man is indeed a totally hopeless creature. Ecc. 6:10-12 functions as a concise introduction. Qoheleth begins this passage with an explanation of why it is the fate of man to be insignificant. In 6:10, he states, “Whatever has come to be has already been named, and it is known what human beings are...”. Since all things have already been named, or determined, the fate of human beings is already decided. Qoheleth goes on to point out that humans are not capable of disputing with those who are stronger, which is presumably God, wisdom, or someone divine. In 6:12, Qoheleth reminds humans that they “pass like a shadow” and that because of this they cannot really know what is good. This introduction is important because it opens the reader to the idea that man truly is meaningless in the grand scheme of the universe. It is imperative that the reader realizes this in the beginning because the rest of the passage is Qoheleth’s advice for how to make peace with this convoluted life.

There is an obscure shift to positivity in 7:1. Although it may be difficult to realize the positivity, Qoheleth is attempting to comfort his audience by helping them see the value in recognizing their insignificance. Qoheleth seems jaded when he says in 7:1 “...the day of death [is better], than the day of birth.” The reader must realize that Qoheleth is truly saying that recognizing the certainty of death is a means by which a person can see her life in perspective and enjoy it before it vanishes. This most constructive way of interpreting 7:1-4 considers Qoheleth’s musings as pre-requisites to enjoying life. Basically, you must realize that all will perish in the end, before you can understand that enjoying the moment is all that mortals ever have.

In Ecc. 7: 5-12, Qoheleth seems to feel that he has convinced his audience of the importance of living in the present. In this section of text, he turns to offering some real council for how to heed his advice. For example, in 7:10, he touches on the foolishness of nostalgia by warning the reader not to ask “Why were the former days better than these?”. In 7:12, he says that wisdom gives life. Wisely realizing the fleetingness of life is what enables a person to actually have a life that is enjoyed, to actually have a life worth living.

In keeping with his advocation that man is insignificant, Qoheleth returns the focus to God in 7:13. He says “Consider the work of God: who can make straight what he has made crooked?”. This verse seems to have dual meaning. The most obvious is that humans are powerless and that they cannot effect the will of God. However, on a deeper level, this verse hints that humans and God are not even viewing the world in a common language. Humans find something crooked that God considers straight. In 7:14, Qoheleth advises humans to live in the moment by being happy at the appropriate times and sad when adversity comes. Pointing out the dominance of God is excellent support for Qoheleth’s advice, because it leaves the reader with the idea that living with the highs and lows of life is all the she is capable of, therefore she might as well accept Qoheleth’s advice and enjoy all the fleeting moments that she is given.

Death and Wisdom

This section begins by echoing the earlier sentiments of mortality and the mundane quality of Earthly life (Eccl. 6:10-12). Chapter seven begins with a series of proverbs. Qoheleth says that “a good name is better than precious ointment and the day of death, than the day of birth” (7:1). I originally interpreted this to mean that to leave this purposeless world is better than entering it. However, I like Brown’s interpretation better. Brown states that “Qoheleth [recognizes] that human glory, if there is such a thing, is essentially a posthumous ‘victory’” (72). This interpretation relates back to the theme of Qoheleth’s fixation with being remembered because only after death does one have a chance of remembered. Naturally, one cannot technically be remembered while he or she is alive.


The next three verses continue similarly and place sorrow and mourning over gladness. In verse 4, Qoheleth states that “the heart of the wise is in the house of mourning; but the heart of fools is in the house of mirth.” Rather than saying that if we are wise, we should be mourning, I think maybe Qoheleth is saying that those who have wisdom have no choice but to mourn, for they understand the vanity of our Earthly lives. In this sense, wisdom is something of a Pandora’s box.


However, Qoheleth later praises wisdom, saying “the protection of wisdom is like the protection of money” (v. 12). I think this comparison raises an interesting point about where Qoheleth places his trust. Jeremiah 9:23-24 says “do not let the wise boast in their wisdom, do not let the mighty boast in their might, do not let the wealthy boast in their wealth; but let those who boast boast in this, that they understand and know me, that I am the Lord.” I think Ecclesiastes 5:1-7 make it clear that Qoheleth has a reverence for and belief in God, but maybe Qoheleth should take more comfort from knowing God than from his own wisdom.


In verse 14, Qoheleth asks the reader to “consider the work of God; who can make straight what he has made crooked?” I found this interesting because Qoheleth seems to be saying that although God is all powerful so what he has made crooked cannot be made straight, Qoheleth questions whether God knows what is best. If Qoheleth wishes to make straight something God has made crooked, does Qoheleth mean that he better understands what is “good” than God does? I think this is another example of Qoheleth trusting in his own wisdom instead the omnipotence of God.

