Wednesday, September 15, 2010

Qoheleth is Meaningless, Yet he Still Has his Moments

Despite the fact that Qoheleth eventually does offer advice for how to cultivate a meaningful existence, Ecc. 6:10-7:14 begins in a fashion that leaves the reader thinking that man is indeed a totally hopeless creature. Ecc. 6:10-12 functions as a concise introduction. Qoheleth begins this passage with an explanation of why it is the fate of man to be insignificant. In 6:10, he states, “Whatever has come to be has already been named, and it is known what human beings are...”. Since all things have already been named, or determined, the fate of human beings is already decided. Qoheleth goes on to point out that humans are not capable of disputing with those who are stronger, which is presumably God, wisdom, or someone divine. In 6:12, Qoheleth reminds humans that they “pass like a shadow” and that because of this they cannot really know what is good. This introduction is important because it opens the reader to the idea that man truly is meaningless in the grand scheme of the universe. It is imperative that the reader realizes this in the beginning because the rest of the passage is Qoheleth’s advice for how to make peace with this convoluted life.

There is an obscure shift to positivity in 7:1. Although it may be difficult to realize the positivity, Qoheleth is attempting to comfort his audience by helping them see the value in recognizing their insignificance. Qoheleth seems jaded when he says in 7:1 “...the day of death [is better], than the day of birth.” The reader must realize that Qoheleth is truly saying that recognizing the certainty of death is a means by which a person can see her life in perspective and enjoy it before it vanishes. This most constructive way of interpreting 7:1-4 considers Qoheleth’s musings as pre-requisites to enjoying life. Basically, you must realize that all will perish in the end, before you can understand that enjoying the moment is all that mortals ever have.

In Ecc. 7: 5-12, Qoheleth seems to feel that he has convinced his audience of the importance of living in the present. In this section of text, he turns to offering some real council for how to heed his advice. For example, in 7:10, he touches on the foolishness of nostalgia by warning the reader not to ask “Why were the former days better than these?”. In 7:12, he says that wisdom gives life. Wisely realizing the fleetingness of life is what enables a person to actually have a life that is enjoyed, to actually have a life worth living.

In keeping with his advocation that man is insignificant, Qoheleth returns the focus to God in 7:13. He says “Consider the work of God: who can make straight what he has made crooked?”. This verse seems to have dual meaning. The most obvious is that humans are powerless and that they cannot effect the will of God. However, on a deeper level, this verse hints that humans and God are not even viewing the world in a common language. Humans find something crooked that God considers straight. In 7:14, Qoheleth advises humans to live in the moment by being happy at the appropriate times and sad when adversity comes. Pointing out the dominance of God is excellent support for Qoheleth’s advice, because it leaves the reader with the idea that living with the highs and lows of life is all the she is capable of, therefore she might as well accept Qoheleth’s advice and enjoy all the fleeting moments that she is given.

2 comments:

  1. I interpreted 7:1 a little differently than you did. I know in class we've endlessly discussed whether or not Qohelet believes in an afterlife, and when reading Ecclesiastes it is unclear (imagine that). Personally I think Qohelet might be leanin towards a belief in heaven with 7:1. If a person believes that when they die their soul will eternally exist in a place like heaven, it seems pretty reasonable to infer that, for them, death would seem much better than life. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I didn't really see 6:10 as saying we are insignificant, but that's just me. It seems like there are a lot of times in Ecc. where Qoheleth talks about how we don't have control over our situations, we shouldn't try to change things, etc. I interpreted it as saying something similar to that.

    ReplyDelete