Monday, September 13, 2010

And he takes and he takes and he takes

Ecclesiastes 5:1-6:9

The opening lines of Ecclesiastes 5 are instructions regarding how one should act in the presence of God. Qoheleth uses the setting of the temple to instruct the reader to “draw near to listen.” Qoheleth believes that it is better to listen than to offer a sacrifice that is not genuine. He evokes a sense of humility from the reader when he says that it is better to be silent than to speak “ for God is in heaven, and you upon the earth” (v.2). Qoheleth seems to be suggesting that God’s thoughts are higher than our thoughts. He is beyond human understanding, therefore, we are incapable of understanding his movements or his ways.

A rather abrupt shift occurs in verse 8 when Qoheleth begins to talk about the “oppression of the poor and the violation of justice” as an everyday occurrence. He then makes another unusual shift by saying, “the high official is watched by a higher, and there are yet higher ones over them. But all things considered, this is an advantage for a land; a king for a plowed field.” Even after reading Brown’s commentary on this portion of the text, I am still completely confused as to the meaning of this passage.

In the next section of chapter five (v.10,) Qoheleth says the lover of money will never be satisfied. The more they get, the more they shall want. Even carefully guarded wealth can be lost. Qoheleth writes that in the end material wealth is meaningless, because we will all end up in the same place. Humans gain nothing from their toil. Once again, Qoheleth suggests that man eat, drink, and find enjoyment in the few days he has been given.In chapter six, Qoheleth discovers an evil that he says, “lies heavy upon humankind.” God gives wealth and then does not enable the wealthy to enjoy it – “ And he takes and he takes and he takes” (Casmir Pulaski Day). Man be given much in the way of material possessions, land, and children, but if he cannot enjoy it, Qoheleth says that “ a stillborn child is better off than he” (v.3) Qoheleth believes that a long life that is never filled with joy is worse than no life at all.

Qoheleth ends this section in chapter six by saying that humans will never be satisfied. They will always desire more than they have been given. It is important to see the good and find enjoyment in the very act of recognizing the good, rather than the act itself, which will only result in further desires which cannot be fulfilled.

3 comments:

  1. In your third paragraph your sentences nicely state the contridictions of Qoheleth's reasoning when he is debating what is and is not meaningful and lasting.
    However, when you state,

    "In chapter six, Qoheleth discovers an evil that he says, 'lies heavy upon humankind.' God gives wealth and then does not enable the wealthy to enjoy it..."

    it seems like Qoheleth's God is what is evil in life, though this may be what you intended to describe. It is an interesting idea that Qoheheth's God is both one of the (more) meaningful things in life and is also what makes life miserable and creates the "unhappiness of existance." (Fox 39) It is also amazing that he continues to have faith in this God of pure contridiction. Maybe Qoheleth's definition of evil needs further explantion...

    ReplyDelete
  2. In chapter 6 ("...a tragedy...weighs heavily on mankind"), I have two versions. One says "weighs heavily on mankind", the other "a grave one (evil) it is for man". I almost want to translate it as man having some responsibility in their inability to enjoy their wealth. Either way, Qohelet seems to maintain that you shouldn't question God in any instance. That you shouldn't question why God doesn't "enable the wealthy to enjoy it."

    ReplyDelete
  3. Genevieve, I like how you actually ask why Qoheleth continues to have faith in this version of God. I have been thinking this the entire time. Qoheleth's concept of God makes God seem like a big bully. Why is this a God that is worshipped? It seems to me that Qoheleth feels he has to worship this God because he can't be understood or reasoned with and he is very evil. Qoheleth seems to see the safer option in worshipping this God, at least this is how to not get your processions taken away.

    ReplyDelete