Wisdom and Women

In this text from Ecclesiastes, the general theme seems to be on wisdom and what is better for man. Qohelet’s ideas are consistent in that he continues to bring up death and mourning as “better” than birth and feasting (7:1-2). He goes on to say “sorrow is better than laughter” (7:3a), and the “heart of the wise is in the house of mourning” (7:4a). I read this as a reality check – sadness and death reminds man of the inevitable destiny.

In 7:11-12, Qohelet praises wisdom, saying it is a good and beneficial thing. It is a shelter (just like money) but possessing knowledge means having the wisdom to preserve one’s life for longer. Qohelet goes on to say in 7:13-14 that man cannot discover anything about his future, so just be happy when things are great and when things are awful, remember God has made it so. I take this to mean that yes, wisdom is a good thing, and can protect those who have it and do not abuse it, yet man should not try to use their knowledge to guess the future, for that is futile.

After establishing wisdom is beneficial, Qohelet moves on to parallels he has seen in his life in 7:15-18. He warns of a life of extremes – a righteous man can perish in his righteousness and a wicked man lives long in his wickedness (7:15). Do not be too wise, or too foolish, for either way will knock you down. It is only those who find the balance, avoiding the extremes, who will fear and obey God sincerely.

Finally, I am a little bewildered at Qohelet’s statements about women at then end of chapter 7. He says a woman who is a snare, with her heart as a trap, is more bitter than death and it is the sinner who will become entangled (7:26). Then Qohelet goes on to say that he “found one upright man among a thousand, but not one upright woman among them all” (7:28). Is Qohelet saying women cannot authentically fear and obey God? Is this a result of the patriarchal society of ancient times or is Qohelet just a bitter bachelor?

Monday, September 13, 2010

Life is Vapor, Enjoy It. (sorry so late)


Ecclesiastes 5 begins by describing the proper way to worship God, with much emphasis on words in verses 1-7. Verse 2 states “God is in heaven and you are on earth, so let your words be few.” This verse shows that God is all-powerful and above us, so we should learn to listen to him rather than speak a lot. Verse 7 says that “Much dreaming and many words are meaningless. Therefore stand in awe of God,” proving that talking too much is vanity and that we do not listen and “stand in awe” of Him enough and enjoy His presence.

The next section would be 5:8-6:9, discussing the satisfaction that man tries to find in the world. These satisfactions vary from food, money, and the other things that we strive to find, yet never truly find the satisfaction that we are looking for. Verse 15 says “Naked a man comes from his mother's womb, and as he comes, so he departs. He takes nothing from his labor that he can carry in his hand.” We continuously try to find this satisfaction in worldly possessions but will only find true satisfaction through God. As humans, we “toil” but this is all vanity when it comes to the end of a mans life. I find this verse in some sense beautiful, reminding me to not worry about the worldly things and to focus more on God. There is then a shift in verse 18 where Qoheleth realizes that it is good for a man to enjoy all the things he has toiled over, even though we will leave the world with nothing, because in the end God wants humans to be happy. He must enjoy the work he has done because it is God’s gift to the world. It is better to enjoy the present than to wonder about the what if and the future.

Qoheleth then begins to contemplate again about the continuing hunger that man has towards worldly possessions and satisfactions. Stating in the end that we must enjoy what we have been given, including the worldly possessions. It may be vapor, but it is better to enjoy a meaningless life than to be constantly worried about the future. So bottom line? Enjoy your life, even if it is vapor.

"with the joy of their hearts"

The beginning of Ecclesiastes 5, Qoheleth presents the correct behavior in worshiping God, but warns against the vanity that can lie within. Ecc. 5:1 states, “to draw near to listen is better than the sacrifice offered by fools; for they do not know how to keep from doing evil”, this, along with 5:2, “Never be rash with your mouth, nor let your heart be quick to utter a word before God” illustrate how quickly worship can turn impertinent. Reverence must be pure, or else you are just listening to yourself talk, which is vanity. Qoheleth goes on to say “God is in heaven, and you on earth”, showing that God is above man, he is the supreme power, and we cannot fool him with meaningless words. This idea is confirmed in 5:8-9, Qoheleth discusses how to act when we observe the “oppression of the poor and the violation of justice and right”. He tells us “do not be amazed” or in essence, not to worry when we experience this, for there is always someone in a higher position watching over. God is not just some idle bystander; he will come to judge the oppressors and the violators. I feel as though you would have to have an abundance of faith to watch this happening and believe that a just God is allowing it and will bring the wrongdoers into judgment some day though.

