Monday, September 20, 2010

Journal of Optimism

Eccl. 9:4-5
“But he who is joined with all the living has hope, for a living dog is better than a dead lion. For the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing, and they have no more reward, for the memory of them is forgotten.”
In his usual fashion Qohelet brings forth a contradiction to what he previously wrote. In 4:2-3 he says “And I thought the dead who are already dead more fortunate than the living who are still alive. But better than both is he who has not yet been and has not seen the evil deeds that are done under the sun.” I’ll let these verses serve as support for the argument that Ecclesiastes was written like a journal in which Qohelet wrestled with the unknown. Qohelet has a near obsession with knowledge and I think at times he grows tired of having it and other times he sees its necessity. In chapter 4 Qohelet talks about knowledge as if it was a curse. It’s as if that day he encountered something terrible or unjust and because of this experience he’s decided (temporarily) that knowledge is something that no man should want. I think his awareness of the state of the world and the evils that exist make him feel that he would rather not know anything which produces verses 2-3 in chapter 4.
In chapter 9, Qohelet returns to valuing knowledge over death. I think it’s important to understand what the knowledge is of in order to compare this passage to previous passages. In 9 he specifically says that “the living know that they will die, but the dead know nothing.” At first it seemed strange to me to place importance on the awareness of certain death but this passage compliments 9:7-10. If people are aware that at some point they will die, they will cherish the moments they have with family and loved ones more than people who live their lives as if they are immortal. Also, it’s too late for the dead. They no longer have the opportunity to appreciate the people around them or their circumstances because they no longer exist. I suppose I can’t help but find optimism in Qohelet’s message but I think Qohelet , like any human, was burned by his life experiences and because of that he searched for meaning and purpose. I believe that what he found was the importance of love (not necessarily romantic) and interpersonal relationships.

2 comments:

  1. I think these verses you're discussing are important because they seem to depict a turning point for Qohelet. In earlier passages, Qohelet emphasized the importance of being remembered after death and then suffered hopelessness at the realization that no one is remembered. But here, he seems to change his mind when he says in verse 4 “but whoever is joined with all the living has hope, for a living dog is better than a dead lion,” (Eccl). I think Qohelet has come to accept that even great kings and wise men or “lions” will not be remembered once they die; therefore, the time to find satisfaction is in life. So, even if one is lowly and unimportant or a “dog,” he or she is better off alive and with the opportunity to seek hope and joy than someone of greatness who is dead.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'm beginning to think that the contradictory passages in Ecclesiastes are just part of his thinking process, he's looking at things from both sides. But Qohelet knows that there is no right answer: "Man cannot discover its meaning," (8:17). I think Qohelet can say that death is good and some ways and bad in others. In chapters 6 and 7 death provided relief from negative experiences, but in this section death ends good experiences but also makes that moments on Earth that the living have more precious: "the living have hope" (9:4) and v. 10

    ReplyDelete