Monday, October 11, 2010

Lemme Break It Down for You

Chapters 1 and 2 of Job give the reader a narrative which provides syntactical information for the book. The first chapter tells of Job, his family, his possessions, and his pious nature. It also relates the tale of how Job became the issue a challenge between God and Satan. Chapter 2 tells of how the challenge intensifies after Job fails to falter in his devotion. The narrative nature of these first 2 books raises some concern as to its authenticity. That, combined with the humanistic qualities that are attached to God and Satan lead me to believe that these chapters may have been added at a later time from the rest of the book.
The first chapter informs the reader of Job, his family, his worldly wealth, and his pious nature. Some of these details are conveyed in an almost hyperbolic manner. “He was blameless, a man of complete integrity.” (Job 1:1) “He was, in fact, the richest person in that entire area.” (Job 1:3) In verse four, it goes so far as to talk of how he would “purify his children” at each of his sons’ birthdays. The exaggerated approach that the first chapter uses to describe Job leads to some speculation as to its origins. It sounds as if the poetic dialogue that makes up most of Job was discovered first, and then the first chapter was added to set the scene.
Chapter 1 continues and in verse 6 the situation is further revealed. After Satan reveals that he has been traveling the Earth, God asks him “Have you noticed my servant, Job? He is the finest man in all the earth--a man of complete integrity.” (Job 1:8). Immediately, there is the question of how we know of what is going on in heaven. Arguably, one of the main messages in Job is that mankind is humble and cannot expect to understand how things work on a divine level. However, assuming that for some reason God has allowed us to access a transcript from his heavenly court, the account reveals that Satan is skeptical of Job’s devotion. Out of this skepticism, comes a challenge from Satan. God accepts the challenge, and Job’s life becomes a spectacle for the divine. Even after Job proves his loyalty for God in verse 22, the challenge is allowed to intensify in Chapter 2 because Satan is not convinced yet. It is perplexing how petty God is portrayed in this situation. Why would God Almighty feel the need to boast on his servant? Why would he feel the need to prove that he is right through this wager with Satan? God is an all powerful, all seeing, omniscient being, so in going with that, this entire exchange with Satan should be completely pointless? The reduction of God to an almost typical man is uncharacteristic of biblical books as well as the dialogue within Job. If the workings of God are truly as complicated and incomprehensible as expressed in chapter 38, how is it that this story can be related so simply?
The narrative first two chapters, if added after the initial recording of Job, were most likely added to help the reader understand the story of Job by providing details surrounding it, fabricated or not. The simple hyperbolic nature of the descriptions and the simplification of the heavenly happenings point to origins outside the original author.

2 comments:

  1. I really like your questions about this disturbing depiction of God. The simplistic nature of the narrative and the contradiction of the beyond-our-minds God of chapter 38 with the clear view of the working of Heaven in the narrative make the author of the narrative seem pretty unreliable. I actually am wondering how Job in this current state made it into the Bible, seeing as how it seems pretty flawed.

    ReplyDelete
  2. What befuddles me the most about this depiction of God in chapter 1 is that he clearly needs humans. God needs Job to praise him. God needs this servant to make him seem high and mighty. Basically, God would not be the God depicted in chapter one without people. This brings God's high and mighty persona down a few notches in chapter 38. I believe this is why we are so bothered by God. God just is not as high and mighty as he wants Job to believe. God needs Job, maybe as much as Job needs God. Job is forced to admit this in the end, but God gets to wiggle out of facing reality and continue to seem grandly independent and mighty. God is just not being fair; he's pretending to be something he is not.

    ReplyDelete