Monday, September 20, 2010

The Righteous vs. The Sinners

In this section Qoheleth begins by wondering why those who commit sins sometimes go without punishment and why those who are righteous are often the ones who get punished. He returns to a point in Ecclesiastes 8: 13, that humans should fear God and that those who hold him in reverence are still better off then those who go around sinning. For those who continue to sin and refuse to fear God live their lives as if they are in a “shadow”, as opposed to the people who fear God and “toil through the days of life that God gives them under the sun” (8: 15). I also believe that another question gets answered in this section. We have been discussing Qoheleth’s view on work and if he truly believes that the only way to live is to be merry and have a good time under the sun, but in this section he states “ So I commend enjoyment, for there is nothing better for people under the sun than to eat, and drink, and enjoy themselves, for this with go with them in their toil through the days of life that God gives them under the sun” (8: 15). Qoheleth uses the word “toil” in this verse to explain his point that your work should also be worth living for. I think he is finally declares that work is part of the enjoyment of life and he wants people to find a balance between work and toil.

Qoheleth goes on to discuss those who have spent time thinking about death will often feel despair because they will never be able to gain enough wisdom so that they can understand death. This discovery can be discouraging, but he claims, “then I saw all the work of God, that no one can find out what is happening under the sun” (8: 17). Qoheleth seems to take comfort in the fact that no one else can answer this question because then he does not feel like as much of a failure and therefore his pride can remain intact. He then restates his point about how that everyone will eventually suffer the same fate and that the greatest evil in the world is not what happens under the sun, but is the eventually death of everyone. I really feel that he is trying to drill this idea in our heads because this is the second time he has mentioned it and he wants it to be known that this is what he actually believes.

In this section Qoheleth finally seems to be dealing with some of the issues that he has been going back and forth on throughout this text. He has made some concrete claims that actually make sense and he is willing to repeat as opposed to recant.

1 comment:

  1. I agree with you that Qoheleth is to some extent advocating toiling for something that is "worth living for".. But still, what does Qoheleth think is worth living for? Is he vouching for something like an individual pursuit of happiness? It seems to me that to ever fully to understand what Qoheleth means, we would have to know what type of person he was. Does he have any place in his head or heart for notions of community or civilization, as significant factors in dealing with the weariness of life?

    Nonetheless, whatever his character traits may be, I think think based on his contradicting emotional tones, its safe to say that before anything Qoheleth is a Realist.

    ReplyDelete