In Ecc. 5:18-20 Qoheleth is saying again how eating, drinking and finding enjoyment in all the toil is what is good and how we should be continuing the days we have on this earth. The last line of the chapter is my favorite though, 5:20 states “For they will scarcely brood over the days of their lives, because God keeps them occupied with the joy of their hearts”. I cannot imagine anyone reading this line in a depressing light. If we can realize that God has given us worth beyond that of the gains from toiling under the sun, then nothing in life is “meaningless” at all, in fact all of our toil has more value then we could ever imagine. I find all of chapter 5 to be the most uplifting section of Ecclesiastes we have analyzed so far.

In the song “Casimir Pulaski Day” by Sufjan Stevens ( http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9EzeW5KoPUI ) it is obvious that he is singing about the decay of someone close to him, and his internal conflict with why God would allow this to happen. In the line “All the glory that the Lord has made and the complications you could do without” I believe we can hear a somewhat sarcastic approach by mentioning the glory of the lord, and this obvious terrible mistake he has made by giving this ill human all of these obstacles that were not necessary. In the last two verses of this song, the singer addresses his own interactions with God, I think he doesn’t understand why God let this happened and is most likely really hurt and confused. I can see how this song ties into this weeks’ reading though, you must have faith in a just God that knows best and will be fair in the end.

"Wandering of the Soul"

In Ecc. Chapter 5, vv. 1-6, Qohelet’s point seems to be that you should think before you speak. He speaks of being cautious in making vows, because unlike God, humans can’t discern the future. Verses three and four are very similar to Deuteronomy. While Deuteronomy talks about the guilt you’ll feel in breaking a vow, Ecclesiastes speaks of what will come of revoking your vows (betray your vows, God will destroy your possessions).

Qohelet says in Chapter 5 verse seven to not wonder at oppression/suppression of the poor. It sounds as if Qohelet doesn’t foresee improvements in social oppression. He says that everyone must tend their land in order to survive. He notably uses the word “control” in talking about the land (“he controls a field that is cultivated”, 5:8). Verses 9-12, Qohelet speaks of the futility of the love of money. The purpose of money is instant gratification, but you will soon want more. Money ignites greed in others, and causes the holder of wealth to have anxiety about losing it to another. Qohelet sees it as pointless to have money and lose it never having enjoyed it, or to have money due to God, but God does not allow you to enjoy it. Qohelet sees working and never gaining anything from it as the worst case scenario. He believes the best thing to do is use your money in a timely fashion in a way that would please you.

In Chapter 6 verses 7-9, Qohelet talks of what we have (“feasting of the eyes”) versus what we want (“the pursuit of desires”). If we our enjoying our lives/possessions or “feasting our eyes”, it’s good. But if we start wanting other things (“pursuit of desire”), we forget about whatever we were enjoying and the things we were enjoying are lost…this leaves us with nothing, thus making it all hevel.

And he takes and he takes and he takes.

It wasn't until the end of Sufjan Steven's, Casimir Pulaski Day, that I put together our reading from Ecclesiastes and the song. I'm going to need a therapist after this class haha. Dread, doom, dread.

Qoheleth talks about man having everything under the sun and not having anything at the same time. The rich being prosperous yet not being happy with his earning or losing everything they have earned so that his son still has no earnings from his toils.

Eccl. 5:1-4 suprised me, it didn't have the same tone as the rest of what we have read from Ecclesiastes. The heading for this section, Stand in Awe of God, but I percieved it as more Stand in Fear of him. "Gaurd your steps when you go to the house of God. Gonear to listen rather than to offer the sacrifice of fools, who do not know that they do wrong. Do not be quick with your mouth, do not be hasty in your heart to utter anything before God." (Ecc. 5:1-2) Sounds like more of a warning if you ask me. Should we fear God? Or should we look at him in a fraternal way?

After listening to Casimir Pulaski Day, I got the feeling that while they were talking about the father driving to the Navy yard when he heard that the daughter (I'm guessing daughter) had bone cancer, and that he drove there to say he was sorry, that somehow he was supposed to be interpretted as God. Thinking of God as your father and then interpreting the song in that sense made the song make more sense to me.

