Monday, August 30, 2010

Computer Problems. Sorry.

I really enjoyed today's readings especially the introduction of Interpretation with the story about Gilgamesh and Enkidu. My favorite part is describing how this story relates to Ecclesiastes, "the dread of death, the futility of human existence, the bond of fellowship, the import of joy and contentment, the inscrutable will of the divine and the bankruptcy of heroism." This saying sums up the way I felt that Ecclesiastes chapter 1:1-11 is tying to be described by the author. There is joy where there is pain, there is happiness where there is meaninglessness and there is nothing where there is something.

"Dust in the Wind" to me, related the most Ecclesiastes in the sense that the world we live in is "dust", everything is materialistic and we haven't found meaning, or wisdom. Materialistic things could be related to dust and how as soon as life ends or at any given second, something could (blow) or take it away. May that be death or disaster, we will never know until it happens, and at any given second it could. It's scary to think that the life we live now is meaningless, but in all truth, if we believe in a higher power, it is. I would like to believe that there is something else out there, but i fight with my earthly ideals daily. You don't realize how materialistic the world is until you sit and think, or analyze scriptures such as Ecclesiastes and listen to songs such as "Dust in the Wind". "Thrills", spoke to a younger crowd but brought the same message of materialistic-ness and could be interpreted depressing and hopeless and depressing but could to other listeners could be portrayed as almost hopeful and meaningful, which describes Ecclesiastes in a nut shell.
The central point of Ecclesiastes 1:1-11 is that man’s life is futile because it is short lived or fleeting. The same things happen again and again, mans’ life just going through the motions (life, death, and so on). He parallels this to things on earth, such as wind constantly blowing and streams rushing to the ocean (but never filling it).

It also says that everything has already existed, there is no longer anything original. Qohelet may be expressing dissatisfaction with the limitations we have as human beings, maybe even feelings of insignificance. Verse eight says “The eye is not satisfied by seeing or the ear filled with hearing.” We are unable to explain the world on our own, our knowledge and wisdom is limited. Since Qohelet thought “the individual can and should proceed towards truth by means of his own powers of perception and reasoning”, having limited time and ability to acquire truth by our own means would be very frustrating.

In Proverbs 8:22-31, the speaker (Solomon) uses a happy tone and enjoys rejoicing before God every day. While Qohelet maintains that respectfulness of God, his voice contradicts that of the first speaker’s: “He set a limit for the sea so that the waters would not violate His command” versus “All the streams flow to the sea…All things are wearisome” (1:8). Proverbs maintains a voice of the author simply being grateful for all of God’s creation, while Ecclesiastes speaks in a philosophical manner.
First of all, I really enjoyed both “Thrills” by Cake and “Dust in the wind” by Kansas. I found it interesting that lyrics from both of the songs could be pulled right out of Ecclesiastes. I thought it was significant that “Thrills” sounded like a message straight from a southern evangelical preacher. “Thrills” is pretty deliberately conveying the message that today’s youth is seeking satisfaction in material things but from the singer’s point of view, they are not finding it. In Ecclesiastes 1:8, the idea is the same, “All things are wearisome; more than one can express; the eye is not satisfied with seeing, or the ear filled with hearing”. This line is stating that we as humans cannot be satisfied on our own, or with worldly affairs. In “Dust in the Wind” the meaning is different from “Thrills” but still very alike that of Ecclesiastes. I feel as though this song could be interpreted as both very depressing and hopeless or an almost uplifting and contemplative song, which can also be said about Ecclesiastes. Seeing our lives as “dust in the wind” could mean total meaningless, or precious and fleeting. If the message is that of everything being only momentary it shows us how we should appreciate the time we are given. I think this message can be interpreted from Ecclesiastes if you can make it past the initial bleakness of the first few verses. Brown discusses the use of constant movement in the imagery of Ecclesiastes, in both the water and the wind, and the way human lives move. We are constantly in this circle of work and folly, but we never reach a worthwhile purpose. Brown uses the term “mirage” to describe the progress that comes of our work on this earth. I feel as though this is a very accurate description, and agrees well with how it is approached in Ecclesiastes.

Dust

The lyrics to “Dust in the Wind” are similar to the images of the world found in Ecclesiastes 1:1-11 and Proverbs 8:22-31.  The passage from Proverbs contrasts the opening to Ecclesiastes.  Ecclesiastes focuses on the cosmos’ eternal, meaningless motion and puts little emphasis on individual people while Proverbs puts its emphasis on the individual’s place in God’s creation.  The “Solomon” in Proverbs believes that he was created before God created the world.  I interpret this as meaning the spirits of humans were with God before God had even created physical bodies for them.  It all seems very happy and lovely, but if you look at the last two verses (8:30-31) maybe not so much.  The speaker was happy because he was in God’s presence (sort of like heaven?), but considering that he is now physically alive he is no longer that close to God.  He might be in the Ecclesiastes version of meaningless existence; somewhere between primordial spirit and the oblivion of death or just maybe an afterlife.  The two passages are like flip sides of the same coin in that life can feel very good sometimes and at others can feel pointless.  “Dust in the Wind” leans towards Ecclesiastes in its message, but it gives more thought on how we should live.  The songs admits that every thought or action is “just a drop of water in an endless sea” and that everything becomes dust in the wind.  In Ecclesiastes 1:7 the sea is described as never being full.  The water travels between sea and stream forever and for no obvious purpose.  The world is a cycle that progresses to anything new.  Man toils to create but all is forgotten or as the song says, “nothing lasts forever but the earth and sky”.  The final verse in “Dust in the Wind” says that we should not try to hold onto things and nothing can increase our time on Earth.  We should enjoy every moment that we have.

Ecclesiastes 1: 1-11

The author opens the book of Ecclesiastes by identifying himself as the “Teacher, the son of David, king in Jerusalem” and saying that “ All is vanity.” The phrase “ All is vanity” is the prominent thought of the author throughout the book of Ecclesiastes. In verse 3, Qohelet begins his search for meaning in life by asking what man gains from working. Qohelet is searching for purpose and meaning in the life of man.

