Ecclesiates chapter 5 begins with a meditation on the worship of God. Qohelet sees no point in making sacrifices to God when God is in heaven and man is on Earth (v. 1-2). The realm of God has no need for money or slaughtered animals. What man can offer to God is fulfilled vows, unfulfilled vows come from fools who speak empty words. Silence is preferable to empty, ill-chosen words, it is better to listen to God because as someone on earth what can be said to God who transcends earth. Therefore it is better to let your words be few in front of God (v. 2). I’m not sure if this means Qohelet thinks that God does not do anything about human concerns or if there is no connection between Earth and God. In “Casimir Pulaski Day” the sick person was prayed for but nothing happened.
Money is an earthly thing that man foolishly tries to collect. The rich are Money cannot be taken with man when he dies yet rich men spend all of their time trying to get more of it (v. 10). The rich are never satisfied with their wealth. So much so that the rich man cannot sleep while the laborer's sleep is “sweet” (v. 11-12) Man leaves the world as he enters it (v.15), a man cannot take what he has earned from to work to whatever happens after death. At the end of this section, Qohelet realizes that is its good for man to enjoy the short life that God as given him and enjoy whatever wealth he has received, unlike the rich man who always wants more and can never enjoy what he has (v. 18-19). In verse 20, Qohelet seems to think that a man who follows this advice has a good life in the sense that he does not worry about the shortness and meaning of his life because he is focused on enjoying simple pleasures (eating, drinking, finding joy).
In chapter 6 Qohelet says that the inability to enjoy things is a “grievous evil” (v.1-2). He thinks that a stillborn child, who never knows anything of existence, is better off than a man who does not enjoy his good fortune (v. 3). I’m not sure what Qohelet means by the man not receiving a proper burial, maybe not receiving a burial is like being unfulfilled. I’m guessing the hypothetical man’s 100 children did not care for him because he was not enjoying his life including not enjoying his children.
I don't think it would be entirely accurate to say that Qoheleth finds sacrifices and vows meaningless. He just seems to think that broken vows are worse than no vows at all; I think he still finds value in fulfilled vows. Although, I do believe that Qoheleth feels that people should not be preoccupied with pleasing and appeasing God and should be more worried with enjoying their lives.
ReplyDeleteI thought that Qoheleth sees enjoying life as a way to please God. Therefore, I'm not sure that he would actually say that enjoyment is more important than service to God. Actually, I think a big part of what makes enjoying life important is because God has given humans this gift and it is their God-given lot to enjoy it. Of course, there is that other thing about life being totally meaningless if you do not enjoy the small pleasures, so maybe you are right that this is more important than serving God. Still, I think the two seem to go hand-in-hand.
ReplyDelete