This was my first time to read Ecclesiastes and so I was surprised by how personable the writing was. I had expected it to be more similar to Proverbs, though it did have it's specific pieces of advice, and so sound more distant and less sympathetic to the direct experience pain felt by humanity. Rather than being objective, it sounded more like a personal journal written by a person who could honestly admit to and face the pain of everyday life. An issue I have with reading other sections of the Bible is that, while they provide optimism and encouragement for endurance, they do not fully sympathize with or explore the initial bad feelings. Christians are definitely not exempt from feeling the emptiness of life that can, at times, be overwhelming, nor should they. Ecclesiastes admits to that feeling, even while loving and fearing an almighty God. Not that the God described provided a constantly reliable source of comfort to the author. The author of Ecclesiastes readily spoke of the uncertainty of God's plan and his main piece of advice seemed to be to go with the flow. We are incapable of predicting the exact future, so the best thing we can do is accept what happens and find an appreciation for the experience at hand, whether it is what we had hoped for or not, remembering that life is full of cycles.
My favorite verse was 7:14, “In the day of prosperity be joyful, and in the day of adversity consider; God has made one as well as the other, so that mortals may not find out anything that will come after them.” The verse is neither too optimistic to take seriously or empathize with on a day of adversity, nor is it discouraging. It provides a realistic way to make the best of both situations and to appreciate them for what they are. Fighting adversity typically only encourages more discouragement, and so by freely feeling what is within, without feeling as if one is doing something sinful or against God's will, can one be healed with the endorsement that it is good and natural for unhappiness to come on some days. The book of Ecclesiastes unabashedly admits how awful life can be for anyone, but rather than quickly steering the sufferer away from the unknown, it stands by and patiently waits by his side.
So I'm glad that I read your view on Ecclesiastes. I feel like you personally took a more optimistic point of view from it, thus you were able to experience a feeling of sympathy from it. I think that's what you're saying. I say this because, this book was actually making me feel a little uneasy. I was wondering why it was so... grim. Frankly, it could be because we are human, and are subject to doubt. By addressing that doubt, the book is taking an almost psychological route in addressing that doubt and providing comfort.
ReplyDeleteI like how you pointed out that this could be a personal journal. When I read, I got a little irritated by the way that the Teacher seems to think of himself as very wise. Since I don't find much wisdom in the Teacher's attitude toward those who are oppressed, I did not like the Teacher presenting himself as an authority on life. However, you made me realize that this could have just been personal musings of a troubled person and not actually meant to offer anyone else guidance.
ReplyDeleteAlso, I liked how you brought up the uncertainty of God's plan. I felt that this was a great cause of frustration for the Teacher. I agree that his overall advice was to "go with the flow". This made me wonder if he might not be more benefited from a view of God that "goes with the flow" with the rest of humanity, instead of one that is so controlling.
Ah! I love 7:14 so much!! (cf Job 2:10, "...should we accept only good from God and not accept evil?")
ReplyDeleteI really like Lacey's comment too because it just explained a lot to ME, too. I have been puzzled by all the responses from people who found Koheleth irritating and egotistical, etc.
And there's the answer! You're bound to feel that way if you read it at as some sort of authoritative official impartation of advice to others, as opposed to one man's meandering journey. Like Genevieve, I had always read it that way, but now the other viewpoint makes sense to me too.
I'd rather read it as not authoritative; I'd definitely find it annoying too if I took it as some sort of official, authoritative sort of text. Do you think the translation of Koheleth (Qoholeth?) as the Teacher (or the Preacher as in KJV) might also encourage this authoritative view?
Huh, I guess 12:9-12 actually helps here, in choosing one interpretation or another. I think it supports the personal-journey view more than the authoritative one. "....He listened to and tested the soundness of many maxims... The sayings of the wise are like goads, like nails fixed in prodding sticks"