After his question in verse 3, Qohelet begins to discuss his understanding of the cosmos. Qohelet says that the world is constantly repeating the same cycles over and over again, however, there is no real reason for its’ repetitions. Just as the earth and its’ cycles are repetitive and serve no purpose, so do the actions of human beings. He believes that “ everything (and all words) are wearisome. “ There can be no relief from the lack of purpose in life. Essentially, Qohelet finds the world to be a hopeless place and life to be a form of meaningless existence. He sees no loving God that was involved in creation and he does not seem to believe in the existence of a God that is present in the world today.

The author of Proverbs 8: 22-31, has a very different take on the state of the physical world. The scripture is written from the perspective of wisdom, and speaks of the creation of the world by a loving God. The author does not see the act of creation as an accident. The author sees creation as a very intricate process that was brought about for the enjoyment of all. Wisdom seems to “rejoice in his inhabited world and delight in the human race.” This author finds joy and purpose in God’s creation, whereas Qohelet seems to see the world and humans as entities without hope or a reason to exist.

Thursday, August 26, 2010

I said I would be wise, but it was far from me.

Ecclesiastes gives a clue to its methodology in chapter 7, vs 2 through 4. 2It is better to go to the house of mourningthan to go to the house of feasting;for this is the end of everyone,and the living will lay it to heart. 3Sorrow is better than laughter,for by sadness of countenance the heart is made glad. 4The heart of the wise is in the house of mourning;but the heart of fools is in the house of mirth. This conviction that, as F. H. Bradley has put it, where things are bad it can only be good to know the worst, places Ecclesiastes in a radically different position from its biblical predecessors. In its survey of 'the bad life' it seeks, I believe, to make men wise and, ironicly given its perceived pessimism, to spare them the hardships conferred to those who do not possess this wisdom. There is so much of value, I would go so far as to say of truth, in this book that I hardly know where to begin or if, once begun, I could end. A favorite truth it preaches/teachesQohelithizes is that man's status differs not-at-all from his animal counterparts. This is explicitly given us in ch 3 vs 18 through 21 and stated implicitly elsewhere through simile and metaphor. For instance, in ch 9, vs 12.
For no one can anticipate the time of disaster. Like fish taken in a cruel net, and like birds caught in a snare, so mortals are snared at a time of calamity, when it suddenly falls upon them.
Take that, creationists, you and your dominion theology just got Solomonically served! Muhahaha! ...
This was the first time I have ever actually read the book of Ecclesiastes, and I must say it honestly fits in with many of my own personal beliefs about morality in Christianity. What I mean by this is that, from the opening verse to the end of the book, Solomon denounces what could be paraphrased as "meaningless worldly pleasures." This idea seems to suggest an approach to the philosophy of life that is similar to a Tibetan Buddhist monk's lifestyle. The phrase "chasing after the wind" appears no less than fifteen times in the first 6 chapters of Ecclesiastes. I believe that this almost poetic repetition of this idea is meant to drive home the concept that regardless of your successes in your life on a shallow human level are as fleeting as human life itself. Bill Gates and Steve Jobs will not get to take a penny of their tremendous wealth to the afterlife with them. Lance Armstrong's numerous Tour de France titles are still going to be behind glass in a display case somewhere a thousand years from now. Solomon is really trying to reinforce these ideas that endless work and toil to achieve worldly success in human honors and accolades along with monetary wealth will be long forgotten in the near future after we die, so be sure to put your values in things that are truly valuable. Solomon suggests that wisdom is the most valuable thing that a human can possess in this life, but he also ironically says that the wisdom he speaks of is the knoweledge that everything in this earthly life is pointless and shouldn't be esteemed as the most important thing that our souls will ever experience. Heaven is truly valuable; the worship and fear of God is truly valuable; understanding that your successes or failures in this life are a mear blip on the radar of the endless spectrum of time, and therefore ultimately meaningless, is truly valuable.

Lost in the Woods

I have not read Ecclesiastes in many years, and was surprised to find its content very different from what I remembered. What was most striking to me was Koheleth’s apparent embrace of the material world as demonstrated by his insight that he “saw there was nothing better for man than to enjoy his possessions, since that is his portion (3.22),” and assurance that God favors this type of behavior. I was surprised that he endorsed enjoying wealth rather than sharing or redistributing it. This argument to enjoy the material world must be central to Koheleth’s belief system since he revisits it so often throughout the text. Even though Koheleth embarked on his own journey for wisdom he seems to argue that simply enjoying life while cultivating a respect for God is better than rigorously pursuing wisdom. Koheleth’s relationship to wisdom was perplexing. I was surprised that he noted that wisdom should be pursued in moderation (7.16), but then in other areas of the text, placed a high value on it, even saying that wisdom can bring about wealth (7.11).

Maybe Koheleth wrote this book so that others would not get too wrapped up in an “excess” of wisdom and instead, gain from his journey so that they could immediately begin trying to live in the moment as Koheleth prescribes rather than wasting precious time on their own search for wisdom. If youth is so fleeting, Koheleth must believe that it shouldn’t be wasted in a tormented pursuit for meaning. Koheleth often drives home the point that life is fleeting in his beautiful but also somewhat dissatisfying meditation on mortality. Koheleth doesn’t claim to have all the answers to life, leaving important questions, such as whether a man’s lifebreath endures, unanswered (3.21). While reading Ecclesiastes, I found myself constantly wanting more, and wishing that Koheleth would reach some grand insight that made life seem orderly and fulfilling. His indirect writing style which travels around in circles, revisiting old ideas and subtly shifting them made me feel like I was trying to find my way out of the woods, but instead only retracing my steps.

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

So this is different...

