Wednesday, October 6, 2010

Have you considered my servant Job?

One of the first thoughts that came to mind as I was reading Job is that this book has a much more clearly defined structure than Ecclesiastes. Both books are quite poetic and both have somewhat of an underlying structure, though the structure in Ecclesiastes is, at times, quite loose. Job, however, has a more defined structure that seems to work to further the narrative in a clearer, more concise manner.


The beginning of the book (Chapters 1 and 2) are in prose. They set up the story of Job, letting the reader know of the tragedies that befell him and why. They serve as an introduction and a background to the poetic conversations between Job and his friends. The final section of the book (Chapter 42 verses 7-17) is also in prose and neatly finishes the story of Job in a straightforward, epilogue fashion. This occurs after the Lord finally answers Job's questions about his misfortune and Job repents.


I wonder if this narrative style of poetry bookended by prose is simply a narrative technique or whether it has thematic elements. The tragedies that befall Job and later the prosperity that the Lord returns to him are both concrete elements to the story. They are the only parts that have to do with action rather than speaking or questioning. They are also the only parts that occur in prose, rather than in poetic style. The poetic elements of Job occur in his questioning of God and in the debates with his friends. Perhaps this poetic nature is somehow related to the abstract aspects of Job's questing or of his friend's extolling the virtues of God. It does seem, however, that Job resolves itself much more neatly than did Ecclesiastes. Despite the troubles Job faces in the beginning, he finds answers in the end, repents, and his fortune is restored. This book seems to reaffirm Job's worldview rather than tearing it down.

2 comments:

  1. I am curious as to what answers you think that Job finds in the end? I interpreted the text as Job realizing that he has no answers (when God rebukes him), and then once again being blessed by God.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also payed a lot of attention to structure, and wonder if there are more subtle intended functions of the structure than I can appreciate. I also think however, that it would be possible to break Ecclesiastes down into a very similar structure, having and introductory narrative voice, the words of the character(s), maybe an interlude somehwere, and then again closing with a narrator. But I wonder if its right to be inclined to think so just because they are both texts from similar historical backgrounds.

    ReplyDelete