Monday, August 30, 2010

The central point of Ecclesiastes 1:1-11 is that man’s life is futile because it is short lived or fleeting. The same things happen again and again, mans’ life just going through the motions (life, death, and so on). He parallels this to things on earth, such as wind constantly blowing and streams rushing to the ocean (but never filling it).

It also says that everything has already existed, there is no longer anything original. Qohelet may be expressing dissatisfaction with the limitations we have as human beings, maybe even feelings of insignificance. Verse eight says “The eye is not satisfied by seeing or the ear filled with hearing.” We are unable to explain the world on our own, our knowledge and wisdom is limited. Since Qohelet thought “the individual can and should proceed towards truth by means of his own powers of perception and reasoning”, having limited time and ability to acquire truth by our own means would be very frustrating.

In Proverbs 8:22-31, the speaker (Solomon) uses a happy tone and enjoys rejoicing before God every day. While Qohelet maintains that respectfulness of God, his voice contradicts that of the first speaker’s: “He set a limit for the sea so that the waters would not violate His command” versus “All the streams flow to the sea…All things are wearisome” (1:8). Proverbs maintains a voice of the author simply being grateful for all of God’s creation, while Ecclesiastes speaks in a philosophical manner.

5 comments:

  1. I read the verses from Proverbs as being written from Wisdom's perspective rather than Solomon's. According to the passage, God created Wisdom as "the first of his works, before the deeds of old." This contradicts Ecclesiastes by saying that the most fundamental aspect of this world is wisdom. What is wise cannot be meaningless; therefore, the world does indeed have some purpose. Additionally, at the end of the passage, Wisdom states that she "was the craftsman at his side" and was pleased with the creation of the world. With Wisdom assisting in creation and delighting in it, the world cannot be utterly meaningless. While I do agree that the Proverbs passage marvels at God's creation, I think what the author is trying to say is that Wisdom is the foundation of the Earth and, by that logic, the world is not without meaning.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with your interpretation of the Ecclesiastes section, and we agree where we understand proverbs, for the most part. I understood the Proverbs to go beyond rejoicing in God, I felt like it was confirming our reason for existence as human beings. More importantly I saw it as a strong contrast with the Ecclesiastes section. In Ecclesiastes 1:5-11 we read of all these natural images and how weary they are. They are constantly going through the same motions, aimlessly. In Proverbs 8:27-31, however, there are similar images but they are given meaning, because it was through the wisdom of God that we were created. So, I agree that the Proverbs involves joy in presence of God’s creations, but I believe it takes it a step forward in saying that everything God created was done so with the utmost wisdom; that includes us. Thus there is no weariness, only purpose in knowing that this is how God wanted it to be.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Beth, a very interesting point! I think they don't contradict, and here's why:

    I read Ecclesiastes not as concluding that life is meaningless, but that it is *meaningless* *as* *far* *as* *humans* *can* *tell*.

    So for God and His Wisdom, everything may be all very fine and well and meaningful. But for us mere mortal humans, Ecc 3:10-11 sums up our limitations well.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I am not sure which way i lean, is it contridicting? is it not? But, i do see your point beth and i think that it is a very interesting point of view. I do like your answer that since wisdom was there in creation and a foundation for the earth there must be a meaning to life.

    Tod, I like your interpretation of proverbs going a step forward and how this is how god wanted it to be.

    Dom, I wonder, if we humans have limited perspectives and thinking capacities and can't know if there is a purpose, how can we know if life is fully meaningless? if we can't percieve it as having a meaning how can we say in all certinty that it doesn't.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree, Marissa. Sorry if my wording was obtuse. I do mean to say that there may or may not be some meaning and we aren't capable of discerning what if any it is and whether there is any.

    (But that does mean that it is "meaningless as far as we can tell" in that the set of meanings we can discern is empty-- just pushing words around, but I mean the same thing you do :-P)

    ReplyDelete