Although I am the son of a preacher man, I cannot not even pretend to be extremely well versed in the bible. The book of Ecclesiastes shares several similarities with an Alanis Morisette album. It starts with the blatant declaration of the futility of everything. With such a broad and inclusive statement, I was expecting more than mere speculation for the lack of impact we, as humans, will make. With further reading, I was intrigued with the gloom and foreboding nature of the book. It was like someone took away this guy’s antidepressants and made him watch the Diary of Anne Frank. Ecclesiastes raises several questions, which I was told never to have as a good Christian boy. Why seek out knowledge, why seek pleasure, why work? With these questions now raised, there now exists the need to answer them, which I am having a few issues doing.

One of the main issues that I had with the book, upon first glance, was the conflict between the idea of loving God and fearing God. It leads to the question, ‘which is more powerful, fear or love.’ Unlike much of the rest of the New Testament, Ecclesiastes lends itself to the side of fear. In my experience, church and organized Christian worship have always taught that Jesus died for our sins so that there is hope for an eternal life in Heaven. In all honesty, I have always thought of New Testament God to be more forgiving and loving than Old Testament God. The book of Ecclesiastes seems to not only question this idea, but contradict it as well by insisting on life’s lack of purpose and fulfillment without God.

Upon further examination, however, it would appear that the point that is being made is that mankind can have no fulfillment without God’s love. If you approach it from that angle, the book of Ecclesiastes is much less contradictory to the rest of the New Testament. I am however still struck by the Old Testament manner in which the message is delivered, a sort of ‘love or be forsaken NOW’ manner.

An Endorsement for Gloomy Days

This was my first time to read Ecclesiastes and so I was surprised by how personable the writing was. I had expected it to be more similar to Proverbs, though it did have it's specific pieces of advice, and so sound more distant and less sympathetic to the direct experience pain felt by humanity. Rather than being objective, it sounded more like a personal journal written by a person who could honestly admit to and face the pain of everyday life. An issue I have with reading other sections of the Bible is that, while they provide optimism and encouragement for endurance, they do not fully sympathize with or explore the initial bad feelings. Christians are definitely not exempt from feeling the emptiness of life that can, at times, be overwhelming, nor should they. Ecclesiastes admits to that feeling, even while loving and fearing an almighty God. Not that the God described provided a constantly reliable source of comfort to the author. The author of Ecclesiastes readily spoke of the uncertainty of God's plan and his main piece of advice seemed to be to go with the flow. We are incapable of predicting the exact future, so the best thing we can do is accept what happens and find an appreciation for the experience at hand, whether it is what we had hoped for or not, remembering that life is full of cycles.
My favorite verse was 7:14, “In the day of prosperity be joyful, and in the day of adversity consider; God has made one as well as the other, so that mortals may not find out anything that will come after them.” The verse is neither too optimistic to take seriously or empathize with on a day of adversity, nor is it discouraging. It provides a realistic way to make the best of both situations and to appreciate them for what they are. Fighting adversity typically only encourages more discouragement, and so by freely feeling what is within, without feeling as if one is doing something sinful or against God's will, can one be healed with the endorsement that it is good and natural for unhappiness to come on some days. The book of Ecclesiastes unabashedly admits how awful life can be for anyone, but rather than quickly steering the sufferer away from the unknown, it stands by and patiently waits by his side.

Ambiguity of Ambiguities

Every time I read from Ecclesiastes I ask myself the same types of questions…If he is so convinced that after we die that’s it, why does he even believe in God? Is that any better than chasing the wind? If he believes what he is saying, how is he not utterly apathetic, or at least sarcastic towards everything? I can hear him now… How about instead of ‘life’ we just call it ‘meaningful meaninglessness’.

Nonetheless, I believe this book is of great value to the human race. I think that what the Teacher does well is to hone in on the ambiguousness of things, which is why it’s clear to me that he is not just some depressed, self-contradicting, know-it-all. I think for today’s audience, it might have helped if he had started out by saying “ambiguity of ambiguities, all is ambiguous!” To me is his main point is not that life’s light is sadly brief and dim, but that it must be carefully carried through the vast darkness, never knowing where the either light or dark begins or ends.

Indeed, every time I read Ecclesiastes I hear a man who is confidently dwelling within the ambiguous space between righteousness and sin, between predetermination and free will, between enthusiastic embrace and gloomy acceptance. Despite this seemingly overwhelming gray-area that we all exist in, I don’t think the Teacher was most concerned with making other people aware of their own vanity. I’d like to think that the Teacher would agree with my interpretation, that the universal value and beauty of this text is not its brutally honest realism as much as how it subtly suggests humans ought to respond to ambiguity. By going through a myriad of life’s dimensions, and labeling them one by one as utter vanity, what’s being suggested is not that everything is a waste of time, but that God or no God, ambiguity in human experience is a constant. Humans simply cannot escape ambiguity as long as they are breathing. The skeptic might say ok, but, if ambiguity is a constant then why suggest that something as rigid as the Ten Commandments should be upheld? Well, for the Teacher to remain a truly ‘wise’ figure in my mind, what he must have wanted to convey was that dealing with life requires a high degree of self-composure. The message I hear is that what we do in life places no limit on how we experience life. The teacher is suggesting that what people need more than satisfaction or pleasure, are things like temperance and humility. The reasoning goes something like this: By focusing on ‘what’ instead of ‘how’ , fulfilled desires convince people that they have discovered an unambiguous space that they can stay in forever, even though ambiguity is in fact a constant that cannot in this life be escaped.

Not Pie in the Sky

“The making of many books is without limit, and much study is wearying of the flesh.” (Ecclesiastes 12:12)

Once I too was very weary of all philosophical or religious writing. So much of that genre feels irrelevant, unproductive. Then I read Ecclesiastes, and found it more immediately practical than a cookbook or manual. Wow!

