Thursday, September 2, 2010

Sorry bout the late post

Ecclesiastes 1:12-2:26 focuses on the meaninglessness of not only worldly achievements, but the pursuit of them as well. The teacher talks about all of the projects he has undertaken that did not bring him any greater satisfaction than he already had. To me this is an ineresting idea because usually the oppossite is thought to be true. "t is unwise to be complacent in stagnation". My Dad used to say that to me all of the time when I was a child and what he meant was that you can't be proud of yourself and your achievements if you sit down and do nothing while you have the capacity to still do even bigger and greater things with your life. I still believe this to be true in relation to my life, by the Qoheleth says that the more he set out to gain in knowledge, the more sorrowful his heart became from understanding more about the true plight of the world (1:15-18). This at first would also seem to say that ignorance is truly bliss, because no matter how the teacher tries to approach life after gaining this wisdom, he could not shake his cynicism and grief caused by knowing about the evils in the world ("what has been twisted cannot be straightened"-vs. 1:15)

The idea of "chasing after the wind" is applied to all pursuit of a better life. I thought for a while that the moral of this teaching was to be content with what you already have rather than to stargaze your whole life. The pursuit of something more always leaves you with more material possessions, but the feeling of emptiness upon discovering what else there is to be had that you don't already have will always remain with you and eventually break you. This led me to believe in being thankful for what you already have, but the teacher then appears to even speak against that as well. Ecclesiastes 2:3 talks about the teacher's attempt at complacency, but says that with the knowledge and wisdom he already had gained, it was pointless and futile to try to fool his own mind into believing a reality that he knew wasn't true. So many contradictory thoughts.....

"Would Not Come" by Alanis Morissette speaks directly about a more modern take on the pursuit of something more. Everything that she thought would bring he peace of mind and happiness just left her aching for what else she didn't have. All of these things that were suppossed to fill that emptiness that comes from knowing about what you don't have never went away, and no matter what she achieved, who she spoke to, and what she tried to do to take her mind off of her restlessness, the joy to occupy that empty space in her heart "would not come".

This modern experience coupled with the teacher's further documentation of his views on the futility of everything in life really does paint a more bleak picture of the book of Ecclesiastes if one looks at life as the viscious circular cycle of wanting, but never gaining; trying to forget this sorrow from "a chasing after the wind" but knowing that the truth in your mind will never go away. Reality is haunting, isn't it?

1 comment:

  1. In response to your father's wisdom,

    "The eye is not satisfied with seeing, nor the ear filled with hearing..."

    :-)

    ReplyDelete