This is the first time that I have read Ecclesiastes, other than briefly “skimming over” the book. The Teacher seems very dispirited about the state of the world around him. Actually, he proclaims multiple times that “all is vanity” and “chasing after wind” and “there was nothing to be gained under the sun”. With these frequent remarks, the book quickly takes on a negative tone.
It is obvious that the Teacher has had ample time and opportunity to ponder the questions of life and death that interest him. I began to think about the kind of person that would have this type of luxury. Surly, it is one that has food to eat and his other basic needs met, otherwise he would be spending more time toward life-sustaining ends and less time with pursuing philosophical questions. The next aspect of the Teacher’s life that made an impact upon me was his borderline obsession with gain. From the very beginning of the book, the Teacher begins displaying all of his possessions. I find his manner almost conceited when he seems so pleased, at the end of chapter two, that he has “more than any who had been before me in Jerusalem”.
Despite the fact that the Teacher clearly has more than what he could possibly need, he is still very dissatisfied with his life. I could not help but notice his indifference towards those who are less fortunate and wonder if this might be the reason for his unhappiness. He advises people to not worry about “the oppression of the poor and the violation of justice and right” in chapter five. He attributes his lack of concern to his idea that God will avenge all injustices at the right time. I can see how this would pacify the privileged, but how is this to be of immediate comfort to those who are actually being tortured in the present?
I would have to agree with the Teacher that his life is indeed vain. However, I do not accept this vanity as an inevitable aspect of life. The reason that the Teacher finds no value is because he is only “toiling” for personal gain. It is only logical that life would be vain if each person only strived for the sole benefit of himself, after all everyone is going to perish in the end. The Teacher might feel more satisfied if he thought of someone other than himself.
Great point about the ample time to think. I was struck by that. See 7:29, "But, see, this I did find: God made men plain, but they have engaged in too much reasoning."
ReplyDelete