Ecclesiastes 1:12 – 2:26 is rich in content, and a lot can be said about these verses. For me, wisdom is the most interesting aspect of this passage because of the different ways Qohelet talks about wisdom and meaning. As I read this text, especially 2:9-23, I felt that he was not saying that wisdom is necessarily bad, but rather he was resigning to the fact that wisdom does not change the fact that death is inevitable, and someone will take over all the things left behind. 2:24-26 goes on to say that a man “can do no better than to eat and drink and find satisfaction in his work.” Worrying about who will get the things you’ve toiled for is meaningless because it’s not going to be any different. Rather, things are given from God and should be appreciated. Though wisdom can be a burden, God gives the “man who pleases him” the ability to gain that knowledge and understand that true fulfillment is unattainable.
Something I found really interesting in Fox’s commentary was a discussion of part of 1:13 (“I set my mind…”). Fox translates it to “I set my heart” and goes on to talk about Qohelet’s distinction between his heart and his ego. Qohelet speaks to his heart and explores in his heart, as if it is a completely separate person. Reading the text with this in mind put a new spin on it. It was interesting to swap “myself” with “heart” and look at how it changed the tone or content of the text.
Finally, I think Alanis Morissette's “Would Not Come” was such a reflection of Ecclesiastes 1:12 – 2:26. That feeling of never being fulfilled, of obtaining or changing things, was vey clear in the lyrics. “I’d be filthy rich and still it would not come. I would seduce them and still it would not come. I would drink vodka and still it would not come…if I accumulate knowledge I’ll be impenetrable.” Wealth, pleasure, and drink are not fully satisfying. The idea that accumulating knowledge will cause impenetrability (but in reality it will not)…where have we heard that before? I feel Alanis captures Qohelet’s attitude in just four minutes, and adds a new layer to the question of fulfillment.
According to Fox, the moment in 2:13 in which he praises wisdom simply may have been him restating common knowledge. Even though he never refutes this knowledge, this would make his conclusion about the fool and the wise man's fate even more damning. When Koheleth concludes that a man who pleases God will have greater fortune at the end of chapter 2, I felt that Koheleth was unclear about what, if anything, would make a man be in God's favor. This, for me, makes that conclusion ring false for me.
ReplyDeleteI also felt that the Alanis Morissette song was very appropriate for the given verses. It reiterated the folly of achievement that Koheleth seems to dwell on. On the other hand, I was really confused by the choice of Kanye West's "Diamonds from Sierra Leone".
i was also confused about the inclusion of the Kanye west song, but i think it is about striving to acquire all that your heart desired and finding that none of it actually mattered.
ReplyDeleteanyway
i think i agree with your first paragraph if you mean what i think you mean. My take on it is that the search for wisdom is meaningless because everything ends up the same. in 2:26 we get a list of the rewards that different people get. The wise man gets wisdom and the sinner gets to store up all his wealth and then leave it to someone else. "this too is meaningless, a chasing of the wind." I read that as very resentful towards god and life in general.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your first paragraph where you state that you believe that Qohelet is saying that wisdom is not bad- though the end result of your life will not be different than that of a foolish person. I believe Qohelet thinks that those who are wise have it worse off than the foolish. In 1:18 he writes, “with much wisdom comes much sorrow” and “the more knowledge, the more grief." I think Qohelet's argument - that knowledge causes more suffering is a very interesting one- that should most definitely be discussed in class.
ReplyDeleteYou say that "Qohelet speaks to his heart and explores in his heart, as if it is a completely separate person." I'm curious as to how you came to this conclusion; I attempted to read that way but I did not see it. In biblical Hebrew the word used here for "mind" can also mean "heart." Also in Hebrew the heart (or soul) is not separate from the self.
ReplyDeleteI also agree with your first paragraph that wisdom isn't bad in itself but that its bad (or unfavorable) because in the end it doesn't have nay benefits or add to anyhting, "a wise man has the same fate as the fool". but then he states that extensive wisdom only beings "vexation and sorrow".
ReplyDeleteI do however, disagree with your statement of the heart taking on a new persona than the mind. Doesn't the mind think and speak from the heart? If so, then they are connected and shouldn't have two meanings and different "persons".