This blog represents the work of the students of RELI 227 "Skeptics in Scripture" at Hendrix College. We are a community of learning investigating the biblical texts of Job and Ecclesiastes. Your thoughtful comments are invited and encouraged.
Sunday, September 26, 2010
Lame, Lester...
Lester Burnam (Kevin Spacey), the narrator of the film American Beauty, according to modern American suburban standards, had everything. He lived in a well-furnished two story house, married an attractive realtor wife, fathered a cute daughter, and could put on a cheerful smile when needed. But, like Kohelet, he eventually reached a breaking point at which his life seemed to have lost direction and meaning. To our generation, Lester's breakdown looks like a mid-life crisis, a time at which everything he had been suppressing bursts back into consciousness. A Freudian interpretation would fit well here for Lester (as well as for every other character in the film), but there are things other than sex that he was ignoring. He had ignored his need for personal meaning. Everything in his life revolved around paying for his expensive lifestyle, leaving no room for personal growth or pleasure. So suddenly, his need sprung forth! Beautiful girls entranced him! He bought a sports car! Smoking pot was liberating! And just when he felt, for the first time in a very long time, that everything was good, he died. In Kohelets eyes, his death would be a perfectly obvious sign that his actions were foolish. Just because Lester could get high and fantasize about an underage girl does not make his life any better. He still died didn't he? His problems with his wife were left unresolved, his daughter will forever carry guilt and stunt her own happiness, and the man next door will have even more problems accepting his sexuality. Ridding yourself of tedious obligations and replacing them with pleasure and a shallow sense of wisdom, even if they dull the pain, does not augment the meaning of one's life. Way to deceive yourself, Lester! (says Kohelet).
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I disagree that Qoheleth would tell Lester that he had decived himself. In my interpretation of Qoheleth the things that Lester was searching for are the same things that Qoh was searching for. I think Qoh would have told Lester that he was on the right track and then tell him that "pot is no good I tried it in the 1850s and it was an uncool scene man." I am looking mainly at 9:7 where Qoh says to enjoy your life while you are here. Then in 9:12 no man knows when his time will come so it is a good thing that Lester did what he could while he was still alive.
ReplyDeleteI agree with jam325. I think the "striving after wind" that Qohelet talks about is perfectly exemplified in American Beauty. This is especially the case if we accept that Solomon wrote Ecclesiastes since he had many concubines.
ReplyDeleteI also have to disagree, i think that Qoheleth's teaching and beliefs are portrayed in American Beauty, but like Lance said in his blog, I think that lester has taken this "teaching" to the extreme and actually ruined more things instead of fixing them, but by the time he realized it he was murdered. This exemplifies the importance of living for today, because no man knows when his time will end. You just might die when you figure out what is meaningful.
ReplyDeleteI think that Qoheleth would have considered Lester a model student. He seems to fully embody Qoheleth's advice about enjoying the moment, which can be seen in his extreme impulses to seize the day, which for him meant buying a sports car and sleeping with a teenager. Also, Lester seems to realize the futility of life. He knows that everything is basically meaningless, he doesn't even care that his wife is having an affair. He seems to fully embody Qoheleth's go with the flow attitude. The only way Qoheleth would find Lester lame is if he thinks that his own life philosophy is lame, which I guess could be argued.
ReplyDelete