Monday, August 30, 2010

Dust

The lyrics to “Dust in the Wind” are similar to the images of the world found in Ecclesiastes 1:1-11 and Proverbs 8:22-31.  The passage from Proverbs contrasts the opening to Ecclesiastes.  Ecclesiastes focuses on the cosmos’ eternal, meaningless motion and puts little emphasis on individual people while Proverbs puts its emphasis on the individual’s place in God’s creation.  The “Solomon” in Proverbs believes that he was created before God created the world.  I interpret this as meaning the spirits of humans were with God before God had even created physical bodies for them.  It all seems very happy and lovely, but if you look at the last two verses (8:30-31) maybe not so much.  The speaker was happy because he was in God’s presence (sort of like heaven?), but considering that he is now physically alive he is no longer that close to God.  He might be in the Ecclesiastes version of meaningless existence; somewhere between primordial spirit and the oblivion of death or just maybe an afterlife.  The two passages are like flip sides of the same coin in that life can feel very good sometimes and at others can feel pointless.  “Dust in the Wind” leans towards Ecclesiastes in its message, but it gives more thought on how we should live.  The songs admits that every thought or action is “just a drop of water in an endless sea” and that everything becomes dust in the wind.  In Ecclesiastes 1:7 the sea is described as never being full.  The water travels between sea and stream forever and for no obvious purpose.  The world is a cycle that progresses to anything new.  Man toils to create but all is forgotten or as the song says, “nothing lasts forever but the earth and sky”.  The final verse in “Dust in the Wind” says that we should not try to hold onto things and nothing can increase our time on Earth.  We should enjoy every moment that we have.

6 comments:

  1. At first I also thought that most of the lyrics of Dust in the Wind were speaking of the meaningless of worldly pleasures and things like that. The line in the chorus that really makes me question whether there is a moral of any kind of hope is "ALL WE ARE is dust in the wind."

    This made me think because it is not talking about out actions anymore. This is a direct reference to us as humans and to me it says that we have little to no lasting effect on our world. Once we pass, not only are we gone, but any memory or good effects we've had on the world don't last at all.

    This is an odd statement considering how huge of an impact we have on our world in every way.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really like the point you made about the Proverbs passage and the Ecclesiastes passage both being different stages of Solomon's existence. I agree that the section from Proverbs is talking about a man's existence (perhaps as God's thought) before his human debut. If this is true, and the author of Ecclesiastes is in fact Solomon, I could see how his opinion of creation could shift so dramatically upon entering the physical realm of life.

    ReplyDelete
  3. You drew an interesting conclusion that, "we should enjoy every moment we have." I remember we discussed earlier how one's interpretation of Ecclesiastes typically reflects upon a personal perspective, so I am wondering if you consider yourself to be particularly optimistic, so as to be able to draw such a conclusion from a section that people often regard as depressing, and especially after stating that "the water travels between sea and stream forever and for no obvious purpose." When I read Ecc. 1:1-11 I don't see it as having yet reached a place to derive sure optimism, but I am glad that you can see it as being so clearly uplifting.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The passage from Proverbs was from the perspective of Wisdom, personified as a woman. You had to look back to 8:12 to figure it out though. The passage was confusing to me out of that context. I hope that helps!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I liked your analysis about the “Solomon” in Proverbs and your statement that he was created before God created the world. When I was reading this passage I also felt that it was implying that God knew about his plans for every one of us before he even created the world. However, I found the ending to be difficult because I am not sure if I am supposed to read it as if I have lost my connection with God by having a physical presence on earth and will never regain it or that the point of my physical presence on earth is to regain a connection to God.

    ReplyDelete
  6. "Dust in the Wind" has often struck me as being a bit on the nose when it comes to its messages about mortality (although I do love the song). But in the context of Ecclesiastes, the song seems to reaffirm the ideas put forth by Koheleth in Ecclesiastes 1:1-11. Kansas, of course, substitutes "hevel" for dust. "Dust in the Wind", as viewed through Ecclesiastes, seems to support a reading of these verses that emphasize the futility of human endeavor vs the constancy of nature. Kansas, the biblical scholars that they are, seem to take the text (or if not the text, the ideas from the text) at face value.

    ReplyDelete