It reads like a (meandering) account of a (relatively) scientific investigation into a problem, the problem of being a living human being, regularly confronted by "vexation of the spirit." The central question: "What's the point?" (1:3)

Ecclesiastes yields some practical advice on this. Here is what I think it is right now:
  • The trajectory of the world over time is immutable, having been fixed beforehand by its Creator (3:1-8). It is also too complicated to be understood by the humans within it.
  • Thus humans can never reliably control, understand, or predict their world.
  • Sadly, it is their nature is to attempt just that! (3:10-11)
  • As a result, human pleasure and happiness (like life itself) is fleeting.
  • These are universal truths. They can be shown by reproducible experiment (2:1-16).
  • Paradoxically, these statements do represent some weird indirect understanding by humans of their world**, and by living according to this wisdom rather than vainly struggling against it, they can minimize their suffering.
  • But there's a catch: since being lucky enough to uncover and successfully apply this wisdom is itself a worldly activity, subject to the same preordained, unpredictable will of the Creator as all other goals (2:24-26, 7:6-7). So good luck, schmuck.***

I think as a practical work it successful. I have now often read it in times of trouble. I still don't fully get it though. I keep finding new things to puzzle over in it, like a good painting.

(**: The way Koheleth puts it bothers me. It sounds to me like he is assuming that the way this wisdom is distributed to people is that the person who "pleases" the Creator gets the wisdom and the one who "displeases" Him gets punished with the "urge to gather and amass." This sounds suspiciously circular.)

(***: It's hard for me to read Ecclesiastes for long without running again and again into circular/self-referential "paradoxes" like that one! It must not just be me, though; I think I saw a remark to that effect in the introduction to one of our textbooks-- but of course I would have, since "there is nothing new under the sun"... see how easy it is to fall down that rabbit hole?)

(By the way, what does everyone think of 12:9-13? I think it feels tacked on, trivializing the rest of the work, and patronizing the audience. (though the actual message seems consistent with the rest) It seems almost like a disclaimer from worried authorities saying "Hey, in case that was too confusing, he was just saying you should follow the rules. Oh that crazy Koheleth, always saying his sayings!" I don't like it. And it spoils the symmetry!)


You Have to Love What You Do

I have never read Ecclesiastes before today. In all honesty, this is probably the only time that I’ve ever read any of Bible, so I wasn’t really sure what to expect when reading Ecclesiastes. The first thing that struck me when reading was the darkness of the scriptures. By darkness, I am not referring to violence, fire, brimstone, or any other general doom and gloom, but the realities of life. Koheleth frequently reiterates the futility of most human endeavors and forces the reader to acknowledge the stark truth of human mortality. Even his solutions seemed to be peppered with a certain cynicism that I found very surprising. Though they were often dark, the passages were also evocative and beautiful. Koheleth’s wish to find meaning seems to come from a place of genuine spiritual interest, instead of just the whiny, apathetic aimlessness that can often be associated with those in pursuit of meaning. To me, Koheleth’s conclusions were most surprising in their focus on Earthly enjoyment. Instead of treating life on Earth as simply a required path to get to the afterlife, Koheleth instead concludes that a life is best lived when one is in God’s favor and spends time enjoying life instead of pursuing wealth and wisdom, both of which Koheleth regards as follies. Although I am not a religious individual, I found Koheleth’s search for meaning in a frequently harsh world to be incredibly moving. The book also seems to lack a singular focus, though, often contradicting conclusions that had been reached only pages before. Considering my complete and utter lack of biblical knowledge, I was also interested to find how much of Ecclesiastes I already knew, most notably the “for everything there is a season” poem and the phrase “there is nothing new under the sun”. Overall, I found the book of Ecclesiastes to be a highly satisfying piece of religious philosophical pursuit.
It's amazing how you don't hear this kind of scripture in church. It would make sitting throughout the hour long sermon a lot more interesting. I know the stories in the bible and some of the characters throughout the bible but I'm not familiar with Ecclesiastes. From the beginning there was a kind of dark demeanor about the story the teacher was telling. I believe the teacher was disappointed not in his findings of true knowledge and of God but of how men have handled finding "everything under the sun". Almost as if he was calling the greedy and they were looking for something more than what was already there, yet at the same time i think he was more complaining of himself in an almost third person point of view. It's quiet depressing the way he describes life as meaningless and how man is wicked and about the fate that awaits them. I feel like he's judging other people's mistakes or the fact that maybe others are taking life for granted but at the same time I don't feel he is doing anything different that those who he is complaining about. The teacher was very bitter but loosened up at the end of the story. It made me feel like maybe he found God again or had strengthened his relationship with him. Maybe through his complaints he was trying to keep man humble and ask that they not take life and God for granted and just repeatedly go through the motions. I found it to be a most interesting read and I definitely look forward to reading more.

No Happily Ever After

The Hebrew word hevel seems to be the theme of Qoheleth. As with many, if not all of Hebrew words, hevel can be translated into many meanings such as “meaninglessness,” “uselessness,” or literally translated to mean, “vapor,” or “breeze.” Vanity is the translation most commonly used.
Solomon did many great things in his life, he searched for true wisdom, he created marvelous things, and even sought out the things that he desired but in the end found that all of these things were hevel, vanity.
Man, as far as I can tell, has always searched for a fairytale ending. In almost every movie, book, story, epic, or legend, there is a beginning, middle, and end. The end is usually paired with complete resolution; the bad guy is dead and the hero lives happily ever after. Perhaps Qoheleth is declaring that this is not reality. There is no happily ever after in this life because there will always be injustice, pain, and sorrow as long as man has reign over this world.
This idea may be severely depressing to some, and rightly so. Yet, Qoheleth provides a comfort in this way. There is no way to know for sure that an afterlife exists so, according to this book, people should eat, drink, and be merry! There is no resolution in the story of our lives so we should enjoy the middle. God gave us this life and therefore we should enjoy it.
Qoheleth shows that it is normal for us to seek things that please us. People do what is within their hearts, no more, no less.
However, the writer’s lack of structure and apparent rambling makes it difficult to ascertain if this is the meaning of this book. I am very interested to delve into the history of this writing to determine if there is some outside knowledge that may ease interpretation. This book seems so very different than most other books with its lack of God being active or interacting with the story.