The Riches are Worthless

Ecclesiates chapter 5 begins with a meditation on the worship of God.  Qohelet sees no point in making sacrifices to God when God is in heaven and man is on Earth (v. 1-2).  The realm of God has no need for money or slaughtered animals.  What man can offer to God is fulfilled vows, unfulfilled vows come from fools who speak empty words.  Silence is preferable to empty, ill-chosen words, it is better to listen to God because as someone on earth what can be said to God who transcends earth.  Therefore it is better to let your words be few in front of God (v. 2).  I’m not sure if this means Qohelet thinks that God does not do anything about human concerns or if there is no connection between Earth and God.  In “Casimir Pulaski Day” the sick person was prayed for but nothing happened.


Money is an earthly thing that man foolishly tries to collect.  The rich are Money cannot be taken with man when he dies yet rich men spend all of their time trying to get more of it (v. 10). The rich are never satisfied with their wealth.  So much so that the rich man cannot sleep while the laborer's sleep is “sweet” (v. 11-12) Man leaves the world as he enters it (v.15), a man cannot take what he has earned from to work to whatever happens after death.  At the end of this section, Qohelet realizes that is its good for man to enjoy the short life that God as given him and enjoy whatever wealth he has received, unlike the rich man who always wants more and can never enjoy what he has (v. 18-19).  In verse 20, Qohelet seems to think that a man who follows this advice has a good life in the sense that he does not worry about the shortness and meaning of his life because he is focused on enjoying simple pleasures (eating, drinking, finding joy).       


In chapter 6 Qohelet says that the inability to enjoy things is a “grievous evil” (v.1-2).  He thinks that a stillborn child, who never knows anything of existence, is better off than a man who does not enjoy his good fortune (v. 3).  I’m not sure what Qohelet means by the man not receiving a proper burial, maybe not receiving a burial is like being unfulfilled.  I’m guessing the hypothetical man’s 100 children did not care for him because he was not enjoying his life including not enjoying his children.   

And he takes and he takes and he takes

Ecclesiastes 5:1-6:9

The opening lines of Ecclesiastes 5 are instructions regarding how one should act in the presence of God. Qoheleth uses the setting of the temple to instruct the reader to “draw near to listen.” Qoheleth believes that it is better to listen than to offer a sacrifice that is not genuine. He evokes a sense of humility from the reader when he says that it is better to be silent than to speak “ for God is in heaven, and you upon the earth” (v.2). Qoheleth seems to be suggesting that God’s thoughts are higher than our thoughts. He is beyond human understanding, therefore, we are incapable of understanding his movements or his ways.

A rather abrupt shift occurs in verse 8 when Qoheleth begins to talk about the “oppression of the poor and the violation of justice” as an everyday occurrence. He then makes another unusual shift by saying, “the high official is watched by a higher, and there are yet higher ones over them. But all things considered, this is an advantage for a land; a king for a plowed field.” Even after reading Brown’s commentary on this portion of the text, I am still completely confused as to the meaning of this passage.

In the next section of chapter five (v.10,) Qoheleth says the lover of money will never be satisfied. The more they get, the more they shall want. Even carefully guarded wealth can be lost. Qoheleth writes that in the end material wealth is meaningless, because we will all end up in the same place. Humans gain nothing from their toil. Once again, Qoheleth suggests that man eat, drink, and find enjoyment in the few days he has been given.In chapter six, Qoheleth discovers an evil that he says, “lies heavy upon humankind.” God gives wealth and then does not enable the wealthy to enjoy it – “ And he takes and he takes and he takes” (Casmir Pulaski Day). Man be given much in the way of material possessions, land, and children, but if he cannot enjoy it, Qoheleth says that “ a stillborn child is better off than he” (v.3) Qoheleth believes that a long life that is never filled with joy is worse than no life at all.

Qoheleth ends this section in chapter six by saying that humans will never be satisfied. They will always desire more than they have been given. It is important to see the good and find enjoyment in the very act of recognizing the good, rather than the act itself, which will only result in further desires which cannot be fulfilled.

Wednesday, September 8, 2010

Up in the Vapor

Most people have multiple differing relationships with numerous people that are greatly valued and cherished. That is not the case for Ryan Bingham played by George Clooney in the 2009 film “Up in the Air.”

Ryan is a loner who flies around the country firing people for a living and also, strangely enough, is a motivational speaker. Ryan is at home when he is flying from place to place. He loves all the things about air travel that most people hate right down to the cheap sushi. He is also working on flying 10 million miles to be only the seventh person to ever do so and have his name placed on an airplane. Ryan really knows how to travel, he knows how to get all the perks and benefits, he knows all the shortcuts, and he knows how to travel light. He also travels light with the relationships with people in his life.

