In Ecc. Chapter 5, vv. 1-6, Qohelet’s point seems to be that you should think before you speak. He speaks of being cautious in making vows, because unlike God, humans can’t discern the future. Verses three and four are very similar to Deuteronomy. While Deuteronomy talks about the guilt you’ll feel in breaking a vow, Ecclesiastes speaks of what will come of revoking your vows (betray your vows, God will destroy your possessions).
Qohelet says in Chapter 5 verse seven to not wonder at oppression/suppression of the poor. It sounds as if Qohelet doesn’t foresee improvements in social oppression. He says that everyone must tend their land in order to survive. He notably uses the word “control” in talking about the land (“he controls a field that is cultivated”, 5:8). Verses 9-12, Qohelet speaks of the futility of the love of money. The purpose of money is instant gratification, but you will soon want more. Money ignites greed in others, and causes the holder of wealth to have anxiety about losing it to another. Qohelet sees it as pointless to have money and lose it never having enjoyed it, or to have money due to God, but God does not allow you to enjoy it. Qohelet sees working and never gaining anything from it as the worst case scenario. He believes the best thing to do is use your money in a timely fashion in a way that would please you.
In Chapter 6 verses 7-9, Qohelet talks of what we have (“feasting of the eyes”) versus what we want (“the pursuit of desires”). If we our enjoying our lives/possessions or “feasting our eyes”, it’s good. But if we start wanting other things (“pursuit of desire”), we forget about whatever we were enjoying and the things we were enjoying are lost…this leaves us with nothing, thus making it all hevel.
I like what you are saying. I would like to see what you think about what Brown says on page 61. he talks about how Qoheleth is now lamenting about not having anyone to pass on his wealth to. now the problem seems to be that there is not going to be anything to pass on to your children. (Ecc. 6:12)
ReplyDeleteI agree with what you are saying, i also saw the comparison to Deuteronomy. Why don't you think that Qohelet doesn't see possible improvements with opression and unjustice? Does he believe this because money has a negative effect? I think this where you were going, because the wealthy back then ran the country, so if the wealthy are corrupt, then how can the oppression be fixed?
ReplyDeleteWhat do you mean by owing money to God? I don't understand what you mean exactly.