This is the first time I have read through Ecclesiastes and really thought about the words of the “Qoheleth” or the teacher. The first few chapters set a dark and depressing tone. The words are blunt to the point that I did not want to read much further into it, however, in its entirety we see that the message Solomon is sending is not so unpromising. When the teacher’s words change from “All is vanity” to telling us “It is fitting to eat and drink and find enjoyment in all the toil”, we see the idea Solomon is really proposing.

In chapter 9, verses 7-10, we see the big picture of Ecclesiastes. “Go, eat your bread with enjoyment and drink your wine with a merry heart; for God has long ago approved what you do.” This quote shows that the teacher does not actually think everything we enjoy in life is vanity, if we are living not under the sun, but for God, we should enjoy the things he has provided us. In 4:7-8 it states, “‘for whom am I toiling,’ they ask, ‘and depriving myself of pleasure?’ This also is vanity and an unhappy business.” These verses are reinforcing the idea that being grateful to God and enjoying the life he has laid out for us is how we should be living.

I find it interesting that The Teacher uses such poignant description of life. I’m not sure it’s necessary to use this technique in order to get his point across, but I do think it grabs the reader’s attention. I can also see why this book of The Bible has the reputation of being so pessimistic, but with a critical examination I think it is easy to interpret the meaning as an optimistic one. Life can and should be enjoyed, not all is vanity, if you’re living for God.

Confusion and an Over Used Passage

When I hear someone talk about the book of Ecclesiastes, my mind automatically goes to the passage in chapter 3 where Solomon is stating that there is a time for everything. I feel like this specific passage is commonly recognized in the secular culture. It is a passage that is overused by pastors and others in the Christian community, in my opinion. Before I read this book today, this was the only passage that I could remember from the book, causing my thoughts about the book to be very biased. Is it this passage to cliched? Or maybe I am looking for another word... possibly just well known?

When reading Ecclesiastes today, I could think of one word to describe it: Confusing. It seems that the author, Solomon, is speaking throughout his life, beginning with a very depressing outlook on life and later moving on to reminiscing about is past, telling the reader to "remember your creator in the days of your youth, before the days of trouble come." It seems as if he doesn't exactly know what exact point he wants to make. Is life just meaningless or should we appreciate what we have and have been through?

I have read this book a few times in the past and now that I have gone back and read it again, I find myself more confused each time I read it. All I know for sure is that there is a time for everything. Maybe I will understand this confusing book better in the months to come?

I read Ecclesiastes for the 5th time yesterday and found myself to be just as confused as before. In the first several chapters of the work, we find the speaker, who is referred to as the “Teacher,” has become very frustrated with his life. He writes that much of his earthly work has given him virtually no benefits. He seems to believe that he has acquired wisdom, although he neglects to go into the benefits of this wisdom.

In the third chapter of Ecclesiastes, the Teacher goes on to discuss how there is time for everything under heaven. He believes that God is in control, and that whatever God has planned will be accomplished. In the next several chapters, he shares his belief that life is meaningless, and that whether an individual is wicked or righteous, the same fate awaits them.

In the last portion of the book, the Teacher starts to see the beauty of life, and tells the reader to enjoy their blessings now, before there bodies start to age. The book ends with the Teacher telling the reader to “Fear God, and keep his commandments.” The Teacher, in his old age, has come to realize that the only thing that brings any joy to this life is obedience to the Father. Everything else is meaningless.

The book of Ecclesiastes is the journey of the Teacher from a young boy to an elderly man. While reading Ecclesiastes this time around, I became very interested in the beginning verses of chapter 3 where the Teacher composes a list of antithetical pairs that he hopes will help the reader understand that there is a time for both the joys and sorrows of life. I found it hard to believe that a God who says that he loves all of mankind would think that there should be “ a time to hate” and “ a time for war.” Is this merely the Teacher’s list of sorrows and joys, or as he discusses in verse 14, are these acts part of God’s plan for human kind? Are these acts of hate and war God's doing?

Ecclesiastes is my favorite book of the Bible, along with Song of Songs. I remember reading it for the first time and how dismal it was, and it just wasn’t your regular book of the Bible. Re-reading it now, I do not think it necessarily has to be interpreted that way (interpreted as authored by someone with a cynical point of view). I noticed in chapter one, verse two, the author states “everything is futile”. I think most interpret this as everything is meaningless, worthless, etc. This could also be seen as everything moves quickly or is “fleeting”, not leaving it time to gain meaning in our lives. It could also be a parallel to the traditional Christian view of our life on earth (temporary) versus our time spent in Heaven (eternal).

The most interesting thing in Ecclesiastes to me was how the author put an emphasis on pleasure. In chapter two, verses one through three, the author explains how he tries different means of pleasure but all the while he maintains his perspective. In verse 3:12, he states that “there is nothing better for them to rejoice and enjoy the good life.” In chapter two he explains that he never denied himself a pleasure because he felt that he deserved them as rewards for his struggles, but goes on to say that these rewards were also futile. It seems that the author felt that possessions and other means of self-gratification could not satisfy.

A recurring theme in Ecclesiastes seems to be a subtle, but very simple one: anything from God is really, really good. If one is skimming over the book, it can read as if the author can’t find good in the world or might be depressed. But every time the author comes to a point about something God has given him, he has something very positive to say (e.g., 3:13-14).

