Thoughts on an afterlife? In 3:15-17 Qoheleth makes reference to G-d bringing judgment to both the wicked and the righteous and calling all of their actions into account. On my first read through for the first blog, this was the only mention I remember of G-d justly calling into account the actions of men. Does this mean Qoheleth believes in an afterlife? Not necessarily. This passage is immediately followed by a discourse on the uncertainty on what happens to the soul and whether or not our fate is different from that of the animals (3:18-22). Any thoughts on that?
Chapter 4 finds Qoheleth completely returning to his tone of depression and hopelessness. Qoheleth states that he sees the tears of the oppressed, and how all the power is in the hands of their oppressors. Rather than doing something about this (which he should be completely able to from his supposed kingship), Qoheleth decides that it's better to be dead or to never have been born at all (4:1-3). Remember all that volunteer work you've done? Well, you only did it because you were envious of your neighbor. In 4:4 Qoheleth argues that there's no such thing as a selfless action, and all our labor is hevel. It is better to work with someone else and have a friend than to be alone, because two can produce more and can more easily keep safe (4:9-12). If I had to guess though, the work you do with a friend, while more productive, is still meaningless. Qoheleth finishes out the chapter by saying that a poor youth is better than an old foolish king (4:13). This poor youth has potential to become a great leader, even to become the next king. In the long run though, people won't like him, and his rise from poverty to kingship will all have been, you guessed it, meaningless (4:14-16).
Like you, I have struggled with the beginning passage of chapter three. I agree with Cayce's statement that there is a possibility that Qoheleth is just stating things that have happened and will continue to happen in the future, however, I do think it would be interesting to analyze the passage in a different manner. If there is a supposed time for events such as hatred and war, what does that say about God who supposedly has made everything beautiful in its' time(v.11) and has complete control of the universe(v.14)?
ReplyDeleteI agree that the beginning of chapter 3 seems completely out of context for Qoheleth and I wonder if their is actual truth to the claim that this passage was added later. However, I think that hate and war while unfortunate cannot be avoided and God never promises that he can keep his people sheltered from these acts, sometimes these acts happen so God can show us the beauty on the other side.
ReplyDeleteWow, your interpretation is even more bitter than my own! You seem almost personally upset about Qoheleth's rant. I was also bothered when Chapter 3 explains that there is a time for war and for hating. There is no denying that this is a part of the world we live in. Although, I disagreed with Qoheleth when he attributed this to God. This is probably injecting too much personal opinion on Qoheleth, but I don't understand why he thinks that everything is from God or even why he thinks that nothing is new. I think part of his depression is because he puts all responsibility for everything on God, which makes him meaningless. The reason that the "time for war" is so depressing when Qoheleth says it is because Qoheleth doesn't give people any opportunity to change this. He just says we would be better off dead. I don't blame you for being so bitter towards him.
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure Qoheleth is saying he won't do anything to help the opressed. I think he is merely pointing out that generally, and in that time, people didn't. Also I don't find it odd that Qohelet considers charity to be a striving after the wind. In a perfect world people would be truly selfless, but I feel that in the real world it doesn't seem unlikely for people to do good deeds and hope that they get some recognition. Maybe I'm wrong but I think, especially recently, it has become "cool" to care about the downtrodden and it is for the purpose of being "cool" that most people join charity organizations.
ReplyDeleteThanks for mentioning the time for everything spiel. I also thought it was kind of pointless. I've always read that with a sort of tone mundaneness, but in the context it just seems like he's rambling on again about the pointlessness of EVERYTHING.
ReplyDeleteIn your mention of his belief in the afterlife, I'm wondering what he means when he speaks of where the spirits go. That's my biggest evidence for belief in the afterlife.