In my opinion, the movie (Up in the Air) itself is about finding your purpose and defining what is valuable to you. Throughout most of the movie I would say that Ryan Bingham (George Clooney) was busy occupying his every second so that he wouldn’t have to address the issue of life’s purpose. He didn’t have any valuable people in his life, not even his own family. As the movie continues, however, Bingham is faced with the possibility of being “grounded” for life. I think this possibility forces him to reevaluate his life in terms of the relationships he doesn’t have. During the movie meets Alex Goran, a fellow travelling businessperson, and as their relationship grows he feels compelled to be more seriously committed to her. Unfortunately, Alex is married. I think the fact that they can’t actually be together isn’t as important as the fact that their experience together taught him to value the people in his life. At the end of the movie Bingham, in an act of love and perhaps devotion, transfers his precious airline miles to an account for his sister and brother-in-law. I think this growth from feeling like he didn’t need anyone to realizing that having other people in your life is important is the whole point of the movie. I also feel that it is quite relatable to Ecclesiastes 4:9-12.
I also feel that the movie possibly gives some insight into how Ecclesiastes might be better understood. What is the meaning of all our “toil under the sun?” Perhaps the answer to that question depends on what kind of day you had; who you met, how much stress you experienced, or how you felt. Maybe the reason why Ecclesiastes seems so confusing is because he’s writing different sections at different times. It seems possible to me that a lot of people feel like life is worthless…until they don’t. Ryan Bingham appeared very anti-committed relationships until he met Alex Goran and changed his mind. He spoke at conferences all about how people should remove the baggage of their relationships from their lives. He apparently didn’t think personal relationships were meaningful enough, that is, until he met Alex and found a purpose in them. I think Qohelet could be expressing or possibly journaling his day-to-day thoughts about existence. Maybe some days he feels lonely or bored with his life and those emotions produce the passages that question what it’s all worth. On other days he might have met a beautiful woman at the well and totally changed his perspective. Then, maybe she wasn’t so interested and he’s back to his hopeless outlook. I obviously don’t know the life experiences that Qohelet had but I do think it’s a reasonable assumption that he probably allowed those situations to shape his outlook on life.
I like your ending paragraph about the possibility that Qohelet wrote Ecclesiastes in segments about his daily life. Definitely something to think about in class discussion. I think this is definitely a possibility and I enjoyed your take on both the passage and movie.
ReplyDeleteI am really intrigued (and agree with) your discussion of situation. It could go back to there being a time for everything - depending on the situation, it could be a time for laughing or a time for weeping. This is definitely personified in "Up in the Air," as Ryan Bingham changes his views as his life goes on and he finds himself in a wide variety of situation. I think applying this to Ecclesiastes helps look around the theme of meaninglessness of life and see the text from a different angle, as if it is Qohelet writing in a more journaling fashion.
ReplyDeleteYou made me laugh when you mentioned Qoheleth going to the well and meeting a woman. I like how you brought him down to a human level. I keep thinking of him as a great philosopher. I don't really know why I continue doing this though, because he is obviously just as confused as everyone else. You made a very good point when you said that Qoheleth is influenced by his moods and the activities of his day(s).
ReplyDeleteI really agree with your point about how "people feel like life is worthless...until they don't." You could maybe even argue that unless we have something specific that we find purpose in, life IS worthless, and will only stop being worthless when we find something that is meaningful to us. I think maybe this is how Qohelet feels when he searches for meaning in riches and belongings. After seeking meaning in these things, Qohelet then deems life vanity; however, later, he talks about finding satisfaction in eating, drinking, and enjoying one's work. I think maybe you can relate how Qohelet searches for meaning and finds life to be purposeless until he eventually learns to take satisfaction in simple things to how Ryan seeks meaning in flyer miles and such until he realizes he's missing relationships.
ReplyDelete