You're so vain, Solomon

This is my first time reading Ecclesiastes from an academic view and not from a "churchy sermon" view, and frankly I was overwhelmed. The Qohelet or Teacher was very verbose in his speech of life experiences. His uncertain, ambiguous, and beautifully poetic rambling made it difficult for mt to focus and determine what his specific teaching/argument was. His frequent changes in tone made it hard to determine his attitude towards life. It was a frustrating read because of his seemingly negative tone, about how "all in vanity". (1:2) However, after more thinking, I believe that the Teacher isn't being negative of pessimistic but realistic and truthful. These problems of "vanity" and "chasing after the wind" are problems that every human being, even Christians who won't admit it, face in life. Ecclesiastes is taken negatively not only because of its contrast to the Old Testament, which is straightforward and decisive, but also because the Teacher confronts a topic that everyone want to ignore: "the meaning of life". Is the meaning of life joy? Wealth? Wisdom? To answer this the Teacher goes through an unconventional rout of discovery that portrays the skepticism in humans. Int eh end, the Teacher decides that all is vain in the end, "all go to one place; all are from dust, and all turn to dust again". (3:20) The Teacher who is presumably King Solomon, describes his life as all toil and vain. Even though Solomon purposely set out to experience the "joys" of life in wealth, power, and sexual pleasure (2:4-8), he still ended up unhappy. He blames it on the toil of life. But is his unhappiness because of his actual and physical toil, or is it because of his reason of toiling? Toiling for yourself doesn't being happiness, you'll just die in the end and lose it. (2:18). Toiling for others doesn't work either, you'll just be forgotten by the next generation. (2:16) Solomon struggles with this vanity issue but conclusively agrees that if you work or toil for God and keep Him as your priority, you can and will enjoy life and its toils. Since the Teacher said that everything under the sun is vanity repeatedly, I believe that he is advising us to put our works and toils over the sun into heaven. Make God's heaven big and our earth small and everything else will be put into perspective. Like the Teacher said, make God the primary goal of life.
The book of Ecclesiastes seems to span the Teachers life. In the first few chapters, the Teacher is disillusioned with life, having found that his work on Earth has amounted to nothing. He speaks of having wisdom, but rather than imparting any of it, he instead complains about how he has not gained anything from the material aspects of his life. It is only in the middle chapters that the Teacher does anything more than mourn the supposed pointlessness of life and begins to pass on bits of wisdom to the reader. In the last few chapters, the Teacher seems to have gained more respect for the beauty of life and instructs the reader to enjoy God’s creation before old age sets in. In the course of the book, the Teacher expresses the disillusionment of a young man who expected more from this life, the grim acceptance of the evil of the world as seen by a mature man, and the wistful appreciation for a life lost, yearningly expressed by an elderly man.
While reading Ecclesiastes, one thing that stuck out to me was that, for all the Teacher’s accounts of the worthlessness of his acts and gains, he only once mentions helping others. The Teacher even says that it’s useless to worry over the poor and injustice. Certainly a life filled with material possessions and acts of personal gain would give the Teacher a meaningless existence but perhaps if he had used his wisdom and money to serve others rather than himself, he would have found more purpose in his life. The Teacher repeatedly instructs the reader to just try to have as much fun as he or she can in life since it’s all rather pointless; however, this advice seems likely to lead to an equally pointless existence. Again, if the Teacher had lived his life for others rather than himself alone, I believe he would have found life to be much more meaningful

Additionally, I found the Teacher’s bitterness at his lack of understanding of God’s plans to be quite arrogant. As the Teacher expressed several times, he is very wise, but what man can be so wise as to truly understand God?

Despite these disagreements with the Teacher, I found chapters 7-12 more insightful. In these chapters, the Teacher seems more content to accept that he has no control over the good or the evil in the world and gives useful advice for enjoying what you can from life.

I read Ecclesiastes (for what I believe was the first time) over 12 hours ago and I still do not know what to think about it.  At first glance I was struck by the haunting beauty of its passages and the way in which nearly any human, religious or not, could relate to the feeling that life sometimes seems pointless. The passage from chapter 1:1-11 shows how insignificant the life of any one person is compared to the Earth.  A reader from today knows how small we are compared to the entire universe.  Today, we also know that even the Earth and everything that inhabits it is not permanent.  The teacher then tells how he has accumulated wisdom and wealth and tried to enjoy life.  Yet these did not make him have a more meaningful existence.  In fact he said that “for with much wisdom comes much sorrow” (1:18).  The teacher goes on to say that pleasure, folly, and work are all meaningless.  The reasons why these things are meaningless are unclear to me.  Is it because everything is going to die and return to dust?  Is it meaningless in the presence of God?  However the very last verse says that “God will bring every deed into judgment, including every hidden thing, whether it is good or evil” (12:14).  Ecclesiastes does not say what this judgment means.  The closest reference I saw to an afterlife was in verse 12:7 which said that the spirit returns to God.  It did not say whether something good or bad would happen to the spirit depending on the actions of a person’s life.  One of questions that Ecclesiastes asks is what is the purpose of life. Is life something that we just have to suffer through or is it something to be enjoyed?  Does life serve as a way for God to judge us? 

I will admit I have never read the book of Ecclesiastes before today and I also have never remember it being referenced at my church or by my pastor or any other of my religious teachers. I found the book of Ecclesiastes to be very confusing and Solomon seems to be rambling and talking in circles about difficult subjects that really have no connections. The book is very dark at parts, but at the same time it brings up a lot of topics that people are not comfortable talking about.

Vanity is a huge theme throughout this book; the word alone is used five times in the second verse and then repeated again at the end. The “Qoheleth” or teacher acts as if people have lost their sense of direction and are no longer living for God, but are living for the other vanities in life such as food, wine, and land. I also found it interesting that another example of vanity was the idea of someone working so hard at a job that they hated to provide for the next generation, who will not remember them after they have left the earth. The author evens writes “There is nothing better for mortals than to eat and drink, and find enjoyment in their toil” (2:24). Or in others words, life is short so enjoy it while you can. Sometimes people get so caught up in pleasing others that they forget that God is the only one they need to please. People work so hard at a task in order to get more money or to gain friendships or political power, but in reality what are they really gaining. This book discusses that toiling away at tasks that aren’t enjoyable and aren’t for your benefit are really not worth doing. It’s bluntly saying that the next generation isn’t going to remember the current generation and while you are here on earth it’s not important to please your boss or your friends, but it is important to please God. Life can be over in a second, but God is never ending and so our focus should be on him and not the endless vanities we can experience on earth.