In his motivational speeches he claims that “relationships are the heaviest components of your life.” He tells his audience that their relationships take up too much of their life and that they should not put as much into them. Perhaps Ryan has this “philosophy” on relationships because he does not see anything meaningful. This of course is similar to the plight of the author of Ecclesiastes.

Perhaps Qohelet and Ryan have such an innate fear of mortality that they force themselves to believe that there is no meaning to life. If they have no meaningful life then once their death comes around then nothing is lost.

Qohelet and Ryan both agree that “we all end up in the same place… there is no point.” (Ecc. 2:15). However, both offer some glimmer of hope in the value of a companion. Qohelet says, “Two are better than one, because they have good reward for their toil.” (4:9) Just after Ryan starts to believe that life is better with a companion he is given the opportunity to mend his relationship with his sister by talking to her groom-to-be with cold feet on the day of the wedding. The groom also thinks there is no point to life because he believes that we all end up dead anyway so Ryan tells him to think of all his favorite memories. He then asks him if he was alone in any of those memories. “Life is better with company,” Ryan offers to the cold feet groom, “everybody needs a copilot.”

Crap Happens and Then You Die

So pretend there is a back pack. In this backpack, there is every physical possession and relationship a man has ever owned. Well now the back pack is pretty heavy, so has to decide what to keep in it and what to take out. How does one decide what is important and what means the most to him. Up In the Air, raises this question and gives various possible answers to it. From the protagonist, it can be concluded that nothing really matters, and there is virtually no need to keep anything in the backpack. The protagonist’s point of view suggests that none of it is worth having; in fact, all of these things will do nothing but hold a person back from other aspirations, dreams, and experiences. So, with nothing holding a man back, he is free to climb the proverbial mountains and make his claims on all sorts of triumphs, such as accumulating ten million frequent flier miles. Up in the Air suggests, as I understood it, that the sky is the limit and that with nothing towing a man down, he is free to reach it.
Alas, the problem with this ‘philosophy’ is that once the sky has been reached, what else is there. Where does one go? Does he go home to his family? Where does he go if he has no home? Most importantly, what is the point of this amazing accomplishments and feats if the man accomplishing them has no one to share them with? Furthermore, who is there to remember.
The book of Ecclesiastes also suggests the futilities of… well, everything. Everything is futile. Lives start; lives stop. Stuff happens and then everyone dies, and in the end none of it matters because the rivers will keep flowing and the sun will keep rising. With an outlook as bleak as this one, I would conclude that the author would be apathetic to all things including all things good, bad, and ugly. The author does however mention briefly that all things are futile, and one of the reasons he gives for that is that no one will remember. No one will remember who won the foot race; no one will remember who won the space race. It is all futile.
“What is with men’s obsession to pee on every tree?” Men seek to be remembered is a claim struck by the film. Whether it was having the main character’s name on the side of an airplane or simply not being forgotten over the years, both Ecclesiastes and the film showed a slight desire to be remembered. So, in regards to claims made by the film for the benefits of an empty backpack, is it really worth being able to reach the sky if there is no one to share in the glory. Is it worth it if no one remembers?

What's the Point?

During the movie “Up in the Air” which casts George Clooney as the protagonist Ryan Bingham, we are entered into a world of airline travel and isolation. Ryan Bingham’s job is to travel around to other companies and fire employees for bosses who are too pansy to do it themselves. It sounds like horrible work, never being home, traveling in crowed airports all the time, but Bingham loves it. He discusses how he couldn’t imagine living any other way, here in the sky is where he calls home. Bingham’s whole life is about efficiency and he proves himself to be very efficient by using the fastest car rental place, by swiping his elite status cards at every checkpoint and being able to cram his whole existence in to one carry-on suitcase. He runs away from family and from any type of human connection because he doesn’t know why he should care. His life is shifted when he meets Alex, a women who lives or so he thinks a very similar lifestyle to him and then again when he is asked to work with Natalie the new up-in-coming associate in his office. His world of isolation is shifted into a world of companionship and connection. He attends his sister’s wedding with Alex and realizes that he likes having her around. Suddenly he has the backbone for the first time in his life to step up and be there to support his sister. He even saves the day when her fiancĂ© gets cold feet before the wedding. The fiancĂ© asks what the point of life is if at the end we just die. Bingham responds that there is no point because at the end you will just die, but wouldn’t you rather spend the time you do have here on earth with somebody. He no longer wishes to be isolated, but to suffer through life with someone by his side. Bingham flies to Chicago to tell Alex, but discovers that she has been lying all the time and that she has a family. After putting his heart on the line it gets crushed by someone he really cared about. Is it worth it? Having all the feelings of pain and suffering of love on top of the pain and suffering of life. I think it is and so does the book of Ecclesiastes.

