Wednesday, September 1, 2010

Joy from God

Qohelet begins this section by describing how he first sought meaning through wisdom, but finds no fulfillment in knowledge. Qohelet is disillusioned, stating that “what is twisted cannot be straightened” (1:15). For all of his wisdom, Qohelet has found that simply understanding the world does not enable him to bring meaning to it. Moreover, Qohelet has found that not only does wisdom not bring meaning to the world, but also that “with much wisdom comes much sorrow” and “the more knowledge, the more grief” (1:18). Like the saying “ignorance is bliss,” Qohelet believes that having the wisdom to understand the futility of life brings more pain than a lack of understanding.
In chapter two, Qohelet first describes how he tried to find meaning in pleasure. Verses three through nine relate the luxuries and joys Qohelet had. Twice in this verses Qohelet makes the point that he maintained his wisdom throughout his search for pleasure. This could possibly be to make clear that he never lost himself to pleasure and that perhaps those who devote themselves entirely to pleasure and “folly” (1:3) do not suffer the frustration of searching for purpose and meaning. Similarly, the Kanye West song “Diamonds from Sierra Leone” relates a pleasure filled existence. The singer seems only interested in prestige and material wealth, but rather than being utterly lost to pleasure, the singer, like Qohelet, questions the lasting significance of his joys (“Forever ever? Forever, ever? Ever, ever?”). In contrast, the Alanis Morissette song “Would Not Come” echoes the frustrations of Qohelet. The singer finds that no pleasure or efforts ever bring fulfillment (“I’d be the hero and still it would not come,” “I’d be filthy rich and still it would not come”). Additionally, the sense of chaos in the music depicts the senselessness of the world that has no meaning.
Despite the depressing message of the passage, verses twenty four through twenty six offer hope. In verse twenty four, Qohelet states that “a man can do nothing better than to eat and drink and find satisfaction in his work.” As Brown explains in his interpretation of Ecclesiastes, “no longer is enjoyment to be gained from one’s toil; it is recognized as part and parcel of one’s work, discerned within the labor, an intrinsic joy” (p. 38). Thus, although the world and all of our actions in it is meaningless, there is hope in the joys of simple gifts. Additionally, Qohelet states that these joys are “from the hand of God, for without him, who can eat or find enjoyment?” (2:24-25). Because our ability to experience pleasure is itself a gift from God, pleasure cannot be found in one’s own searching. Rather, pleasure and joy are experienced in the basic necessities of life that God gives us. For Qohelet, the world is meaningless and without God, the world is not only meaningless, but also without any pleasure.

5 comments:

  1. Beth, in response to versus 2:24-26, which could easily be interpreted in many ways, you provided a thoughtful analysis. My question is about your last sentence,
    "For Qohelet, the world is meaningless and without God, the world is not only meaningless, but also without any pleasure."
    Does this mean that God is not at all within the world and that is the reason the world is meaningless? Qohelet seems ambiguous in addressing Gods interaction with the world and his providence. Sometimes Qohelet sounds like he believes that God has preordained his (and everyone else's) every move, which would definitely be a reason for despair in the inescapably of life meaninglessness, but your sentence sounds like a different interpretation. Are you inferring that Qohelet believes he has a direct relationship with God, and so has meaning in his life, that God is in his life and yet life is still meaningless, or that God is nowhere near, which is why life is meaningless?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also felt that Qohelet tried to find meaning in his pleasures. He was living the life of wealth and vanity and trying to obtain wisdom, but at the end of the day he discovered that all the wealth and vanity and wisdom couldn’t give him the meaning he wanted out of the world. I found it so interesting that after saying this a few verses later he recants on this statement and says that “ a man can do nothing better than to eat and drink and find satisfaction in his work.” Qohelet seems to be going back and forth on this point because of his own personal experiences; he doesn’t know what he believes.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with your interpretation of the Kanye song being about someone who is consumed by materialism and a desire for possessions. I also think it's interesting that he references how he's taking over where Jay-Z left off. This seems to contradict what Qohelet says about leaving your wisdom and skill to someone who has not worked for it.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree. The Kanye song tied in with today's reading extremely well. Qohelet was upset by not being remembered and who would have his possessions after his death. Yes it's something to be concerned about, but life isn't about the possessions and materials that people are concerned.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I also agree with how well the song from Kanye tied into todays reading. In response to the previous comment, I agree that Qohelet was upset by not being remembered and where his possessions go, and that life isn't about the possessions that we have, but Qohelet reminds me of the typical american consumer who believes we have to have pleasures and possessions to be happy. Life isn't about these things, but so many of us fall into the trap of possessions. Maybe this was Qohelet's problem too?

    ReplyDelete