I have not read Ecclesiastes in many years, and was surprised to find its content very different from what I remembered. What was most striking to me was Koheleth’s apparent embrace of the material world as demonstrated by his insight that he “saw there was nothing better for man than to enjoy his possessions, since that is his portion (3.22),” and assurance that God favors this type of behavior. I was surprised that he endorsed enjoying wealth rather than sharing or redistributing it. This argument to enjoy the material world must be central to Koheleth’s belief system since he revisits it so often throughout the text. Even though Koheleth embarked on his own journey for wisdom he seems to argue that simply enjoying life while cultivating a respect for God is better than rigorously pursuing wisdom. Koheleth’s relationship to wisdom was perplexing. I was surprised that he noted that wisdom should be pursued in moderation (7.16), but then in other areas of the text, placed a high value on it, even saying that wisdom can bring about wealth (7.11).
Maybe Koheleth wrote this book so that others would not get too wrapped up in an “excess” of wisdom and instead, gain from his journey so that they could immediately begin trying to live in the moment as Koheleth prescribes rather than wasting precious time on their own search for wisdom. If youth is so fleeting, Koheleth must believe that it shouldn’t be wasted in a tormented pursuit for meaning. Koheleth often drives home the point that life is fleeting in his beautiful but also somewhat dissatisfying meditation on mortality. Koheleth doesn’t claim to have all the answers to life, leaving important questions, such as whether a man’s lifebreath endures, unanswered (3.21). While reading Ecclesiastes, I found myself constantly wanting more, and wishing that Koheleth would reach some grand insight that made life seem orderly and fulfilling. His indirect writing style which travels around in circles, revisiting old ideas and subtly shifting them made me feel like I was trying to find my way out of the woods, but instead only retracing my steps.
Oh, this is one of my favorite posts so far! Beautiful!
ReplyDelete"Of making many books there is no end..."
I really like the way that Koheleth could not find the answers and kept going back to old ideas. I don't think any of us could ever find the answer of life even though we live over two thousand years later and have so much more knowledge. But of course there was that verse about gaining wisdom meant gaining sorrow..
ReplyDelete