Sunday, September 26, 2010

Ecclesiastes Needed More CGI Rose Petals

In AMERICAN BEAUTY (Sam Mendes, 1999), Lester Burnham (Kevin Spacey) is a man without a purpose. He has become so listless that his life barely even qualifies as one. He feels like he has been dead for a long time. Then, he sees something that pulls him out of his existential funk, his daughter's friend Angela (Mena Suvari), a Lolita-esque vision of highly sexualized youth. From that point forward, he starts living his life for one purpose, his own enjoyment. The enjoyment based life is an idea that is emphasized repeatedly in Ecclesiastes, but does it work for Lester Burnham and would Qoheleth approve of Lester's choices? It's difficult to say. Does Alan Ball's Oscar-winning screenplay make Lester out to be a wise man who has found the secret to life or as a selfish asshole who abdicates his responsibilities as a husband and father.
The answer seems to be somewhere in the middle, but there is an incredibly telling moment near the end of the film. Lester has finally has obtained his ultimate prize; Angela is his for the taking. When she tells him she is a virgin, though, something clicks back into place for Lester. You could say that he, for lack of a better term, became an adult again. He quickly goes into paternal mode, consoling Angela. While she's in the restroom, he gazes contently at an old family picture in his last moment of life. It sends a very complicated message, but the message I gleaned from the film can be boiled down to this: the oppressiveness of suburban domesticity can cause to miss the real beauty in front of their eyes, namely their families, and do drastic things to recapture their own identity. With that reading in mind, it seems clear that Alan Ball (and Sam Mendes, for that matter) don't seem to support a life based entirely on enjoyment. Would Qoheleth support Lester's life, though?
In Ecc 5:17 Qoheleth states, "Only this, I have found, is a real good: that one should eat and drink and get pleasure with all the gains he makes under the sun". Lester seems to take this to heart. He quits his job, buys a sports car, and lusts after younger women. In the process, though, he alienates everyone around him. I feel as though Lester Burnham takes the ideas of Qoheleth to their logical extreme, to the point where is damages others' lives. On paper, Lester seems like a perfect model of Qohelth's philosophy, but he takes it to its breaking point, to the point that shows the fault in Qoheleth's thought.

2 comments:

  1. Maggie said...
    Lance, I really like your point about how Lester is taking Qoheleth's ideas to the extreme. I felt the same way. Even if Lester is in some ways trying to live life to the fullest I believe that he has reached a breaking point and is no longer fulfilling what Qoheleth is actually is trying to teach.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm not quite sure that Lester's full realization and implementation of Qoheleth's ideas about enjoyment are as negative as you are both making it seem. When Lester was looking at the family photograph, I thought that he had realized the importance of his family and the enjoyment that they could bring. Also, it seemed that he rejected his responsibilities as husband and father BEFORE he realized Qoheleth's wisdom. Basically, when he was all caught up in work and seeming perfect, he neglected his family because he simply couldn't see the potential joy in them. Unfortunately, Lester's life ended too soon for us to see if his enjoyment philosophy helped his family relationship, but I don't see anything in the movie to indicate that it wouldn't have. Lester did have a bad relationship with is wife, but after all, she was having an affair and was entirely too caught up in her job. The relationship with his daughter also wasn't so great, but I thought that this was something that could have turned around if Lester and Jane could have both realized that they had something to offer one another. Basically, the enjoyment philosophy would have been more of a healing presence in Lester's life instead of such a negative one.

    ReplyDelete