I read Ecclesiastes (for what I believe was the first time) over 12 hours ago and I still do not know what to think about it. At first glance I was struck by the haunting beauty of its passages and the way in which nearly any human, religious or not, could relate to the feeling that life sometimes seems pointless. The passage from chapter 1:1-11 shows how insignificant the life of any one person is compared to the Earth. A reader from today knows how small we are compared to the entire universe. Today, we also know that even the Earth and everything that inhabits it is not permanent. The teacher then tells how he has accumulated wisdom and wealth and tried to enjoy life. Yet these did not make him have a more meaningful existence. In fact he said that “for with much wisdom comes much sorrow” (1:18). The teacher goes on to say that pleasure, folly, and work are all meaningless. The reasons why these things are meaningless are unclear to me. Is it because everything is going to die and return to dust? Is it meaningless in the presence of God? However the very last verse says that “God will bring every deed into judgment, including every hidden thing, whether it is good or evil” (12:14). Ecclesiastes does not say what this judgment means. The closest reference I saw to an afterlife was in verse 12:7 which said that the spirit returns to God. It did not say whether something good or bad would happen to the spirit depending on the actions of a person’s life. One of questions that Ecclesiastes asks is what is the purpose of life. Is life something that we just have to suffer through or is it something to be enjoyed? Does life serve as a way for God to judge us?
I don't know much about this (I bet our professor or other students will have some insight tomorrow), but I think that Christianity seriously changed the concept of the afterlife, didn't it?
ReplyDeleteWhat was the view on that in context, at the time?
This may be an unpopular view, but I really like the lack of a magical appeal to an afterlife. It allows the book to actually matter here and now instead of having to lean on some unproveable, undisproveable claim that anyone could just make.