Sunday, October 3, 2010

Qohelet Should Get to Punch This Epilogist in the Face, Or Atleast Tell Him Off

When reading Ecclesiastes 12: 9-14, the epilogue, I found myself wondering if the person who wrote this section had read the same Book of Qohelet that I have been reading. The epilogist begins, in third person point of view, by saying that the Teacher taught people knowledge. I guess that one could make the case that Qohelet’s constant reiteration that humans have no control over what happens in the world, to the point that they cannot even know how to be good, is some twisted sort of wisdom. However, this is definitely not conventional wisdom; this is not simple advice that one can effortlessly apply to life in a beneficial way. The epilogue fails to shed light on the confused, meaninglessness at the core of Qohelet’s knowledge. Instead, the epilogist compares Qohelet’s teaching to “many proverbs” in verse 9, which is misleading. The epilogist also says, “he wrote words of truth plainly”. Qohelet is nothing if he is not confusing. I cannot see how anyone could find the Book of Qohelet plain, or easy to interpret. This book is basically one frustrating contradiction after another. This false impression of Qohelet tinges the rest of the way that the epilogue is interpreted.


Since verses 9-10 portray Qohelet as a person that has knowledge that is true and helpful, it is easy to assume in verse 11 that Qohelet is using goads, with nails firmly fixed, to encourage his students to heed his advice. Of course, the knowledgeable Qohelet of the epilogue, with his true, pleasing words, would only be goading people for their own good. Qohelet is even referred to as a “shepherd” in verse 11, and in verse 12, the epilogist warns readers to beware of delving into the study of anything that is “beyond these”, which I took to mean beyond these wise teachings of Qohelet. In verse 13, the epilogist takes this caution a step further, when he says, “The end of the matter; all has been heard.”


Verses 11-13 really portray Qohelet as a person who should be listened to, as a man who truly knows what he is talking about. I’m not quite sure that Qohelet would like this. I think he would be the first to admit that he knows nothing and he wouldn’t be embarrassed by this, because no one knows anything, but chasing after the wind. I think the epilogist is using Qohelet as a means to his own ends. In 13b, the epilogist says, “Fear God, and keep his commandments; for this is the whole duty of everyone.” Maybe fearing God is what the epilogist would like to think is the whole duty of everyone, but the real Qohelet has just written an entire book proclaiming the futility of fearing God, because humans cannot know what God desires. The epilogist ends in verse 14 with an attempt to enforce his advice to fear God, with the reminder that in the end God will judge all deeds, whether good or evil. I think at this point Qohelet would laugh at the epilogist and remind him that all people come to same death. Maybe Qohelet would sneer at the epilogist and tell him that his goody-two-shoes self is still dyeing and going down with the animals.


This epilogue is making a mockery of the Book of Qohelet. The cynical, confused, honest Qohelet is lost, and some all-knowing wise man is presented instead. Although the epilogist’s stretching of Qohelet’s message is probably the reason that Ecclesiastes made it into the Judeo-Christian cannon, Qohelet’s true wisdom has been lost and perverted in the epilogue. A more honest epilogist would have ended with “Enjoy your food, wine, and toil; for this is best that you can hope for in your vain, little life.”

2 comments:

  1. I agree with this. I think those last 6 verses are the reason that Ecc made it into the bible. I am not sure how much Qoh would disagree with all of the epilogue's claims but verse 13 he would definitely not like. I wonder what you would think about the theory that Brown puts out that there are 2 authors in the epilogue?

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really liked most of your interpretation. I would agree that the epilogue disagrees with most of the book. However, I'm not sure that Qoheleth would disagree with all of the epilogue. In 1:13-16 Qoheleth writes "I devoted myself to study and to explore by wisdom all that is done under heaven . . . I have seen all the things that are done under the sun . . . I have grown and increased in wisdom more than anyone who has ruled over Jerusalem before me." Also, I think Qoheleth would completely agree with the part about fearing G-d (standing in awe of G-d, 5:1-7).

    ReplyDelete