Wednesday, August 25, 2010

You're so vain, Solomon

This is my first time reading Ecclesiastes from an academic view and not from a "churchy sermon" view, and frankly I was overwhelmed. The Qohelet or Teacher was very verbose in his speech of life experiences. His uncertain, ambiguous, and beautifully poetic rambling made it difficult for mt to focus and determine what his specific teaching/argument was. His frequent changes in tone made it hard to determine his attitude towards life. It was a frustrating read because of his seemingly negative tone, about how "all in vanity". (1:2) However, after more thinking, I believe that the Teacher isn't being negative of pessimistic but realistic and truthful. These problems of "vanity" and "chasing after the wind" are problems that every human being, even Christians who won't admit it, face in life. Ecclesiastes is taken negatively not only because of its contrast to the Old Testament, which is straightforward and decisive, but also because the Teacher confronts a topic that everyone want to ignore: "the meaning of life". Is the meaning of life joy? Wealth? Wisdom? To answer this the Teacher goes through an unconventional rout of discovery that portrays the skepticism in humans. Int eh end, the Teacher decides that all is vain in the end, "all go to one place; all are from dust, and all turn to dust again". (3:20) The Teacher who is presumably King Solomon, describes his life as all toil and vain. Even though Solomon purposely set out to experience the "joys" of life in wealth, power, and sexual pleasure (2:4-8), he still ended up unhappy. He blames it on the toil of life. But is his unhappiness because of his actual and physical toil, or is it because of his reason of toiling? Toiling for yourself doesn't being happiness, you'll just die in the end and lose it. (2:18). Toiling for others doesn't work either, you'll just be forgotten by the next generation. (2:16) Solomon struggles with this vanity issue but conclusively agrees that if you work or toil for God and keep Him as your priority, you can and will enjoy life and its toils. Since the Teacher said that everything under the sun is vanity repeatedly, I believe that he is advising us to put our works and toils over the sun into heaven. Make God's heaven big and our earth small and everything else will be put into perspective. Like the Teacher said, make God the primary goal of life.

5 comments:

  1. Ah, make God the goal of life, eh? What does that mean exactly? Anyway, could this goal, too, like all the others, not also be vexed, subject to the same caveats and troubles as every thing else Koheleth discusses? E.g., as in 2:24-26.

    Is Koheleth really concluding that, after all, there really is a silver magic bullet that succeeds? Or does his advice apply to itself?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I have the same question as Domingo: what does it mean to toil for God? It would be interesting to hear more about the author's personal experience of God, rather than his assumptions that God is the answer. Though the author has ruled out every other option, is God really the magic answer to life's pain or is he the only unprovable option remaining? Does a change in to whom you attribute your actions to make a lasting difference, or is it wishful thinking?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Qohelet's understanding of God is one of the consistent dilemmas in interpreting the book of Ecclesiastes. Qohelet certainly believes in God and commends fear of God. It is less clear, however, whether he thinks God is reliable or even has humankind's best interests at heart. I'll be interested to see where you all come out on this issue.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think the author is using "living life for God" as a way to deny responsibility for fellow human beings. The author is so self-centered that he can only see the benefit of helping others if it gains him some kind of everlasting fame, which is why I personally think he is so dissatisfied. The author only advocates living for God because he thinks that God will judge in the end and that his fear of God will result in him being on the "right side" in the end. Once again, this is very self-centered. It would be nice if the author would have developed some type of god-concept that might help people here and now.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think Qohelet's thoughts on both God and enjoyment may be more complex than we have so far allowed. Look, for instance, at Ecc 6:1-2. Why does Qohelet raise the issue of a person whom God does not give the capacity for enjoyment? And how might that inform our understanding of what "living life for God" (I'm not sure where that phrase comes from, actually) might look like for Qohelet?

    ReplyDelete