Close Encounters of the Third Kind (with Ecclesiastes)

As some who have posted before me, I'm going to start this post by being honest. I had never sat down and read all the way through Ecclesiastes before today. I did find some of the book quite surprising, and could see why the religious types might not want it spread around too much. I wasn't too happy with the author when s/he (does anyone know if the author's gender is specified?) wrote not to be concerned with justice for or the oppression of others in 5:8. And the blatant sexism in 7:26-28? Not my favorite. I had to read a lot of it more than once to get past the initially obvious points about the meaninglessness of all we do or have and the futility of a single human life.


The first connection I drew from this piece was to the Hindu Upanishads. They carry some common themes on the uselessness of seeking after worldly pleasures and wealth. The Upanishads offer the solution of renunciation; rejecting all worldly possessions and relationships and becoming a beggar, spending all of your time seeking after the truth, the absolute. Ecclesiastes does not reach the same solution. The author seems to come to the conclusion that though wisdom and wealth are ultimately worthless, we should still enjoy them, and they are gifts from G-d (see 2:24, along with several other verses that state the same thing). To me, it seems that a more Upanishadic approach to finding meaning is offered in the NT, with verses like Luke 12:27 and Matthew 19:23-24.


The author's own solution doesn't seem satisfactory to me. S/he seems conflicted to me. It's almost as though the author can't find a better solution to the meaninglessness s/he sees in life than to keep going with it and to enjoy it as much as possible. The solution offered is to ignore the problem. The book rather abruptly changes tones back and forth between "He [G-d] has made everything beautiful in its time" to "man's fate is like that of the animals" in a few short verses (3:11 to 3:19).


Final thought: The bit on fools multiplying their words (10:14) sure seems funny coming from someone who was in the process of writing a semi-lengthy and often repetitive book.

Let's be blunt

To be frank, I have never read the book of Ecclesiastes. Never. I’d heard about it, how it was harsh, how it was real “Old Testament” in nature. I never really had any feelings about it, but that's mostly because I haven't read it.

However, as I began Ecclesiastes, I found myself a little taken aback by the words of the teacher. His message is immediately bleak: “Everything is meaningless," and as I continued reading through Ecclesiastes, I began to think the entire book would be gloomy and hopeless – if everything is meaningless, if wisdom and foolishness, pleasures and toils are all for nothing, what is the point? Why would you want to put any effort into living if it will never mean anything?

But then the teacher changes his tune. He realizes “that it is good and proper for a man to eat and drink, and to find satisfaction in his toilsome labor under the sun during the few days of life God has given him” (5:18). When I read this, I was confused. Was this really the same guy who had just said pleasure and work were meaningless? Now wisdom is better than foolishness, and though we’ll all end up dying at some point – that’s our common destiny – God has given the righteous wealth and it should be enjoyed.

I think the teacher is coming from a good place. He is warning those listening what happens to sinners, to those who are not righteous. He has the shock value in the first few chapters and it grabs your attention. I think this is what intrigues me most about Ecclesiastes. The teacher so believes in what he says, so much that he doesn’t skirt around the heavy issues of not obeying God. He is very blunt and doesn't sugarcoat the unfortunate consequences of disobeying God. I don’t think he is saying life is completely pointless, though I thought that’s where he was going at the beginning of the book. I think the point he wants to make is that the secular things of this world (riches, pleasures, wisdom) can be enjoyed, but God must be first. Be happy, enjoy life, follow your heart, but in the end, God will bring everything to the table.

Ecclesiastes: A Warning Against Selfishness

This is the first time that I have read Ecclesiastes, other than briefly “skimming over” the book. The Teacher seems very dispirited about the state of the world around him. Actually, he proclaims multiple times that “all is vanity” and “chasing after wind” and “there was nothing to be gained under the sun”. With these frequent remarks, the book quickly takes on a negative tone.

It is obvious that the Teacher has had ample time and opportunity to ponder the questions of life and death that interest him. I began to think about the kind of person that would have this type of luxury. Surly, it is one that has food to eat and his other basic needs met, otherwise he would be spending more time toward life-sustaining ends and less time with pursuing philosophical questions. The next aspect of the Teacher’s life that made an impact upon me was his borderline obsession with gain. From the very beginning of the book, the Teacher begins displaying all of his possessions. I find his manner almost conceited when he seems so pleased, at the end of chapter two, that he has “more than any who had been before me in Jerusalem”.

Despite the fact that the Teacher clearly has more than what he could possibly need, he is still very dissatisfied with his life. I could not help but notice his indifference towards those who are less fortunate and wonder if this might be the reason for his unhappiness. He advises people to not worry about “the oppression of the poor and the violation of justice and right” in chapter five. He attributes his lack of concern to his idea that God will avenge all injustices at the right time. I can see how this would pacify the privileged, but how is this to be of immediate comfort to those who are actually being tortured in the present?

I would have to agree with the Teacher that his life is indeed vain. However, I do not accept this vanity as an inevitable aspect of life. The reason that the Teacher finds no value is because he is only “toiling” for personal gain. It is only logical that life would be vain if each person only strived for the sole benefit of himself, after all everyone is going to perish in the end. The Teacher might feel more satisfied if he thought of someone other than himself.

To be honest, I have never really paid all that much attention to the book of Ecclesiastes. Oh, I thought I knew what it was about and of course I could quote some of the more well-known verses. "Vanity of vanities" and "For everything there is a season" were phrases quite familiar and, to be honest, a little trite with overuse. Frankly, though I thought the poetry was beautiful, I never really took the time to try and "get" Ecclesiastes. It just seemed too depressing. I guess I really just never gave it a chance.