Qoheleth in the book of Ecclesiastes talks about the oppressions in life and how people are living lives of vanity. He discusses how people like Bingham are toiling away and gaining nothing, “For all their days are full of pain, and their work is a vexation; even at night their minds do not rest. This also is vanity” (2:23). He also is trying to discover the meaning of life, the purpose of his existence on earth and the reason for him to keep on living. Most of Ecclesiastes is dark, but one of the lighter parts is when Qoheleth talks about companionship. He says “Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their toil. For if they fall, one will lift up the other; but woe to one who is alone and falls and does not have another to help” (4:9-10). Qoheleth is acknowledging that that while life is not easy and most of the time it is horrible, if you have to suffer through it you should suffer through it with someone else. Bingham also comes to this realization during the movie, because he discovers that companionship is what he is missing. Qoheleth doesn’t give a lot of reasons to live in this book and even states that the best scenario would be if you didn’t live at all, but he makes room for eight verses to describe companionship. Obviously companionship became important to him at some point in his life. So maybe life doesn’t have a purpose, maybe it’s just important to find someone who is willing to search for that purpose with you.

Co-Pilots and Companionship

I liked the movie Up in the Air in the same way that I like Ecclesiastes; they're not the perfect little happy stories. Yes, they are kinda sad ans depressing, but they are real and talk about true human thoughts and troubles. Last year when I first saw the movie, Ecc and its references ever crossed my mind. But on the second viewing I saw many similarities. However, i don't think that Up in the Air was based on or had its roots in Ecc. Qohelet in Ecc was struggling with legitimate queries and doubts pertaining to life. Those same questions are still reside in people today, but instead of writing about it, a movie was made. (This kinda supports Qohelets idea that wisdom can only take a person so far. People today struggle with things that people thousands of years ago struggled with; obviously we haven't made much progress). Up in the Air and Ecc have similar themes throughout but that doesn't necessarily mean they were based on one another.

In Up in the Air we learn about the life of Ryan Bingham (George Clooney), a corporate downsizing expert (aka: an expert at firing people) who cherishes his 24/7 isolating job. In the beginning Ryan sees no immediate need for family, friends, or a home. He lives out of a suitcase, is a stranger to his family and doesn't have any real friends. This all changes when Ryan's company hires a new young employee, Natalie. Natalie developed a method of video conferencing that will allow Ryan and his co-workers to fire people without leaving "home". This basically threatens the life Ryan cherishes. To prove Natalie wrong, Ryan takes Natalie on a cross country firing spree. While on this trip Ryan begins to see the downfalls in his way of life. His belief that 10 million frequent flyer miles will make him satisfied begins to shift when Natalie pokes and tests Ryans lifestyle. She asks him questions on family, love, and marriage. Only after convincing his sisters fiance to go through with the marriage saying that life sucks but its suckiness is better when someone else is there...a "co-pilot" does he truly convince himself. Here is where Ryans importance of life changes from frequent flyer miles to companionship. Ryan then decides that Alex, his girlfriend/friend with benefits is someone he wants in his life permanently and wants to have a home, family and friends.

I think that Ryan Binghams life and the book of Ecc mirror each other in themes. Qohelet searches for meaning in self-indulgence (2:3-11) but found short lived pleasure (2:11). Ryan Bingham looked for meaning his accomplishments (frequent flyer miles) and self-indulgence (golden access cards, specific travel cars) but never found true and whole satisfaction. Qohelet also tries to use wisdom to find and reach the meaning (1:13), but only found sorrow and vexation (1:18). Ryan, I believe, was intrigued and somewhat enlightened by Natalie and Alex to a new meaning of life, but Ryan only found sorrow because he discovered that he was truly alone. Finally Qohelet decides that the world is what it is, nothing can change it (3:14-15), and it stinks. But Qohelet discovers that the world, even in its vanity, can still have joy if you have companionship (4:9-12). Ryan comes to the conclusion at his sisters wedding that he needs his own co-pilot.
Both Ecc and Up in the Air conclude with the notion that life stinks and it will always stink but it can be bearable with others.