Again Qoheleth's biggest fear is being forgotten. Yet the part that seems to upset him the most, is that even the wisest of men are forgotten. He tells the story of a brave old wise man that stood up to the king and saved his small town (Ecc. 9:13-18) and after all the old man had done, he was still forgotten in the end. I believe that Qoheleth has this all wrong. Eben after the old man's death we still remember him because we read about him through Qoheleth and his writings. In some fashion or another, someone will remember you.
The differences between wise men and foolish men are stated throughout our readings (Ecclesiastes 9:111-12:8). Qoheleth seems to have made up his mind about wither or not it is better or worse to be a wise man or a foolish man. (Yayy Qoheleth!) In Ecclesiastes 10:12 he stats that "Words from a wise man's mouth are gracious, but a fool is consumed by his own lips." To me, this implies that a wise man word's are few but hold a lot of meaning but a fool says whatever passes his lips without a second thought. He also goes on to say that many of the foolish have most of the authority possessions while the wise and the people that should hold those offices are not, they are just as ordinary as anyone else. He also heeds his readers not to speak of these foolish men in office for a "bird" could hear your conversations and you shall be in a big trouble for it. It makes me wonder what was done during this time period to tick him off so badly. My thoughts would be that hearing the story of the old wise man being forgotten and bashed by the king offends him because he, more than anyone, can relate to the old man. To Qoheleth, that had proved his theory of being a hero, yet no one remembering.
I didn't take the story of the old man to be true. I felt that it was a sort of parable, that Qohelet gave us a situation that has, can, and will occur. By writing about the wise man, he presented a "hero," that hero saved the day, and then died, leaving no one to really remember him. If, let's say, it was a real story, I still think Qohelet has a point. No one reading this text knows the specific old man. He's an ambiguous character written in, I believe, to serve a point and show you that memory is not all it's cracked up to be.
ReplyDeleteEven if this anecdote about the wise man is true, we never hear his name, so he ultimately is forgotten. Moreover, there are countless other wise men that are lost to history. I think Qoheleth has always thought that wisdom is better than foolishness, but that they are both ultimately meaningless. Even the wise man, who is technically better, will be forgotten
ReplyDelete