My first reaction on really reading Ecclesiastes, to my surprise, was not one of angst or of a sense of futility. It wasn't as if the author was saying that nothing ever matters or that life was meaningless, it was more like "Look, you aren't going to be here forever so why don't you focus on what really counts."

Upon the author we can assume great wisdom and experience given that he recounts: "my wisdom remained with me. Whatever my eyes desired I did not keep from them; I kept my heart from no pleasure(2: 9-10) He, however, found that, despite all of his riches, his experience, and his wisdom that "all was vanity and a chasing after wind (2:11). This, at first, can seem really depressing. This man, the son of a king, lived a pretty sweet life, but even he was unhappy. Keep reading, though, and things start to get a little better. It becomes obvious, on further inspection, that these assertions of the meaningless of life and the vanity of wisdom are not meant to be seen alone, they are meant to contrast that in which he, in the wisdom of his years, has found meaning.

"For the one who pleases him God gives wisdom and knowledge and joy (2:26)," In this, he finds meaning. Nothing in this life lasts forever, all is ultimately meaningless but to please God. "I know that whatever God does endures forever; nothing can be added to it, nor anything taken from it; God has done this, so that all should stand in awe before him (3:14)." All of the worries and toils of daily life, of working in the fields, of fleshly pleasures, are ultimately nothing. Life is ephemeral, God is eternal. When the author asks "What do all the people gain from all the toil at which they toil under the sun?" he is not simply asking "What's the point to all this?" He is simply asking "Why spend time thinking of something that will soon be over? God is forever, why don't you focus on him?" Ecclesiastes, to me, is the story of a wise old man saying "Rejoice, young man, while you are young, and let your heart cheer you in the days of your youth (11:9)," and "Remember your creator in the days of your youth, before the days of trouble come, and the years draw near when you will say, 'I have no pleasure in them.' (12:1)."

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

Vanity: More Than Botox and Jimmy Choo

This being my first experience with Ecclesiastes, my mind darted back and forth in an attempt to figure out what the author was getting at. I don’t think I’ll be alone in saying that, at first glance, it seemed as though he felt life was void of any meaning. The introduction alone seemingly stems from depression and hopelessness. I mean the guy said that a stillborn child was better off than a man who lived a long life and produced many offspring! Upon reflection, however, I realized that I do not in fact believe that the writing of this book was motivated by a sardonic disposition but rather a desire to shake the readers out of their blind ignorance.
Solomon (if he really did write Ecclesiastes) seems to say “Alright guys, let’s get real” as he proceeds to point out that we aren’t as interesting as we think we are. God isn’t amused by our behavior even though we can’t get enough of it. I feel like he’s trying to make it clear that we can’t do, say, or make anything that will surprise God. I also think he makes a valid point when he says wisdom and power are vanity. In my opinion, he isn’t saying that having power and being wise are vain. Vanity is being aware of one’s wisdom and power. Similarly, he seems to say that it isn’t what we do that matters but why we’re doing it. Any work for the sake of work and recognition is “striving after wind.” When work is motivated by joy and righteousness it is productive.
I especially appreciated the author’s honesty in 7:21-22 which say “Do not take to heart all the things that people say, lest you hear your servant cursing you. Your heart knows that many times you have yourself cursed others.” It’s like he’s making one last attempt to obliterate any feeling of confidence and superiority that the reader might have left. In my opinion he’s really saying something about the way people criticize others and he’s making the point that we all wrong others and therefore have no reason to feel superior because God is aware of everyone’s wrongdoings and will judge all people accordingly.
On an initial reading of the book of Ecclesiastes the main theme that comes to mind is “Everything is Meaningless!” I read an NIV version of the book and every 2 or 3 verses those words appeared. The entire book seemed based on the fact that everything we do and strive for is meaningless. I can only conclude that if one is to live a Christian life that one must abandon all worldly things because they are so meaningless. However, then we come across Chapter 8 verse 15.

“So I commend the enjoyment of life, because nothing is better for a man under the sun than to eat and drink and be glad. Then joy will accompany him in his work all the days of the life God has given him under the sun.”

This is a complete turnaround from the rest of the book. Up to this point the entire book is about how life is meaningless and then all of a sudden the author commends those who enjoy life to the fullest. I agree with the idea of living life to the fullest and think everyone should do the same, but the verse took me by surprise. I did not expect to be told to go out and live when the author had been telling me that everything was meaningless for the last 7 chapters. I expected more of life being meaningless and more quotes telling me the proper way to live my life. I believe the point of this little quote is that life is not in fact meaningless but the things that you enjoy are meaningless. One should not live their life for riches or prosperity but should live their life to be happy. To have joy in God should be the primary mission of one’s life.

Tuesday, August 17, 2010

The Permeable Wall

A word on method.

One could, of course, teach a course on Job and Ecclesiastes without recourse to a blog. What, then, do I hope to gain by creating this community of interpretation here in the blogosphere? A fair question, to be sure.

(1) Blogging creates a space in which we can form and test our thoughts more carefully than in the classroom alone. Here, I can think; watch my cursor blink; word and reword my sentence; make my point the way it wants to be made.

(2) Blogging allows us to shape and refine one another's ideas. By your thoughtful comments to my blog post, you can help me think more carefully about issues I may have rushed past, or push my ideas further than I have been able to push them myself. You can make me a better thinker.

(3) Blogging creates a "permeable wall" in the classroom. It expands our awareness beyond our small group of readers to include those from beyond, who want to read with us from afar. It makes all of our learning "engaged learning," as we interact virtually with the world outside of class.

(4) Blogging makes us teachers as well as learners. Our writing seeks to inform, illuminate, create. If we write and respond thoughtfully, we can begin to learn together before we ever step into the classroom.

Please invite those you know to peer in on our writing from time to time, to comment on our interpretations, to become part of our extended learning community. Let's move our class beyond the permeable wall.