On an initial reading of the book of Ecclesiastes the main theme that comes to mind is “Everything is Meaningless!” I read an NIV version of the book and every 2 or 3 verses those words appeared. The entire book seemed based on the fact that everything we do and strive for is meaningless. I can only conclude that if one is to live a Christian life that one must abandon all worldly things because they are so meaningless. However, then we come across Chapter 8 verse 15.
“So I commend the enjoyment of life, because nothing is better for a man under the sun than to eat and drink and be glad. Then joy will accompany him in his work all the days of the life God has given him under the sun.”
This is a complete turnaround from the rest of the book. Up to this point the entire book is about how life is meaningless and then all of a sudden the author commends those who enjoy life to the fullest. I agree with the idea of living life to the fullest and think everyone should do the same, but the verse took me by surprise. I did not expect to be told to go out and live when the author had been telling me that everything was meaningless for the last 7 chapters. I expected more of life being meaningless and more quotes telling me the proper way to live my life. I believe the point of this little quote is that life is not in fact meaningless but the things that you enjoy are meaningless. One should not live their life for riches or prosperity but should live their life to be happy. To have joy in God should be the primary mission of one’s life.
Maybe it's just achievable goals that are meaningless, but present satisfaction is not a problem-- it's the working today for some (uncertain, vain, imagined) reward tomorrow that is problematic?
ReplyDeleteI agree with your statement that "one should not live their life for riches or prosperity," however, I don't know if that means that one should live their life to be happy. I venture to suggest the primary mission of one's life should be to serve others(this is mentioned in the book only once, and I don't think that the author necessarily agrees with my statement). I don't think that as individuals we should neglect finding joy in Christ, I just don't believe that it should be the primary goal of our life. I guess you could even say that we can find joy in God through acts of service to others.
ReplyDeleteI like what you said about the importance of living life in order to be happy. What interest me is what is happiness? I think that the Teacher offers a good example of how chasing after knowledge and wealth for PERSONAL gain results in unhappiness. I like what Kate said about living life in service to others, which I think results in true happiness. Therefore, if you accept my definition of happiness, you and Kate are both saying the same things.
ReplyDeleteI don't know about black and white definitions, but I'll admit I pretty much agree, Lacey, so maybe Kate and I are saying the same things after all.
ReplyDeleteWith that said:
The only kind of "service to others" I take issue with is the kind that is not for its own sake but in furtherance of another goal, such as "I do it because that's what God said." That doesn't seem a lot different than doing volunteer work to pad one's resume.
If it turned out (somehow, magically) tomorrow that it is certain that there is a personal God who hates people who help others, I wouldn't change my behavior. The idea of doing "good works" as a *result* of wishing to follow religious commandments (rather than for its own sake) has always deeply troubled me.