In this text from Ecclesiastes, the general theme seems to be on wisdom and what is better for man. Qohelet’s ideas are consistent in that he continues to bring up death and mourning as “better” than birth and feasting (7:1-2). He goes on to say “sorrow is better than laughter” (7:3a), and the “heart of the wise is in the house of mourning” (7:4a). I read this as a reality check – sadness and death reminds man of the inevitable destiny.
In 7:11-12, Qohelet praises wisdom, saying it is a good and beneficial thing. It is a shelter (just like money) but possessing knowledge means having the wisdom to preserve one’s life for longer. Qohelet goes on to say in 7:13-14 that man cannot discover anything about his future, so just be happy when things are great and when things are awful, remember God has made it so. I take this to mean that yes, wisdom is a good thing, and can protect those who have it and do not abuse it, yet man should not try to use their knowledge to guess the future, for that is futile.
After establishing wisdom is beneficial, Qohelet moves on to parallels he has seen in his life in 7:15-18. He warns of a life of extremes – a righteous man can perish in his righteousness and a wicked man lives long in his wickedness (7:15). Do not be too wise, or too foolish, for either way will knock you down. It is only those who find the balance, avoiding the extremes, who will fear and obey God sincerely.
Finally, I am a little bewildered at Qohelet’s statements about women at then end of chapter 7. He says a woman who is a snare, with her heart as a trap, is more bitter than death and it is the sinner who will become entangled (7:26). Then Qohelet goes on to say that he “found one upright man among a thousand, but not one upright woman among them all” (7:28). Is Qohelet saying women cannot authentically fear and obey God? Is this a result of the patriarchal society of ancient times or is Qohelet just a bitter bachelor?
i find Qohelet's statements about the woman who is a snare a little disconcerting as well. The likely explanation i would point to is the heavily patriarchal society. But surely he is not talking about all women. What i take from that is the "woman who is a snare" is one who would keep you from your search for wisdom or living how God want's you to.
ReplyDeleteI really didn't understand Qohelet's statements about women because wasn't he just a few chapters earlier discussing that "two are better than one"? It seems to be misogynistic passage written by someone who has been burned by a woman before and never really got over it. And is he really that pretentious that he thinks he is "one man among a thousand"?
ReplyDeleteI don't think Qohelet is speaking of female companionship we he says that "two are better than one". It seems to me he is talking about platonic male companionship. He says that one of the reasons that two are better than one is in case of an attack, which wouldn't make sense if he were discussing female companionship.
ReplyDeleteIn Brown's commentary he seems to think that Qoheleth's comments about women are as a result of the patriarchal society and he also links Qohelet's woman to the woman of Ecclesiastes who led men into sin. It would be interesting to compare both of the commentaries in class tomorrow and evaluate this particular passage.
ReplyDeleteWhether or not the interpretation of Qoheleth as simply a man resentful women is accurate, it would be a funny twist to his writing. Fox provides an interpretation of 8:26-28, explaining that Qoheleth "constantly sought a woman to marry but never found one...so that married life was another part of happiness that escaped him."(p.53) This would imply that Qoheleth, at least for a time, saw the potential for happiness. It is easier to deny the desire for happiness when it is out of reach, anyways.
ReplyDeleteI believe Kate meant the woman in Proverbs, not the woman in Ecclesiastes (since that's the same book as Qoheleth). See Brown's commentary on page 83 and Proverbs 2:16-19, 5:3-6, 7:6-27, 9:13-18.
ReplyDelete